Gilligan's Island (TV Series 1964–1992) Poster

(1964–1992)

User Reviews

Review this title
101 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Mindless tropical fun with an unlikely bunch of castaways
roghache4 May 2006
This is one of a number of highly entertaining and utterly brainless comedies that baby boomers such as myself grew up with. It's based on the unlikely tale of a small tour boat, the SS Minnow, that is shipwrecked during a hurricane while on an anticipated three hour cruise out of Hawaii. Both crew and passengers are left stranded for years on an uncharted tropical island and have to fend for themselves as best they can amidst assorted ill but invariably hilarious adventures. Together they build huts to live in, forage for plants, fish, & coconut cream pies as food, and combine their joint (but woefully less than extensive) wits in order to survive. They hope for a rescue back to civilization, but meanwhile listen to the latest from their transistor radio.

The crew consists of the bossy Skipper, who is invariably at his wit's end dealing with his goofy and bumbling first mate, Gilligan. Gilligan is definitely not the brightest star in the night sky but highly likable. The assorted passengers include millionaire Thurston Howell III, his superficial & society oriented wife Lovey, a sexy Hollywood movie star named Ginger, a brainy science professor, and an innocent young Kansas farm girl called Mary Anne. The banter among this gaggle of castaways generally consists of Mr. Howell's financial schemes, Lovey's lessons in elite manners, Ginger's Hollywood tales, the Skipper ranting & raving at Gilligan, and fortunately every now and then, some survival tip concocted by The Professor.

The actors are all perfect in their roles, including Bob Denver as that endearing bumbleton, Gilligan, and Tina Louise as the beautiful Ginger. I note here that the Skipper's name is actually Jonas Grumby, presumably an indication of his constantly grumbling demeanor.

Various guest stars periodically appear on their island (including a cosmonaut, big game hunter, movie producer, and spies), but never manage to actually rescue these poor unfortunate castaways. It's all pure mindless fun and still infinitely watchable in re runs, with no serious message whatsoever that I can detect. My thanks to that reviewer who enlightened us all as to the first mate's actual first name. And here I thought during all these years that his first, last, and only name was Gilligan!
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
funny, goofy Gilligan..
v-562895 December 2020
I decided to watch Gilliagan's Island for the numerous times Al Bundy from Married with children mentions this show.. And, It is a lot of fun to watch the goofy Gilligan and his fellow stranded castaways in many hilarious situations. Even after those years, it is still a good sitcom.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gilligan's Island
rcj536518 October 2013
All right,so TV Guide rated this sitcom as the top 50 worst television shows of all time,but "Gilligan's Island" does stands out as one of the most maligned sitcoms of the era in a decade that was full of fantasy-themed shows ranging from "My Favorite Martian","My Mother The Car", "I Dream of Jeannie","Bewitched","It's About Time","F-Troop","The Ugliest Girl In Town","Batman","Get Smart","Green Acres","The Beverly Hillbillies",and much more.

Created and produced by Sherwood Schwartz,and originally produced by United Artists Television in association with the CBS Television Network,the series starred Bob Denver(formerly of "Dobie Gillis")as the main character Gilligan along with Jim Backus,Russell Johnson,Alan Hale, Tina Louise,Dawn Wells and Natalie Schafer. It aired for three seasons at CBS from its premiere episode on September 26,1964 until the series finale on April 17,1967. Only Season 1 of "Gilligan's Island" was in black-and-white for 36 episodes that aired on Saturday nights after "The Jackie Gleason Show" at 8:30e/7:30c and had stiff competition against "Lawrence Welk". For Season 2 the network moved the show from Saturday nights to Thursday nights this time in color for 32 episodes where CBS put it at the 8:00e/7:00c time slot opposite "Daniel Boone",and "The Donna Reed Show". For the third and final season the show again moved from Thursday nights to Monday nights at the 7:30e/6:30c time slot for the remaining 30 episodes in color where it got clobbered opposite NBC's powerhouse hit "The Monkees" until its cancellation on April 17,1967(a total of 62 color episodes were produced from 1965 to 1967). Repeats of Season 3 aired from April 19,1967 until September 4,1967. The series ran for a total of 98 episodes.

The reason why "Gilligan's Island" remains a cult classic among the very few? For one,this series was really targeted for kids instead of adults and that what made it so great to this day in recycled repeats. It was based on sophisticated humor. It was silly,stupid and corny but the cast was lovable by all aspects. But speaking of the characters:

You have First-Mate Willy Gilligan(Bob Denver)who was just as clumsy and naive when getting into all sorts of predicaments with those who want to get off the island. Every episode had Gilligan getting into one hilarious situation after another. And for all 98 episodes!!!

Skipper Jonas Grumby(Alan Hale,Jr.) is everything that Gilligan isn't but perfectly capable of taking charge and keeping the rest of the castaways in line.

Thurston Howell III(Jim Backus)is the archetypal crass capitalist who doesn't do any work,and sits around all day talking about money and bonds knowing that his grand ambition is to defraud all the other castaways.

Eunice "Lovey" Howell(Natalie Schafer)is much the "heiress" as she can be.

Profession Roy Hinkley(Russell Johnson) is not the college professor,but in aspects a high school chemistry teacher,but is truly too smart for his own good. He is the only one that keeps the other alive on the island where he can take materials that are wherever resources are available on the island and whip it up in jiffy(imagine making a radio transmitter out of a coconut).

Ginger Grant(Tina Louise)always the glamorous movie star who can seduce the men for information about what goes on surrounding the island.

Mary Ann Summers(Dawn Wells)the naive farm girl from Kansas who can be classified as normal and the only castaway with "common sense" who also tends the island's crops and keeps herself entertained by listening to soap operas on the radio.

The success of "Gilligan's Island" enjoyed solid ratings during its original run,but then grew in popularity during decades of repeats in the 1970's and 1980's in national syndication. The success also spawned two animated Saturday Morning cartoons series("The New Adventures of Gilligan",and "Gilligan's Planet),and three made for TV-movies in he late-1970's and early-1980's,and there are talks of a big screen version based on the classic 1960's sitcom as well.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Full of Fun
JoeErnie17 June 2004
All right, so "Gilligan's Island" may not be "The Dick Van Dyke Show," or any other sophisticated physical comedy show-but all in all it is just pure fun to watch. I remember when I was little watching the reruns on TNT and TBS, and now own the complete first season on DVD. I don't know why it is, but I've always had a special place for "Gilligan's Island," it's one of my favorites. True, you can't take too many clothes on a 3-hour tour realistically, or how in the world can you do everything from build a hut to a lie detector, but can't make a fail-safe raft?

The ratings, in all its three seasons, shone high above many shows; despite the network's attempt of changing the time slot a few times. It beat Bonanza in its first season, and by the end of the third season, it had beat Star Treck, The Monkees, etc. If William Paley's wife hadn't loved Gunsmoke, "Gilligan's Island" would have easily gained at least two more seasons by ratings alone.

If you're looking for sophisticated humor, this show isn't it. It's silly, corny, but the cast is just a lovable one. You can't help but like the series (which is more than I can say for "Green Acres"; which gets annoying after a few episodes). The cast is brilliant in their roles, and the chemistry between Alan Hale Jr. and Bob Denver and Jim Backus' chemistry with Natalie Shcaffer is perfect. All in all, "Gilligan's Island" is just pure clean fun, which is more than I can say for shows on today. Watch it, give it a chance, and enjoy!
58 out of 71 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
After watching even one episode, who wouldn't want to get stranded on an uncharted island, just to see if you could experience what these seven experienced?
lee_eisenberg12 March 2005
I never get tired of watching "Gilligan's Island." As one of the many 1960's TV shows with wacky premises (breaking away from the "Leave It to Beaver" mold of the previous decade), it lives on to this day. At the beginning of every episode, when the theme song begins, I always act out the lines, and then wait for something crazy to happen.

Let's look at the characters. First mate Willy Gilligan (yes, he did have a first name) is the bane of everyone who believes in order and normalcy. Clumsy, pencil-thin and naive, he bungles every chance they have to get off of the island, and yet the other castaways didn't kill him. I guess they understood that he was a good guy under that idiocy.

Skipper Jonas Grumby is everything that Gilligan isn't: fatter than fat, competent and perfectly capable of taking charge. As his weight often is the butt of Gilligan's jokes, not to mention all the times when Gilligan drops things on his feet, the Skipper usually proceeds to hit Gilligan with his hat.

Thurston Howell III is the archetypal crass capitalist. He never does any work, and sits around all day talking about money. I always get the feeling that his grand ambition is to defraud all the other castaways. In spite of all this, Mr. Howell does have one weakness: his Teddy Bear.

Eunice "Lovey" Howell is as much of an heiress as can be. Always the aesthete, Lovey engages in eternal attempts to teach everyone the ways of the elite, but they never get the hang of it. Sometimes, it seems that she and Thurston married for money more than for love. Their marriage is often rocky, but they stay together.

Ginger Grant is the castaway with whom I would like to be stranded. A sultry movie star, Ginger can always seduce the men to get information. Her endless tales about life in Hollywood make life on the island sound not so bad. Ginger's dream would apparently be for Rock Hudson to rescue her from the island...and then some.

Professor Roy Hinkley is truly too smart for his (or anyone's) own good. Still, the Professor is the only reason that they are able to stay alive on the island. Whatever anyone needs built, he can take whatever materials are on the island and whip it up in a jiffy (unless of course anyone needs a raft).

Last but not least, Mary Ann Summers. She is the only castaway who can be classified as normal (and I use that term loosely). A wholesome farm girl from Kansas, Mary Ann tends the island's crops and keeps herself entertained by tuning into the soap operas on the radio. Nothing wrong with her.

So that's the story of the seven Castaways. They've been marooned on that island for over 40 years, and Gilligan's naivety, the Skipper's short temper, Mr. Howell's greed, Mrs. Howell's stuffiness, Ginger's sex appeal, the Professor's smarts and Mary Ann's glimpse into Americana never get old. It's always a riot to see their antics again and again...here on Gilligan's isle!
53 out of 72 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Simple is Good
RNMorton18 April 2003
Probably the best object lesson out there for network executives of the third millennium, a lesson they just DON'T SEEM TO GET - no sex, no hokey "sexual tension", no drugs, no compelling political or social issues. Just good ol' clean American fun. Seven stereotypes deserted on Pacific island spend three years having a good time and botching opportunities to rescue themselves. My nephew knows the details of every episode by heart, but each time I see one I don't think I've ever seen it before. Whatever. This show defines for me the "Mendoza line" for television programming - if it's worse than watching Gilligan's Island I'll pass, which means with 77 cable channels I spend a fair amount of time with the castaways. And Mary Ann kills Ginger...
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Maybe I can find a cashmere tree?"
BumpyRide16 January 2007
This review may sound caustic but I hope I never have to watch another episode from this show ever again. I grew up watching this show in syndication from 1969, then it went to Saturday morning TV, then through the colorized TBS years, past the not so special reunion shows, up until a few years ago watching "The Real Gilligan's Island" movie. I've gorged myself with Gilligan's Island and I've had my share, one can only eat so much cake. I always enjoyed the earlier shows the most, having them building their huts, trying to fix the Minnow only to have it fall apart because the glue disintegrated, hiding from savages in a cave and so on. It was a great ensemble cast with a pretty cool lagoon set complete with running waterfall. I've moved on now, and it's time to say goodbye and farewell. Thanks for the memories little Buddy.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Best Show Ever?
eefan20012 March 2011
If I were stranded on a desert island and allowed only one TV show, it would be "Gilligan's Island". For all it silliness, it's a psychologically complex show. Gilligan screws up every rescue attempt (except for the Don Rickles episode which, interestingly enough, is blown by Ginger)but clearly this is his subconscious working. Why would he want to be rescued? The island offers shelter and plenty of food, so he's in no danger of dying. He's got his best friend, the Skipper. He has a mentor in the Professor. He has parent figures in the Howells (rather strange parent figures, but still parent figures), a fantasy love interest in Ginger, and a realistic love interest in Mary Ann. Why would he want to leave? None of them seem that interested in leaving. Once every couple months, they'll concoct a half-hearted scheme to build a raft or light a signal fire, but overall they're more interested in their wardrobes or putting on talent shows or electing a leader on an island where everyone pretty much does what he or she pleases to begin with... It's a commentary on how man will change any landscape to suit his or her image. Gilligan's motives for staying have been outlined. Skipper is finally a leader (at least in his mind). The Howells love being among people they can clearly feel superior to. Ginger is now the celebrity she always imagined herself being, since her roles in minor movies show she was never A-list. The Professor is totally getting off on being the brains. Mary Ann feels useful and important, probably for the first time in her life, by being the only truly sensible person on the island. The show also comments on man's laziness: letting others do the work. When a guest star arrives the castaways always see that person as salvation, instead of using their own skills to get off the island. This show is awesome. Ginger's gowns alone could be the subject of a book.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Eeeeeehh...
nsequeira-502882 July 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I have a love/hate relationship with this show. First, I'll tell you the good. Then, I'll tell you the bad. This is the good:

This show is a good sitcom, one of the best sitcoms ever made. It has an original premise, all seven characters are unique and complex. This is one of Sherwood Schwartz's gems. He also made The Brady Bunch, a tasteless garbage fire of a boring white bread family lovey-dovey comedy. He made this one first, and I don't know how he could make a good sitcom like this and then go make The Brady Bunch. This one is at least interesting. This one is cool, classic, timeless. It has a good aesthetic. I can't believe Sherwood Schwartz made both of them. This one has some real jokes. This one has conflict.

It's family friendly. My favorite character is probably The Skipper. He's funny because he's fat. Everybody else is also OK. The concept is relatively original, sort of like a contemporary Robinsonade. This TV show is, uh, really good. It's from back when TV was original and fun. I can sit through this sitcom because it's wacky and every episode is different, but it feels real. The colors are vibrant.

Now for the part that I hate. mainly, that it's based off Robinson Crusoe, which was written centuries before this show. Robinson Crusoe was written back when people still hadn't gotten to California. It was written before the age of radar, motors, GPS, or the like. Gilligan's island is set in the present day (and by that I mean the sixties), when finding seven people on an island would be very easy. Thus, the whole premise of the show is absurd and laughable, and is such a plothole that it prevents you from enjoying very much else.

The first episode is the only really believable one. Gilligan and Skipper go out on a raft to try to find help, then give up and end up back on the island. That's the only one that feels as if it's set in the real world. If I was stuck on an island, the first thing I'd do would be maybe try to build a raft and get off the island. That first episode is the only time we see any characters on the water, or trying to get off the island in any sort of way. The first season is the only one that feels all that real. The last two seasons are fantasy. Multiple people get on the island- but they always get amnesia, or something, and never bother to tell the world that there are seven people on the island. It's a bizarre coincidence which I prefer to call a plot device. These seven people never get off the island. Why not?

