7.2/10
308
5 user 2 critic

Are We All Murderers? (1952)

Nous sommes tous des assassins (original title)
The problem of the reasonableness of capital punishment.

Director:

André Cayatte

Writers:

André Cayatte (scenario), Charles Spaak (scenario & dialogue)
Reviews
Nominated for 2 BAFTA Film Awards. Another 1 win & 2 nominations. See more awards »

Photos

Edit

Cast

Cast overview, first billed only:
Marcel Mouloudji ... René Le Guen
Raymond Pellegrin ... Gino Bollini
Antoine Balpêtré ... Dr. Albert Dutoit
Julien Verdier Julien Verdier ... Bauchet
Claude Laydu ... Philippe Arnaud
Georges Poujouly ... Michel Le Guen
Jacqueline Pierreux ... Yvonne Le Guen (version française)
Lucien Nat Lucien Nat ... L'avocat général
Louis Arbessier Louis Arbessier ... L'avocat du tribunal pour enfants
René Blancard ... Albert Pichon
Léonce Corne Léonce Corne ... Le colonel instructeur
Henri Crémieux ... L'avocat de Bauchet
Jean Daurand Jean Daurand ... Girard, l'homme dans la cabine téléphonique
Yvonne de Bray ... La chiffonnière
Guy Decomble Guy Decomble ... Un inspecteur
Edit

Storyline

Rene is not a bright guy. He was taught to kill by the Resistance. But the WW2 is over and he keeps on killing. He is condemned to death. In jail, expecting the presidential pardon, he mets other condemned men. An anti-capital punishment drama, written and directed by a former lawyer. Written by Yepok

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Taglines:

Be prepared for an overwhelming experience!

Genres:

Crime | Drama

Certificate:

See all certifications »

User Reviews

 
We want to live!
30 June 2007 | by dbdumonteilSee all my reviews

That was the second film dealing with justice in France in Cayatte's long career (1942-1978).François Truffaut was always putting him down,but won't you forget ,for a while,the new wavelet and their notorious fusty Cahiers du Cinema ?Cayatte is a name to be reckoned with.

If Richard Pottier("Meurtres" ) tackled euthanasia the same year (1950) as he did ("Justice est Faite")Cayatte was the first in France (and in the world?) to devote an entire film to express his disgust of death penalty.Think of it! It was 1952!It took a lot of guts and a lot of faith to dare such a thing at a time when lex talionis and punishing the criminal as a deterrent to others were the golden rules."What example?" the doctors says "the executions were no longer public as if they were ashamed of what they did"

The first part of the movie may seem weak by today's standards .But it's necessary to introduce René (a never better Marcel Mouloudji)and his background.In his own particular way,he predates Malle's "Lacombe Lucien" hero .One fights for the Resistance,and the other is a collaborator.But both are ignorant poor -René is even illiterate .René lives in a place where "dump" is too beautiful a word.His mother is a shrew who has always had one too many;his sister has been a whore since she was twelve ;his little brother is bound to be a delinquent. Another man sentenced to death has killed his baby girl: but he was exhausted after a hard day of work and as he couldn't sleep because his daughter was crying in their tiny flat he lost his mind.Not a judge can comprehend.Only a woman in a cafe knows better:if that man had been decently housed -just have a look at the lawyer's bourgeois parents' luxury house ,where's there's a "golden dish with every wish"- nothing would have happened cause that depressed man was a good father.

Cayatte puts the whole society on trial,particularly the bourgeois (the lawyer's father just looks up and pretends that he does not see when his son brings the little brother home)In his next movie,"Avant le Deluge" which is to be recommended ,Cayatte would denounce the bourgeois who do not know of the meaning of the word "responsibility".

By its second part ,the movie becomes almost unbearable,even today.Cayatte wanted his movie to be so.Nothing is spared the viewer: the condemned persons cell,where in the small hours they suddenly become frightened :is this dawn THE dawn?Will THEY come?Is IT in the prison? ( the word "guillotine " is never uttered ).Cayatte's directing becomes masterful when he depicts the corridor where a secret ceremony happens early early in the morning.Those men in grey suddenly enter the room and sweetly say "it's your turn ,son!arm up with courage!"

As often in Cayatte's work ,the screenplay is a bit muddled (the Corse episode is a bit too much,but at least it allows us to see great actress Madame Sylvie in two too brief scenes)but until the very end his "hope against hope" will not leave him down.As the lawyer waits for an eventual President's pardon for René ,there's a moving tracking in on his little brother's face .Cayatte does not want to comfort his audience,and this conclusion is the best he could think of.

Time has passed.In 1981,François Mitterrand abolished death penalty in France.One should never forget that men like Cayatte helped along the way .His movie was certainly as important as any of Godard's farces.

Like this?try these....

I want to live (Robert Wise,1958)

La vie,l'amour ,la mort (Claude Lelouch,1969)

Deux hommes dans la ville (Jose Giovanni,1972)

Le pullover rouge (Michel Drach,1979)

Dead man walking (Tim Robbins ,1996)


11 of 15 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 5 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
Edit

Details

Country:

France | Italy

Language:

French

Release Date:

8 January 1957 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

We Are All Murderers See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Runtime:

Sound Mix:

Mono (Optiphone)

Aspect Ratio:

1.37 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page



Recently Viewed