John sticks up for Dexter and Gene when they are profiled and arrested for just standing around outside a theater, but his tirade gets him arrested also.
John's old drunk acquaintance Jefferson Kelly (played by David Cassidy) shows up rolling down some stairs to the station floor. John decides to help him dry up.
John is shocked to see a topless photo of his daughter (Mayim Bialik) in Playpan Magazine. She then makes a surprise visit with her boyfriend who has taken a vow of silence.
Carly introduces her millionaire boyfriend, who has an unexpected connection to Dexter. Meanwhile, John and Catherine flirt with the danger of possible break-ins.
To check items off his bucket list, John tries skydiving and visits his childhood home, and surprises ensue. Catherine displays her vocal chops, and Hampton does a sit-up and receives flowers.