Lily wants to participate in the beauty pageant of Grampa's Knights' Lodge in order to feel special, so Sean has to join the Lodge for Lily to be eligible. Claudia becomes fixated about Lily winning and Eddie about the Lodge's secrets.
Sean is subbing for his friend Gary as a limo driver for 2 weeks and finds unexpected side benefits. Lily is told she's not Yale material like Brad but still manages to get herself an interview. Eddie coaches Jimmy for a school play.
Brad & Lily's anniversary is coming up and Lily has a wish list she gives to Brad. But Brad wants to surprise her. Sean gets a notification from the Home Owners' Association but he decides to defy them. Someone has a dark secret.
Eddie's ex Crazy-Amy has hit pay dirt with nude photos of him, so Sean makes Eddie to try to sell the bar to her. Jimmy is filling in for Brian, the injured male cheerleader. Claudia makes preparations for the baby.