Related: The Office: 5 Times When Jim Was The Bad Guy (And 5 Where He Was The Good Guy)
Over the years, many fan theories have popped up about the Scranton Strangler's true identity. Some even believe that the Strangler is one of the beloved employees of Dunder Mifflin. Toby and Creed are common suspects when it comes to these theories, but could the real Scranton Strangler be an even more unassuming character? Maybe it was simple, music-loving Andy Bernard or even office heartthrob Jim Halpert.