Do they want to stay there? I don't think they do. They all have lives apart from being on the island. so why don't they ever try getting off? This show, behind all the jokes, is depressing. I don't like watching people suffer. It's not enjoyable. Mr. Howell, in one episode, is revealed to have been rumored to be dead back on the mainland, but an impostor tries to impersonate him and says that Mrs. Howell died on the Minnow. That's Creepypasta level horror. How can seven people just vanish without being noticed? Gilligan might not be noticed- Skipper might not be noticed- Mary Ann might not be noticed- Professor would probably be noticed, considering he's a genius- Mr. Howell would be noticed, considering he's a billionaire, and Ginger would be noticed, since she's a movie star and everything. What sort of universe does this take place in? Seven people disappear, and everybody just thinks they died? Nobody searches for them, or anything? That's ridiculous. It's not even Mary Celeste level perplexing. they're on an island. It's a pretty big island, as far as I can tell- and random islands don't just happen. Most Pacific islands are known about. I mean, they had satellites and stuff back in the Sixties! And airplanes! They didn't have Google Maps, but they weren't barbarians!

But society as a whole isn't entirely to blame for this tragedy. The castaways themselves are just as much to blame. At any time, they could lash together a few palm trees and make a crude sailing vessel- not as good as The Minnow, but just enough to take them back to the Mainland. They act completely helpless. Over the course of the show, they make all kinds of things that real castaways would never need- washing machines, bathtubs, huts that rival huts in Florida- I mean, they can do all that, but they can't make a boat? That's nuts. The island has plenty of vegetation that they could use to get off- but they never do. Are they stupid?

Yes, to some extent. Skipper says that he's good at ocean navigation, but never tries to save them or get them off the island. Gilligan is irritating and immature. Mary Ann knows almost nothing. Ginger is vain. Mr. Howell is selfish and egotistical. Mrs. Howell is just as bad. The Professor is the only smart one out of the bunch, and even he doesn't realize that they could just make a raft, so I don't really have much sympathy for him, either. This is a show about idiots suffering. I don't like idiots, but I can't stand watching them suffer, either. Of course, they're not really suffering- but they're isolated from civilization and they're broken husks of their former selves. This show is really very dark. The show could give a reason as to why they couldn't get off. The trees are all too heavy, and can't float, or the island has no trees, or something like that. Or maybe the island has a forcefield that's invulnerable to radar. I don't know. Just some sort of explanation. There never is any explanation.

But what bothers me most of all- is that this show had really good potential for a series finale. In the finale, they could finally get off the island. In the last episode, do they get rescued? No, of course not. It's just another plot, like all the other ones. Why? If the show was ending, they should have resolved the main conflict- the conflict of them being on the island. That would have been a good ending. it would have wrapped up everything, made it all seem complete. Instead, they had to make a movie about them getting off the island- which isn't good. I just don't get it. If they had ended the conflict, that would be fine- because we'd know what happened to them.

The good? Well, the dream sequences are fantastic- and serve to give the show some diversions away from the setting. My two favorite episodes are the one where they switch bodies and the one about the mutated vegetables. Alan Hale is funny. The theme song is catchy. That's it. That's what I can say about this show. I like it.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A true classic from the golden era of family TV
jefferydhamstra28 April 2020
One of the best TV shows that appeal to literally every age. This show is consistently fun, over the top silly, genuinely enjoyable, and surprisingly smart. The comedy rarely feels dated and with the exception of some very obvious effects often feels fresh enough to have been filmed yesterday.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Why Would They?
PretoriaDZ24 November 2019
The biggest plot hole in the series was the missing explanation of why these characters (other than the Skipper and Gilligan) would be on the boat for this rinky-dink 3-hour tour in the first place. Mary Ann could possibly be seen as a tourist taking the tour but why would Ginger, budding starlet, even be down at the docks. The professor can't reasonably seen as taking the time out of his research and studies for this 'cruise'. Finally, The Howells are reputed to be two of the richest people in the world. They would have had their own superyacht and that would not have been in a sloop anywhere near the Minnow.
4 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An after-school staple now on DVD. Oh Mary Ann my dreamboat!
florida8722 October 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Wow, I have not been following these DVD TV sets closely until just recently. For under 20.00 (plus a rebate on top of that!) to get an entire season of one of my all time favorite shows is a no brainer. Gilligan's Island for me, now a 41-ish man means I watched season two and three ad nausea after school in the 70's, with an occasional season one "rare" treat. Now, I started watching this show when I was at the there is a Santa Claus age and the concept of reruns really had not conceptualized in my thoughts. To me, getting home from school, it was must see TV. Why did I want to watch so badly? TO SEE IF THEY GOT OFF THAT FREAKIN ISLAND! I remember the hours of contemplating, "if only Gilligan had not put that rabbit foot in that robot, oh man they were SO CLOSE!", "If only they had not been coated with those feathers when NASA tuned on its satellite, OH THEY WERE SO CLOSE!", "How could those people leave them on the island, OH MY THEY ARE SO MEAN!" LOL I swear to God this show was more than comedy for me, it was an adventure. It was also eye candy and I mean Dawn Wells eye candy, oh man was she my fantasy (still is!). I blame watching Gilligan's Island for my choice in choosing brunettes my whole life, it really influenced my life! And I can probably credit the Professor (With a healthy dose of Star Trek and Scotty) for making me interested in working in a technical field as an adult (man, TV really does influence youth, I wonder what a generation watching "Friends" will aspire too, LOL!). The comedy was great, but man was it heightened by that sexual tension of 3 adult men and 2 gorgeous women on a remote island. The same thing that I dream of Jennie and Get Smart had before they blew it with marriages in attempts to boost sagging ratings. Going back to season one, the times I saw them on TV (rarely shown when I was growing up), I immediately caught the theme song and my beloved Mary Ann not being included, which was a big turn off. The episodes just didn't seem as funny to me as the color ones but I'll give them another try, for me watching the BW episodes as a kid was doing research, how did they get there? Could they salvage that boat? etc etc, man I really took that show oh so seriously! Even as an elder teen I had to see the TV movie where they finally escaped and man was I on the edge of my seat! Will they make it? Oh please get those poor souls off of that island! LOL. Sorry to hear about Bob passing away, but we all leave someday, and he left a lot of joy in peoples lives and will be remembered for it. THANKS BOB, AND ALL OF THOSE ON GILLIGANS ISLAND! Highly recommended for kids and those boomers who grew up watching as kids, Elites stay away.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A lot of fun.
alexmpw17 February 2018
"Gilligan's Island" was one of my favourite shows when I was really young, and even today I'll catch an episode or two on a whim. Yes, it was campy. Yes, you could leave your brain in the next room and watch it all the same. Yes, it's silly, but that's kinda the point. It was just a series meant to be funny.

That silliness prevents me from giving the series a higher rank, as I was yearning for an intelligent episode somewhere to moderate the goofiness of the show. Oh well, c'est la vie.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A childhood delight; An adult hit-or-miss.
mark.waltz15 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
While perhaps the belly laughs have gone out of a series I've seen every episode at least half a dozen times, there are still smiles, mainly from the memory of the show that surprised not only its network but cast and creators as well with its everlasting value. Certainly, the humor is juvenile, with Gilligan (Bob Denver) and the Skipper (Alan Hale Jr.) a 60's version of Laurel and Hardy, and everybody else on the deserted island with them delightfully lovable foils. Certainly, Natalie Schafer's Lovey Howell could be considered the Margaret Dumont of the series, and Jim Backus's Thurston Howell III so delightfully pompous. Obviously, creator Sherwood Schwartz named him after character actor Thurston Hall who often played uppity businessmen or con men educated in the ways of society, and Backus clenches his teeth together so delightfully in making his millionaire truly "top drawer". But as the Howells get used to those socially beneath them on the island, their easier going personalities begin to take over, with Mrs. Howell obviously a mother figure to the two girls (Dawn Welles' simple farm girl Mary Ann, and Tina Louise's glamorous starlet, Ginger), and definitely a surrogate mom to the bumbling Gilligan who needed mothering much more than the girls.

There are flaws to be sure and 50 plus years later, people are still asking how Mrs. Howell and Ginger had so many clothes for a simple three hour tour and how all that, along with Mr. Howell's trunk full of cash, fit on the teeny, tiny Minnow. Certainly, the castaways utilize their own creativity in making tools and needed equipment from sources on the island, but so many things they have seem store bought. How does one single transistor radio continue to work for years on end? Its need is obvious to create plot developments and warnings for hurricanes which hit the island multiple times over the three year series. For me, half the fun of revisiting this show after a long absence from watching it was guessing which episode I was about to see as the show began, with me usually right, and almost remembering each reaction in the script.

For most of the series, it is only the seven castaways (which also includes the genius professor played by handsome Russell Johnson) and the regular voice of the radio announcer, but somehow, three look-alikes of the castaways find their way to the island. This gave Denver, Backus and Louise a chance to show their versatility, creating confusion when they took over their look-alike's lives. There were elements of science fiction with various contraptions lost by Cape Canaveral and other military sites landing on the island, an encounter with a World War II mine, a Japanese submarine pilot trying to take over, an encounter with an eccentric pilot (Hans Conreid's Wrong Way Feldman) who made several appearances, and even visits to other nearby island, one inhabited by a mad doctor who switched personalities of the castaways, giving more opportunity to expand the talented cast's acting challenges.

More importantly, the show gave an indication of how seven totally different people do their best to get along under often the worst circumstances, with Gilligan often messing up but usually being the one to fix things when they didn't get along. One such episode showed Gilligan revealing how mind reading seeds caused more damage than good, and often, he was the one to fix strained relationships when the others began to squabble. The skipper with his gruff manner but huge heart obviously took a fatherly interest in his little buddy, and Mary Anne and Ginger showed that two completely different women could find a shared interest in working together. While the Howells may have been typical Republicans, they were able to add dimensions to their characters to make them seem less excluding, so you had hope that when each of these people returned to civilization, they would know a little bit more about humanity. It is in that element that the show does not date, even if after multiple viewings, the show isn't as funny as it was when you were a kid.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Once more from the top
Steven-M-Bovard8 March 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Gilligan's Island: One of the most loved and also (strangely enough) often maligned sitcoms in TV history. It was originally run on CBS (1964 - 1967). It must be one of the most heavily viewed programs in the history of syndication. GI was an essential part of the after school ritual for millions in the early seventies. Seeing it so much as a kid left an indelible print on my brain to the extent that, even though I haven't watched the show regularly for the past 25 years, I can still recite some of the character dialog when prompted. A remarkable testament to the effect (for good or ill) of TV on young minds.

The show revolves around the fate of the crew and passengers of the lost Honolulu tour boat--the S.S. Minnow---blown off course by a freak storm onto "an uncharted desert isle".

Most of the episodes center on the "seven castaways" efforts to get off of the island and back to civilization. The attempts are always sabotaged by the bumbling first mate of the Minnow --Gilligan (Bob Denver). I like the skinny and young Denver as Gilligan -however the characterization works only on a rather limited basis marked by age and appearance. Put 15 years and 15 pounds on Denver (as was done in the reunion movies) and Gilligan's antics become almost intolerable. The Skipper (Alan Hale Jr) is seen by some to be a gruff authoritarian figure--however I see him as being much more benign (Alan Hale's natural affability comes shining through). I believe that Gilligan and the Skipper come across most of the time like "Mutt and Jeff" rather than as "Laurel and Hardy".

Jim Backus and Natalie Schaefer playing Thurston and Lovey Howell (The millionaire and his wife) are the most accomplished members of the cast. The Howells are played for all they're worth by Backus and Schaefer. Both actors were masters of the ad-lib. I especially like one laugh line Thurston Howell III gets as the castaways listen to a radio broadcasting the launch of a test missile that the professor calculates will hit and destroy the island. The radio announcer does the countdown... then crows, "And it's a perfect launch!"-- "It would be...," says Howell with bitter, comic resignation.

Ginger--the movie star--seductress, red head (Tina Louise) & Mary Ann (Dawn Wells) the virginal, wholesome Kansas farm girl, brunette--certainly set up the eternal question of preference among the male viewers of the show. For my part... either girl would do in a pinch. Tina Louise does a creditable imitation of Marilyn Monroe -I would bet heavy money that the character of Ginger holds the TV record for the sheer number of come-ons made by a woman (always for ulterior motives and never for sex). It's to Louise's credit that she made all that flirting seem real and in context and always in bounds. Sweet, little Mary Ann is a much more incidental character and the only character in the show that is played "straight" most all of the time.

Russell Johnson is first rate as the Professor---the island's resident intellectual / technician. He has a good laugh line in one of the episodes when the other other castaways wax nostalgic about what they miss the most about their previous lives back in civilization--the Professor suddenly pipes up: "What I miss most is Saturday night at the library....the hustle and bustle at the reference desk...." .

It has been pointed out by more than one deep thinker that the "Castaways" are meant to represent "archetypes" of humanity. I am certain that the character types and the casting contributed much to the success of this show. The casting is so critical because the setting for the series (an otherwise uninhabited tropical island) is not the most promising for a situation comedy (which is the reason no doubt for the many strange visitors that find their way to the island--everyone from a World War One fighter pilot to a rock band to a mad scientist to an exiled South American dictator-to a dozen others).....

I mentioned at the beginning of my comments that Gilligan's Island is often abused by critics. It received bad reviews from the the very first show and there are plenty of people who have continued to hammer away at it through 5 decades down to the present day-(Did anyone else see Larry King make Bob Denver squirm when he was a guest on Larry King Live a few years ago?). Gilligan's Island is generally attacked for being comedy of a very low variety--dumb and unsophisticated and marked by a noted lack of realism (How is it that the Howells brought so many clothes along for a three hour cruise?---Why can't the Professor figure out a way to get them off the island if he can make a generator out of a coconut? And why doesn't anyone sleep with anyone else? etc...) I will concede that the overall tone of many of the episodes is slightly juvenile. (The most avid perennial viewers of this show would have had to have been 9 - 11 year old boys). However, that said, it's never been proved to me that Gilligan's Island was any more unlikely in either premise or execution than any number of its contemporaries. Contrived characters and situations have always been a hallmark of American network TV from the beginning --all the way, arguably to the present ---but that's another subject. I can find at least some jokes and situations on GI that contain more social and political comment and present sex in a way more realistic than can be found on Dick Van Dyke (as an example).

Sherwood Schwartz and the show's cast and writers must be given much credit for creating a unique version of an escapist fantasy---that has...like it or not...found a place in American pop culture.
21 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good fun
charlesachapman4 June 2022
It's not meant to find plot holes in, and it's not based on a true story. It's a lot of silliness, but a lot of good exploration of the human spirit. Definitely an after school favorite.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Ridiculously Fun, and Never Boring...
fearfulofspiders7 September 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Gilligan's Island is a show anyone from age 4-100 could watch. Of course, people have varying taste, but to those who have not been introduced to this nice show, do not know what they're getting into.

The episodes are fun and funny. Slapstick plays a major key-role in the comedic style of this show, but there's also some subtle stuff as well as in-jokes.

The acting is great. Every character is casted perfectly, and some of the performances are so over-the-top, it actually fits in and adds to the atmosphere.

There's nothing vulgar, which makes this great for kids. Some of the first season I believe is in black and white, which to kids, can be a slight turnoff. This is a very friendly show.

The various antics and mishaps are hilarious to watch, be they from concept or full realization.

Overall, I highly recommend Gilligan's Island to anyone with a great sense of humor. With a wonderful cast, funny episodes, and great premise, this is a show to watch in the morning as you eat breakfast.
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"No Man is an Island unto Himself;" and that goes Double for Sitcoms!
redryan642 January 2008
A Quantum Leap in the Evolution of the Sitcom. Honest, really, no sh*t! Little old GILLIGAN'S ISLAND! It's considered to be much funnier than NOVA.

Jerry Van Dyke has often mentioned in his appearances on our Late Night talk shows how he had turned down the Title Role of Gilligan, but had accepted the lead in "MY MOTHER, THE CAR"(NBC, 1965-66). Oh well, HE moves in mysterious ways; for thanks to the Good Lord for allowing that questionable career move, or we may not have had the pleasure of Jerry as Luther Van Dam, Asst. Football Coach to Craig T. Nelson's Hayden in "COACH" (1989-97).

To comment on the Gilligan phenomenon, we first should take an overview of the TV Sitcom.

Born out of necessity, following the shot gun marriage of the old silent and sound two reeler Comedies and the Radio's Comedy series. The Sitcom has been with us ever since the dawn of commercial Telecasts in the 1940's. (The first commercial TV stations were licensed in 1940, but development of the medium was delayed by a little event called World War II.) Some of our earliest series were THE BUSTER KEATON SHOW (1950) ,THE COLLEGE BOWL (1950-51) with Chico Marx and the HANK McCUNE SHOW (1950-53). Hank who (?), we hear you ask.

We couldn't find a more obscure name and title if we tried, but on his show, Hank McCune initiated a feature that was found to be an indispensable tool and an outright necessity to all of the comedy series that would follow. And that invention would be the use of the "technically augmented audience reaction", the Recorded Laugh Track.

So when the GILLIGAN show hit the TV screen via CBS in 1964, the Television industry had some 15 years or so experience in producing these "ha-ha-ha" sitcom shows that they surely did some studying of what flew and what bombed. Slowly, some variation began to show. Some were successful and others were canned early, their innocuous plot lines and characters to spend their lives in a sort of Limbo of forgotten series.

GILLIGAN seems to have done things just a little different. First of all, there were seven (7), count 'em folks, seven regular characters, and everyone was worked into the stories each week. Of course the 7 castaways were the only people on the Island; if one doesn't count the hundreds of temporary visitors who had come and gone their way, week to week.

In any play, be it live on stage or a filmed episode, be it comedy or any drama, there is a certain need for exposition and having the story line propelled along its way. So that in a sitcom, each scene should serve some such purpose; and be there not just making for funny dialog and situations. (If you think that there is no such thing as trying to be too funny, just watch an old silent film of comedian Larry Semon.) Once again in getting back to GILLIGAN'S ISLAND, we contend that this series made an additional improvement on the use of the short, little comedy vignettes. In the GILLIGAN Show, the little scenes are devised to bring all of the characters into play, one or two at a time. They also made use of comical situations to move the story along. But they were fashioned in a manner so as to be able to virtually stand on their own without the rest of the story. (Not that there would be any call for a 3 to 4 minute comedy film!) The other achievement of the Production Staff of GILLIGAN'S ISLAND is one that they most probably did not accomplish on purpose. And that would be (My Theory) that in fashioning the short scenes in this manner, almost always using regular characters well known to viewers, have created the celluloid equivalent of the Daily Newspaper Comic Strip. This strong similarity in form and literary device is most apparent in comparing GILLIGAN to the 3 or 4 panels of daily strips like: MUTT & JEFF, BRINGING UP FATHER (Maggie & Jiggs), BLONDIE, BEETLE BAILEY, MOON MULLINS and even PEANUTS (with good ol' Charlie Brown.).

Otherwise, the series ranks very high on the all time list of the Situation Comedy and was the subject of several "back-to type of Made-for-TV Movies as well as animated series of "THE NEW ADVENTURES OF GILLIGAN.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Just Sit Right Back And You'll Hear A Tale
mateovillamayor21 December 2020
What Happens If You Mix A Clumsy Sailor A Skipper A Couple of Millionaires A Movie Star A Professor And A Kansas Farmgirl One Of Thr Best Shows Ever Made Of Really It's Like A Sitcom Family Friendly Version of LOST But Better Yeah Is Really Fun To Watch This Show And If You Like SITCOMS And Castaway Stories You'll Gonna Love It
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Guilty Pleasure
atlasmb10 March 2019
Talk about suspension of disbelief! This show is implausible on many fronts, but somehow is very watchable. It can't be due to the quality of the comedy, because doofus Gilligan provides the crux of most laughs, on an elementary level. Somehow this show is greater than the sum of its parts
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Gilligan's Island Crew
jmlclassic20 June 2017
Of all the TV shows that relied heavily on the principal actors of the show, Gilligan's Island sure beats many if not all shows for casting. The members of the shipwreck was ingenious as to who was aboard. But really the typecasting for the parts is what sets the show apart, elevates it way above many other light, comedy shows-and even some dramas. The actors are just what you would expect the characters to be, magnificent portrayals. The script, the setting, the story line-all take a back seat to the actors playing their parts to perfection. It is #1 on my list of shows that need watching just to see the roles enacted in the most excellent way. For any aspiring actor or actress, they would do well to watch the 'pros' on Gilligan's Island for the model in character acting.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Skipper- You Take Ginger, I'll take Mary Ann
DKosty12317 August 2006
Yes, this is the longest 3 hour tour in the history of boating. Some of the episodes with dream sequences get almost to the theater of the absurd. No, it is not the perfect series. All in all, though, it has the most absurd premise & the most talented cast you could ask for put together at the right time & the right place that it is still an enjoyable time being stranded.

The real inside joke is the way Ginger (Tina Louise) is playing the vamp, while Mary Ann (Dawn Wells) is the real beauty. Dawn, if you ever read this, I have been in love with you since the first time I ever saw you in this. Of course, my chances of ever really loving you are no better than a lost episode of a rescue made in 1967 ever showing up but I dreamed of you often when I first saw these shows & still wonder what it would have been like to have been intimate with you.

Of course, I'd have thrown you out for Barbara Eden (Jeannie), but if I had really ever had a chance to get her bottle, I'd have had her blink you off the island with another full season of episodes on NBC in 1968. Actually, everyone in this series was at the top of their careers.

Bob Denver also was Manyard G. Krebs & he was one of THE GOOD GUYS too, but this is his best work. Alan Hale was the son of Alan Hale Sr. & did a lot of other things, but his work with Denver was his best. Jim Backus was a good comedian & the voice of Mr. Magoo, but this is by far his best work he will be remembered for. Natalie Schaefer & Russell Johnson plus the girls had their best work here. Tina Louise was foolish to disown her heritage of this show as there is nothing else outstanding in her career, here was her apex. At least she didn't cost herself money while the show was running by walking off. I haven't watched any of these in a while, but now that the DVDs are out, you never know when I might just make another tour.

The scripts go from far-fetched to impossible. The relationships drawn between the characters is the glue that holds it all together.

For the time being, I have escaped from the island, but you never know, if they remade this today, should it star Johnny Depp & could he pull this off like Bob Denver? Ahoy ye scarface pirates, there is no plunder here, just escape from the rest of the world. When the first shows ran, there was a sense of isolation. Then the sit com went on to explore imagination and frustration.
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Top 3 for me, all time
airstrivemusic23 October 2022
Gilligan's Island will always be a life saver for me. As a confused young teen I would come home from middle school, make a bowl of cereal, laugh through the episode and then feel sad when the final theme would play at the episode's end. So much more than a show, these characters were my friends. I laugh at the bad reviews of people who take themselves (and the show) too seriously. My faves all time are 1) MASH, 2) Friends and 3) Gilligan's Island. I also love Star Trek, Cheers, Quantum Leap (the original), Mad Men, and Dexter. Gilligan's Island will simply always be a top 3 show for me all-time. Absolutely no apologies.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Junk television that was actually good
ThunderKing67 April 2021
Gilligan's Island was a fun, relaxtainment show. The acting and stories were engaging. The set was obviously fake but it looked better than the cgi infested shows that we have today.

Verdict: Classic show and it only needed 3 years to become an iCON. The Big Bang Theory was on for like 12 years and that show was hash.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
A Lame-Brained Comedy - Short On Laughs & Way Off Course
strong-122-47888522 January 2014
To me, Gilligan's Island is a prime example of just how totally asinine TV Sit-Coms were back in the mid-1960s. When it comes to utterly stupid and completely predictable situations, this dumber-than-dumb TV show certainly scrapes the absolute bottom of the barrel for laughs, which it never produces.

How this despicable, totally unfunny program actually managed to last for 3 successful seasons defies comprehension. It should have been immediately canceled right after its very first episode.

I think that Gilligan's Island's biggest and most damaging deficit was, of course, its #1 star, Bob Denver (as Gilligan), a bona-fide buffoon whose low-brow, dimwitted antics produced nothing but groans of annoyance and exasperation from this here viewer.

And regardless of how desperately the talentless scriptwriters of this badly-conceived show tried to dangle plenty of eye-candy in front of my face, this didn't, in any way, compensate for the clear lack of genuine comedy that definitely rendered Gilligan's Island virtually without a pulse and pathetically anemic.

P.S.

If you were to ask me, I'd swear that the Skipper and Gilligan were secretly sweet on each other. (nudge-nudge-wink-wink)
11 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed