My Shakespeare (TV Movie 2004) Poster

(2004 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Uplifting Insight into the Creation of an Unlikely Stage Show
MITCH!1 January 2006
I just happened upon this on our local PBS channel and was transfixed.

Baz Luhrmann acts as the omniscient adviser to directors everywhere hoping to create a meaningful stage experience, using an inner-city rendition of Romeo & Juliet as the case study. Juxtaposed with Luhrmann's insightful explanation of a director's craft is the making of the project itself -- a West End production of Romeo & Juliet, performed by actors with zero experience who've been chosen off the streets of an inner-city London neighborhood.

Clearly, director Paterson Joseph is biting off more than most folks would presume he could chew, but the documentary does a magnificent job of detailing his process, challenges and creative (and sometimes difficult) solutions to the evolving problems. Many of the cast are spotlighted individually, and their growth from curious pedestrians who answer Paterson's question, "Have you ever read any Shakespeare?" to confident would-be thespians is fascinating. Despite having never directed a performance before (!), Paterson rides the tumultuous wave of highs and lows through to an end that likely exceeded his own expectations as surely as it exceeds that of his cast.

Paterson's grace and wisdom should inspire anyone seeking to create in any art form. Truly recommended for artists of any persuasion, or anyone who doesn't believe in "impossible."
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Though documentary leaves out important information, you get caught up in these people's lives
arcticcarrot31 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This documentary follows actor Paterson Joseph as he directs a production of Romeo And Juliet using non-actors from the poor neighborhood where he grew up. Film director Baz Luhrmann serves as a mentor to Paterson, though only by remote hook-up. We see the casting process, and learn a bit about each of the actors who get cast. For example, Muska Khpal, who plays Juliet, is from Afghanistan and wants to become a doctor. (During the first section - the casting process - there is a lot of annoying music playing.) Paterson has lots of trouble at first. The actor who plays Benvolio is constantly late. And all of the actors have trouble tapping into their emotions. The actors at first basically all say they don't understand any of it. It's interesting that when it comes to the fights, their personal experiences play a large part. Jonathan Taylor, who plays Romeo, has actually been stabbed in a fight. They have an easier time with anger than with love. As a documentary, this film fails to answer some basic questions. Like, how did Baz Luhrmann become involved? Also, a fight choreographer and a vocal coach are brought in. Were they paid? Were any of the actors paid? How were they able to rent the theatre? But once the film got going, it managed to pull me in emotionally, and I actually was anxious for them as it got down to the final rehearsals. Paterson has the actors do an emotional workshop to help them, because these folks are used to hiding emotion. He also takes the leads to a graveyard to rehearse the death scene. Some of the cast goes to the new Globe Theatre, and this trip clearly inspires them - it's actually a great scene. And we do see sections of the actual performance, as well as some of the celebration afterward. So though this film has a shaky beginning, and doesn't provide some basic information, it ends up being quite satisfying. I came to care about these people.

By the way, I'm in the middle of a three-year Shakespeare study, and I've posted a blog entry with reviews of a dozen or so film adaptations of Romeo And Juliet, as well as short blurbs about books related to that play. If you're interested, the site is Michael Doherty's Personal Library on blogspot, and the entry is titled "Shakespeare Study: The Tragedy Of Romeo And Juliet."
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A rare piece of "reality TV" – uplifting, enriching, enjoyable and constructive for subjects and audience
bob the moo31 January 2005
Patterson was born and raised in the rough area of Harlesden, London and, since becoming an actor, has decided to return to his streets with the message of Shakespeare. Setting himself a target of four weeks to cast, rehearse and direct a West End production of Romeo & Juliet, Patterson plans to show the world that Harlesden is not what people assume and prove that Shakespeare can be brought to any place, any people and any time by using a cast of all first time actors. In the background director Baz Luhrmann looks on and offers Patterson advice on how to bring Shakespeare alive for modern actors and audiences.

I am not a big fan of reality television; too much of it either makes celebrities out of people with no talent other than a talent for appealing to the tabloids, while other reality shows seem to be more about holding their subjects up for ridicule with a vague aim of somehow helping them or teaching them lessons. So when I heard of this project last year I did fear the worst but I am very happy to report that this film manages to do what so many reality projects fail horribly to do (if they even try) and was uplifting, engaging and, most importantly, constructive for subjects and audience alike. The concept sounds like a gimmick and indeed there is a risk that it could have been as a collection of innercity stereotypes (baseball caps, hoodies etc) are brought together to do a Shakespeare play that many of them just dismiss from day one, but it holds you while it is like this and then builds to something much better.

Luhrmann has limited input but he is important at the start because he is very interesting while the production is yet to grip us. As the roles are cast then Luhrmann is less interesting and the real people and the production becomes fascinating. The challenge of the play itself is gripping and it is great to see how the young actors develop not only as performers but also as people. Khpal is a great example – coming over as shy, insecure and giggly at the start she becomes so much more confident and her performance has a real sense of wonder about it that she carries in rehearsals and in herself. Many of the cast come on – they say at one point that they don't show emotion "on the street" but then the rehearsals seem to bring them into touch with deeper feelings. It is actually enriching to see it happen and I felt it constructive to me personally just as they found it constructive; this is a world away from the seedy mocking of "How clean is your house?" and all the better for it.

The whole cast are likable people and quickly rise out of the ghetto stereotypes that they come across as at the first few times of meeting them; it does go to show that, although stereotypes have an element of truth to them you stick to them at your peril. Among the rough ethnic teens is a middle class, well spoken mother of two who we assume will do the best but, in reality, she cannot cut it and is removed from the production, meanwhile Taylor becomes more and more emotive and confident, coming across as a great Romeo and a really nice guy. In a genre (reality TV) that often just pigeonholes, mocks and generalises it was so refreshing to see stereotypes being challenged.

Overall this is a wonderful show. I'm not sure if I want to see the idea repeated because it was so perfect here that I think it stands by itself. The people involved are stereotypical baseball cap wearing youths who challenge our preconceptions while also developing as people and actors. The production is amazing considering the challenges involved in time and tools and the whole experience is as uplifting, enjoyable, enriching and worthwhile for the audience as it was for the people taking part. A fantastic piece of "reality television" that is miles above the dross that is in that genre – hunt it out, it is really, really worth seeing.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Teachers- see this movie
segolily6221 January 2009
I saw this movie in one of my college Shakespeare classes. I was so impressed by the concept and the subsequent performance. I have recommended this movie to other English teachers as a must-see. It will rekindle their enthusiasm for Shakespeare. It is a wonderful movie to show in class, since seeing others succeed at Shakespeare is excellent motivation.

The director in this movie is the kind of person we all aspire to be; one who brings out the best in his actors. The movie was a realistic portrayal of the troubles and triumphs of performing Shakespeare. My favorite part of the movie is that the actors really didn't think Shakespeare was for them, and then did an excellent job.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed