"Trial & Retribution" Trial & Retribution III - Part One (TV Episode 1999) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Melodramatic
smartinezmd19 March 2022
...beyond belief. I sense that Richard E Grant is an exceptional actor; however, the writing in this episode is staggering at times. Over-the-top melodrama and, therefore, implausibility. The first episode of this entire series - thus far - has been the best and seems to be winding its way down to an abysmal outcome. I blame the writer and the producer and, possibly, the director(s) - all the actors are usually stellar in their performances; however, they have inept writing here to deal with. It's hard to believe that the series made it for so many years. The same series in today's airtime would not fare so well. Fortunately.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Hard to get past obnoxious lead character...
mallaverack16 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
....because Det. Walker portrayed by David Hayman makes you want him to fail completely to solve any case whatsoever. Honestly, if a 'boss' treated his subordinates with such callous disrespect you'd cheer if one of them resorted to smacking him in the face! There is nothing to like about the leading investigator in this series. Which makes it even more implausible why D.I. Pat North has become romantically linked with this cretin and in this opening episode has actually made him her live-in lover. As if this opening to Series III doesn't contain enough rat-bags and over-the-top shysters. Richard E.Grant a man with bipolar disease is for the most part genuinely nasty, except to D.I. North whose initial response to Grant's irrational behaviour almost beggars belief. And then there is the witness to a sighting of a missing teenage girl whose very appearance conjures up characters from a Monty Python series. When will scriptwriters in particular realise that not everybody who walks this earth is a humourless ratbag, a brainless idiot, a crass and obnoxious git, etc. It is so obviously true that an entire series without somebody with whom the viewers can empathise or just like a little lacks great merit or appeal. I'm pretty sure Lynda La Plante's novels were not as bleak as this TV series...hard to think that she acted as producer?! Don't know whether I'll make it to Part Two!
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed