While helping Sarah prepare for baby Hope's baptism, Johnny becomes involved in a murder case. The case involves a young woman and the demonic possession of a young priest, where everything isn't as it seems. Meanwhile, Sheriff Turner is still investigating Walt's past. She discovers a hidden bank account and the purchase of a lake house during which she inadvertently lets it slip to Sarah about Johnny's vision about Walt's last day.
- When Sarah's baby, Hope, is at her Catholic confirmation, Johnny receives a vision about the priest performing an exorcism. After several more visions and a later discussion with the priest, Johnny determines that a junior priest, Father Tony, was the one receiving the exorcism.
A short while later, when a local woman is discovered to be murdered, the two suspects are Father Tony and her husband. After gathering more clues, Johnny is unsure about who actually committed the murder, and Father Tony is arrested. But Johnny's visions, while accurate, have not revealed the entire story, and things are not what they seem.