"Mannix" To Kill a Memory (TV Episode 1972) Poster

(TV Series)

(1972)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Twists & Turns
telegonus23 March 2021
To Kill A Memory is a Mannix show from roughly its mid-way point in its eight year run on the network. The controversy over the Vietnam war was cooling down somewhat; there were fewer student protests; and long haired young men were't harrased so much by middle aged adults in most parts of the country. The times were a' changin' in 1972, not maybe Bob Dylan's way, but they were.

This episode deals with (as they used to say) relevant issues, but it offers no point of view of its own regarding the mental states of soldiers returning home from in Vietnam, especially those who'd seen combat. There's one at the center of this story, and he's enigmatic in his early scenes, doesn't recognizes many people who were close to him when he was younger, is a puzzle to his family, goes by a name different from the one how was born with; and he suffers from amnesia and flashbacks to his fighting days in Southeast Asia. In other words, he's in trouble.

As the story unfolds, there's way more than meets the eye to this traumatized individual, as his tale is told Impressionistically, in twists and turns, We learn about this young man, Alex, in a typically TV series style; while Aex learned about the previous four years of his life in twists and turns, He also learns a few things about what happened during his years abroad from some unsavory characters who are drawing him into a life of crime, and this is where Joe Mannix and his detective skills come into play.

It's good to mention here that Mannix was hired by Alex's family after learning that he was still alive, as they were unsure of his whereabouts given that he was officially reported as dead. This helps makes this somewhat confusing episode and what happens in it a genuine mystery story rather than a more crime focused one, although indeed a major crime is committed, so it plays fair with the viewer at both ends. To Kill A Memory is one of the more dramatic entries of the series, and the excellent cast of skilled players were up to their jobs. From my end of the spectrum, the ending feels a bit bland for such a heavy hitting (in all respects) slice of prime time from a half century ago, Some solid workmanship went into it, and in that, and in so many other respects, it's a winner.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Very good ep with superb acting but it should have been 2 parts
belanger7526 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
America underwent a big internal turmoil fighting the mass-murdering North Vietnamese forces of Ho Chi -Minh. (Ho became a highly brutal killer with his 1950s land reform in Vietnam!) This Mannix ep capitalizes on that very internal conflict that the country and many of its servicemen and just citizens alike suffered due to Ho.

As to the story it opens up brilliantly with Martin Sheen and John Vernon leaving an airport. Sheen drifts off alone onto a bus that almost first ran him over. He takes the bus and goes to his home where his widowed dad Ford Rainey and Sheen's beautiful wife Pamela Shoop live together along with her brother (also a former serviceman who fought against Ho). Skip the brief first time meeting in a long time between Rainey and Sheen.Once there Sheen claims to have amnesia. They call in Mannix to find out where the previously declared dead Sheen has actually been.

Sheen, Shoop, Rainy and Vernon all turn in absolutely great performances in this. Catch this episode on DVD over and over again it is worth it.

(The other poster is wrong on much. Like that talented legendary actor John Vernon indeed played good guy on a TV show in Canada about a pathologist fighting crime.)
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
THE ACTORS RULE, ESPECIALLY MARTIN SHEEN.
tcchelsey16 September 2022
Sutton Roley was brought in to direct this high adventure, and with super credits like RAT PATROL and VOYAGE TO THE BOTTOM OF THE SEA. Roley did it all.

That said, "To Kill a Memory" is another story that gets a bit complicated, though there are some TWILIGHT ZONE-ish moments. It boils down to a case of amnesia, concerning lost Vietnam vet Martin Sheen who doesn't know who he is --and was killed in action? What exactly happened to this guy?

Despite all the twists (victim, patsy or straight into the strait jacket) this story will definitely keep your attention. John Vernon (as Thompson), a class act villain, is always the one to watch. Likewise, there's Ford Rainey as Sheen's old pop. No one better to play the adult in the room. Popular 70s actress Pamela Shoop plays Jan. Shoop guested at the time in NIGHT GALLERY, MOD SQUAD, ROOKIES and the FBI. She achieved cult status as nurse Bailey in HALOWEEN II. Her father was a distinguished general, long associated with Howard Hughes.

A lot of moving parts here, but worth a look for Martin Sheen, who is outstanding. At the time he was also appearing on CANNON. Arthur Weiss wrote the story, a veteran of MISSION IMPOSSIBLE.

The opening chase scene and explosion is Classic Mannix. Note the closeup shots of Vernon, at his most ominous. A treat.

Keep the late night coffee brewing. SEASON 6 EPISODE 7 remastered color CBS dvd box set.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Completely far-fetched--even for "Mannix"!
planktonrules14 April 2015
"To Kill a Memory" is certainly one of the most far-fetched and silly episodes of "Mannix". So if you've only seen this one, try another--they're not all this bad!

The show begins with three guys arriving at LAX. One of them, Dan (Martin Sheen) looks kinda goofy like he's been bopped on the head. He claims he's okay and goes to get them a cab. Instead, however, he stumbles onto a bus and ends up going way across town! Here he stumbles onto a ranch where everyone knows him--including his father and wife. But he has no idea who they are or who he is!

Instead of calling the police, the family contacts Mannix. This is because the missing guy was in Vietnam and was declared dead! They want to know what's happening before they contact the authorities. Interestingly, the family knows him as Alex!

This film has a lot working against it. The amnesia and PTSD angles are overused and here there are so many confusing gaps. There also is the brother-in-law whose involvement in the robbery and the amnesia/PTSD wasn't clearly defined. Did he sell his brother-in-law to crooks? If not, how did he know to contact them when Alex/Dan showed up at the house?! Additionally, Dan/Alex's 'friend' was John Vernon--a man who NEVER played good guys, only crooks, jerks and scum-bags!! Add to this the ridiculous robbery (involving the most amazingly complicated and James Bond-like gadgets) and you've got a silly and confusing mess of a show. The ending, by the way, is even worse....don't get me started on that!
11 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
After viewing this, you might want amnesia
Guad4218 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I tried to like this episode but couldn't get there. Dan/Alex (Martin Sheen) arrive in LA with two associates. He ends up at his family ranch in Palmdale. At least that was on the bus destination marquee, so I guess the ranch was there. He meets his dad, wife, and brother-in-law, Harry. Dan/Alex and Harry were in the same unit in Viet Nam. They know him as Alex and he was supposedly killed in battle two years prior. Since he can't remember any of them, they call Mannix to sort this out. Alex remembers stray facts like "Duke" and an address. Joe goes there and meets the people who came into the airport with Alex. They are going to rob a diamond merchant and Alex is their alarm guy. Skipping ahead... They try to kill Joe and miss. Alex gets in a wrestling match with brother-in-law Harry, hits his head and remembers he has an appointment with his robber friends. Harry lets him take his car to get to the appointment because he wants to get rid of him because Harry abandoned him when he was wounded. The diamond robbery starts. Mannix and Harry arrive. Harry goes for the cops and Mannix intervenes. He kills all three robbers and saves Alex. Alex now remembers what happens and forgives Harry. The end.

The cast is alright. Sheen played a lot of mixed-up characters back then. In five years, he would go back to Viet Nam with "Apocalypse Now". Ford Rainey was a TV veteran. Pamela Shoop had a long career. John Vernon had a longer career.

Lots to complain about here. The biggest is the in-and-out amnesia of Alex. He can't remember his robber buddies, takes a slight head knock and remembers everything while forgetting his former identity. Also, how he got out of Viet Nam and to Hong Kong makes one wonder. Just too many shortcuts to make any of this believable.

Well, one thing still works. Peggy can do her phone voodoo to get information, even on Sunday. Joe gets paid - another good thing. You can skip this one with no great loss.
6 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ludicrous from start to finish.
daniel-kyle18 December 2021
I won't bother to re-hash the plot. Perhaps someone thought to take a ripoff of The Manchurian Candidate and have it make no sense.

There are a slew of heavyweight actors in this episode, which is the only reason that I even give it a few stars, since they try their best to make the most of the thin, bizarre material. By over-acting.

And it is bizarre. Ludicrous from start to finish. Completely illogical.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
The sheen is tarnished
pkfloydmh14 November 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This one is about a family of a Vietnam veteran hiring Joe to find out where he was for the last two years since they thought he was killed in action two years ago but has unexpectedly come home.

The veteran is played by Martin Sheen in his one and only appearance. John Vernon makes his third and final appearance and of course he plays the villain as usual. He doesn't play anything BUT villains.

There are lots of plot holes and loose ends and also some lunacy. Alex has amnesia but yet he was able to remember where his family's house is, remembered the meeting with Thompson, remembered Thompson's name and address and all of his associates' names and remembered how to disarm the alarm. Wow, incredible! All this while he has amnesia. And how did Joe know that the office Alex mentioned was Thompson's office? Then there was no explanation provided for what Harry's motives were for associating with Thompson, and at the end, there are no police on the scene and no guns pointed at him, but yet Harry simply confesses to Joe for no reason that he's involved with Thompson and then actually starts working with Joe to find Alex. It's all just a huge mess and can't be taken seriously.

There's some appalling and over-the-top acting by John Vernon after his character is shot at the end, which is further proof that nothing can be taken seriously here.

There's lots of mumbling by Martin Sheen, Ben Piazza and Pamela Shoop and all three are difficult to hear at times. There's also some dreadful overacting by Martin Sheen and Ben Piazza and the constant flashbacks to Vietnam are really irritating.

This is quite a fiasco, with plot holes, loose ends and bad acting all converging into one big train wreck. It's obviously one of the worst episodes of the season.
3 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
RIDICULOUS
amolad-116 March 2024
Yeesh. This episode is ridiculous, even for an episode of Mannix. Martin Sheen is wasted. So are good actors like Ben Piazza and Ford Rainey. John Vernon is playing his typical "I'm a bad guy" character that, at least, makes more sense than his character in "Point Blank" who didn't make sense at all.

There were many episodes of Mannix that were entertaining, but not this one. I don't know how much they've pulled out of this episode for syndication, but it could not have helped.

The whole thing makes no sense.

The flashback Vietnam scenes look totally like Southern California.

You'd be better off watching an episode of Hawaii 5-0.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed