A Man of Sentiment (1933) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Keeping his kindness in spite of the ramifications.
mark.waltz28 November 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Hospital clerk Christian Rub has a heart as big as Europe and finds that it keeps getting him into trouble as he continuously abandons his post to help the patients and visitors who need his aid. He's constantly being threatened with termination by supervisor Lucille Ward who obviously hides a huge heart as well underneath her corset of steel. When William Bakewell comes into the hospital carrying the injured Marian Marsh, Rub goes into overtime helping out these strangers who only encountered each other because a tipsy Bakewell had accidentally hit her with his car. From an almost tragic situation, love erupts, and Rub becomes involved in every aspect of their lives, even though she had been involved with the older and wealthy Owen Moore who is reluctant to give her up.

Bakewell, too, comes from a wealthy family, the son of the powerful Edmund Breese. His mother (Emma Dunn) and spoiled sister (Geneva Mitchell) are suspicious when Bakewell announces his engagement to Marsh, with Mitchell being particularly nasty. The big-hearted Rub continues to act as their guardian angel, especially after a nasty encounter between Bakewell, Moore and Marsh that leaves Marsh extremely despondent. Another termination threat, but you know that won't stop Rub from getting involved in the future.

This poverty row soap opera is engrossing with its sentimental old codger delightfully kind and a reminder that even in the worst of all situations, there are still angels around. Believable performances and some gorgeous sets make this appear to have been more expensive than it probably was. Bakewell has a rather harsh look for a romantic hero, his intensity though perfect for the confused young man who is obviously his family's blacksheep.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Nice Performances, Flabby Script
boblipton28 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
William Bakewell runs over Marian Marsh. It's hardly your standard "meet cute", but he staggers into the hospital emergency room with her, ready to take all responsibility, and they soon fall in love, ready to get married. The trouble is that everyone is against it: his snobby rich family, her former lover (played by Owen Moore) who wants her back; everyone but emergency room clerk Christian Rub, playing Jimminy Cricket instead of Gepetto.

It's a cute idea and setting the "narrating" sections in the emergency room is an interesting concept. Rub is, as usual, a delight. On the downside, however, the parts are underwritten, and people do things in a flabbily motivated fashion. Owen Moore acts like a melodrama villain, showing Bakewell he has Marshal in a back room, convincing him he has her in his thrall, so Bakewell walks out in a huff. When Miss Marsh does likewise, Moore just shrugs his shoulders.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Actress better than her material
suskay16 March 2019
Marian Marsh radiates intelligence and charm as the focal point of this lightweight romantic drama. She and her suitor, William Bakewell, (slightly prissy and stiff but looking like he was carved out of marble) meet not so cute -- he runs her down in his speeding car. The title character played by Christian Rub is a hospital clerk who is a sucker for sob stories. Persuading the driver not to confess to his crimes but woo the girl instead, he sets events in motion. After falling in love over Marsh's hospital bed, the lovers run into obstacles. She is an aspiring musician who was on her way to to accept her rich patron's offer of support, sans marriage, when she was convenently run down (and suffers no aches or pains afterward despite being brought into the hospital unconscious). He comes from a high society family that will not accept her. Edmund Breese is impressive as the hero's easy-going father. Owen Moore is second-billed in the part of Marsh's rich patron-to-be, but he has only a few scenes, which he discharges with freeze-dried wordliness and substantial lockjaw. The early hospital scenes are full of ethnic and sexual stereotypes and some lame attempts at comedy, but they do communicate well the atmosphere of the hospital receiving room, tedium and all. The apparently Jewish landlord of Marsh's building is another matter: a very offensive stereotype. Mildred Washington is delightful in her few moments as a pre-Code housekeeper (you can date the moment the Joseph-Breen-led Code came down in late 1934 by when slim, attractive black actresses were banished from the screen).
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed