"Electric Dreams" The Hood Maker (TV Episode 2017) Poster

(TV Series)

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
19 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Telepathy in a dystopian world
Tweekums20 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This, the opening story of this series of unrelated stories based on the works of Philip K Dick, is set is a world where telepathy is a reality and the 'Normals' who don't have these abilities are not happy with the 'Teeps' who do. Our protagonists are Agent Ross, a Normal, and his new partner, Honor, who is a Teep. We are introduced to them as Honor 'reads' members of a crowd to spot those who are really dangerous; one of them is wearing a strange mask and she can't read him at all. Ross chases him down and it emerges that somebody is making these hoods which stop Teeps reading the wearer's thoughts. Ross and Honor set about finding the eponymous Hood Maker and in the process Honor learns an interesting truth about her partner that makes her question whether she can trust him.

In many ways this story feels like a chapter in a longer story; we are not told too much about this world before the story gets started and the ending feels like a cliff-hanger before a next episode that will never come. Some may find this a little frustrating but I didn't particularly mind. I liked the grim, noirish, post-industrial look of the story and the protagonists were interesting characters; Richard Madden does a fine job as Ross and Holliday Grainger really impressed as Honor. The story was intriguing and deeper than one might expect for something only an hour long (including adverts). The conflict between 'Normals' and Teeps was well handled as it was hard not to feel sympathetic to both sides. Overall this was a solid start to this series; I hope future episodes are as good.
29 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A promising dive into Philip K Dick's world
TheDonaldofDoom18 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Never had a chance to read any of Philip K Dick's books so this was a great chance to step into his world. It's drawn comparisons with Black Mirror, and no doubt the similarities are there, but Electric Dreams very much has its own style. Electric Dreams is harder to directly link to the present but still leaves lots of issues to ponder about after the credits roll.

The Hood Maker is an excellent start. Like Black Mirror, it's a realistic and not-too-distant future. There's a lot going on, tensions between normals and "teeps", humans that can read minds. They are used by the state to control the masses and prevent an uprising, a true progression of 1984's Thought Police. In the fantastic opening scene, telepathic Honor is seen reading protesters' minds to let the authorities know which ones are the biggest threats. She can work out people's reasons for protesting by looking inside their minds, enabling the authorities to crack down on them with ease. It's not so simple though, as people are getting hold of hoods to block the brain signals from reaching Teeps. What's so great about this setup is that none of the characters are evil; they all have their motivations for doing what they do. The teeps are shunned by society yet are used for their abilities and the hood maker sees himself as doing the right thing in helping people resist the state's encroaching on people's thoughts.

Parallels can be drawn between this story and current events, such as how governments are more and more interested in reading what you say privately online, especially in the UK where the Snooper's Charter allows the state to read your most private messages. Will it one day be possible to read your thoughts? "The Hood Maker" is a success because it explores these concepts that we've all thought about at some point and it does so in a way that lets us come to our own conclusions. The open-ended ending may annoy some, but it does manage to wrap the story up nicely.
25 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"Protection should be democratic. So should knowledge."
classicsoncall18 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
When Philip K. Dick wrote his original stories, this one in 1955, he could not have imagined the extent to which technology has become such a big part of our lives. In this episode, the government's Clearance Division has enlisted a 'Teep' to partner with a 'Normal' to identify subversives who might lead an uprising. Not unlike the government today pressuring a global company like Apple to unlock the phone of someone who's considered a terrorist. There comes a point though, when the honorable intentions can be turned against the very citizens it's purported to protect. That's when we get things like an 'Anti-Immunity' bill to provide cover for actions that might otherwise prove to be illegal. When you take all this into consideration, then who are the good guys and who are the bad guys? Unfortunately, this episode doesn't reach a resolution between the fate of the principal characters, or the larger question is appears to posit, that is, insuring an individual's freedom of thought. I don't think it gets easier from here.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A fantastic re-imagining.
jcain163515 January 2018
Keeping up with the other episodes I have seen, the acting, atmosphere, and technical aspects here are all at their best. What sets this story above the ones I have seen so far, is that the characters are gripping and well developed, and the ending not only makes sense, but has the nerve to avoid giving you exactly what you would want. I am beginning to like the idea of re-imagining PKD's stories rather then giving them literal adaptations. My second favorite so far next to "Human is". Give it a watch.
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
I'll give this Series a chance
dncorp17 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Was not exactly what I imagined. Really could have done much better.

Really dislike the unwatchable dark scenes, of putting a dark filter over the camera lens. Do not know of anybody that likes that "effect", of literally being kept in the dark.

The description is inaccurate. As should be, Law Enforcement starts using Telepaths, to read minds without permission and interrogate detainees.

The Public starts to go against Talepaths, and even developed a Hood to block the Telepaths mind reading abilities.

Unknown to his Telepathic Partner, the Detective has been trained to block her Telepathic capabilities.

Maybe the next Episode 1.2 will be better.
18 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Who Are the Bad Guys?
Hitchcoc19 January 2018
I think there are a couple failings here. One has to do with the history preceding this episode. How did all this come to be? Give us some sort of milieu to work within. Once we have telepathy, there are factors that need to be addressed. How does one put in filters in a mind that is not a machine? Do they occur naturally? Also, when we reach a stage where there is utter bad on both sides, who are we sympathetic toward? This seemed endless at times and I have to admit I never understood the point. If it was simply that telepathy takes away our humanness, that would have worked. But I'm not even sure that's it.
11 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Surprisingly satisfyingly
Zythean17 September 2017
Keeping in mind there are still 9 episodes to come, all with completely stand-alone stories, so far it seems this might be a new masterpiece to keep your eyes on! Throughout the whole episode I felt like being swept away by the story. The story was brought to life by a lovable cast, great sets and decor lots of mystery and questions in the story line to demand your attention and tickle your desire to keep on watching.

As I want to keep this review spoiler free, I can only urge you to watch and be (hopefully) positively surprised, just like I was. I am really looking forward to the next episode with a new story, new cast and new director. If they are all gonna do a tribute to Philip K. Dick's work as done in the first episode, the next ones are also gonna be really satisfying!
22 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Hood Maker
Prismark1019 September 2017
It has been said that this is the strongest episode of Electric Dreams anthology series. This does not bode well then.

There was nothing too special about The Hood Maker and the dark, grungy look of the dystopian society was just off putting and very much a cliché.

The visuals might had been inspired by Blade Runner but the story was more reminiscent of Minority Report.

The police use Teeps, who are special telepaths to read people's mind and the public are not happy as it is an invasion of their privacy. Special hoods have been created to block the telepaths.

Honor is a Teep but her new partner Agent Ross is someone she finds hard to read. This is a relationship based on mutual distrust as they hunt for the hoodmaker.

The story is a parable of modern times. The influence of government snooping, anti terror legislation etc. It just a shame that the episode was too po faced and drab.
11 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Makes no sense
subtext-4189716 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I personally couldn't stand this episode. The story is trying to make you feel sympathy and outrage for the the telepaths being held down and forced to live in poverty while the people desperately trying to keep their own thoughts private are portrayed as one-dimensional monsters. Everyone who wants to not get mind raped and puts on a mask to block out the telepaths also turns into a sadistic psychopath lol. So the people who mind rape are really being persecuted by not being able to mind rape everyone? That alone is a pathetic attempt to reverse the normal psychology of victim/oppressor often found in scifi.

Also I can't imagine how you could be expected to buy into these telepaths living in poverty. They'd be ruling the world and everyone else would be helpless victims desperately trying to survive in a world where every thought they have can be exploited at will. The masks should be a symbol of revolt against an oppressor who dominates because they can. I think the story just tries to be too clever and spin logic on its head but loses any sense of logic in the process. At the end the telepaths get sick of being outcasts and start destroying everything around them indiscriminately which only further shows that they should've been the bad guys in this story. If the story was structured to show there are no bad guys/good guys and both sides have merit I'd get it more. This story tries to make you side against the poor fools getting mind raped though and I can't imagine how that makes sense. By the end I didn't feel bad for the telepaths any longer, I was left thinking they needed to go lol. I felt bad for the normals who had no defense against these people except the hoods which no one seems to think should exist. It's like trying to make it seem that people with pepper spray to deter rapists are horrible people for not letting the rapists do their thing. Just abhorrent story telling..

Also like everyone else said, way too dark on the camera filters. Reminded me of watching Tim Burton without the cool quirky stuff that makes it interesting. Episode 1 is garbage.
32 out of 57 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The best of a pretty bad batch
RogerBorg17 January 2022
I'm being rather generous with the rating here as this is the best made and produced episode of a weak series that I've averaged out to a 5, with too many below that.

It's less reliant on a surprise twist-to-the-twist premise and is instead written and shot to stand on its own merits as though it's part of a larger milieu: if feels like a pilot for its own series. Not a great series, not one that would get greenlit, but still slicker and more confident than the rest of Electric Dreams.

The characters have actual personality both in their writing and performances. For once, the lines feel more than just straight exposition, and Madden and Granger have some effective chemistry, this time thankfully unmarred by unnecessary and tawdry flesh grinding. However, I could have done without Madden using his actual accent, which to a Scottish ear sounds like Ned gutter trash.

The budget is also well spent on creating an alternative dystopian near-past using well dressed sets and some small crowd scenes, a sharp departure from the barren, hushed and deserted feel of the other episodes. The creative director clearly put some thought into this and films it carefully to give the impression of a bigger budget production, helped by an effective score that compliments but doesn't over-sell what we're being shown.

One nitpick is that the premise has been skewed slightly from Dick's original to make the teeps more sympathetic than sinister, but the core dynamic of the relationship is preserved, and it's decently presented.

If I were going to recommend an episode of this series, it would be this one, but don't get your hopes up, it's all downhill from there.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Dystopion dysfunctional K Dick.
domesticatedprimate18 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The first episode was a massive disappointment for me, It was the first time in a while i actually struggled to get to the end of a TV show. The story itself was bad enough but when you factor in the bad acting that is sometimes cringeworthy (not really helped by the ridiculous outfits they're made to wear) It becomes almost un-watchable. There is no indication to me that this show is set in the future other than the unconvincing words from the actors themselves, The whole set was cramped dingy rooms in which they'd replaced every bulb with a yellow one and then proceeded to film the whole thing with a dark brown filter, there you have it that's your convincing "Dystopian future". There's also a few moments that make little sense whatsoever, One in particular at the beginning during the riot. They were set upon by a mob of angry citizens fuming at the latest trend of mind reading taking this small city by storm. One local hoodied hoodlum unconvincingly throws a molotov cocktail that lands nowhere near them yet they still manage to pull off the dramatic dive to the ground before staring into eachothers eyes for a few painfully long seconds. But that's not the most senseless moment of all, No! that comes a minute later after the "agent" gives chase to the hoodies villain, hitting him with small leather bag that somehow leaves a bloodied mark on his face. After he comfortably subdues the villain someone greets him, who could it be? Oh it's the mind reading girl that whole mob of civilians were trying to get at, How on earth did she suddenly easily bypass this mob? were they left there still mobbing away doing their mob stuff before one confused mobber turned around to the rest to querie "hey, Where's she gone?". What on earth did i just watch?
16 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Hood Maker
bobcobb30110 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
If this episode was any indication this show is going to be very politically-driven as we could easily see the parallels with this episode and the perceived vision of President Trump's take on foreigners.

It wasn't great, this is not Black Mirror or Twilight Zone quality, but it was a somewhat entertaining premise. The show needs to give us a twist though. There wasn't much of a twist or a big ending, it just went as expected.
3 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Different
iwilladvertise10 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Each episode is different which is nice for a change. Always futuristic. Some stories are slow to the plot. Not gonna spoil anything because it is worth watching, however, Amazon needs to fix the order of the episodes either on this site or on prime. They aren't in the same order.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Its cant even compare to the novel
tau_poppa29 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This episode a kind of an origin story of the novel and this is why its story doesn't makes sense at all. If people of the society didn't shared their thoughts and telepaths not even on the high level at the police why would the hood maker made the hoods? To prepare for what? To make civil war to a powerless minority? Also missed the HUGE plot twist compare to the novel. Acting was just ok, scenery, mood and costumes were great but the desing of the "hood" was ridicously lame...
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Confusing and Boring
MovieHead12310 June 2022
This episode was the most boring of all. Were the teeps a different species? Where did they come from? Did they have neuro typical parents and were born that way due to a change in the environment? This episode never answers that. Instead, it left me with more questions than it provided me answers. Aside from the confused mess, it was also incredibly BORING. If you haven't seen this episode and want to watch it because there are only ten episodes in the series and want to watch all of them, prepare yourself to be confused and bored. Don't say you weren't warned.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
[5.5] A hopeless future
cjonesas9 September 2021
A complex slow episode like a distorted work of art.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not one good idea in over 50 minutes!
okami_ito18 March 2019
Unbelievable dull. A lot of drama is anticipated. There is actually not one single original thought or emotion found here. Cinematography is sub part, too. Just a big yawn is all you get.
3 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Disappointing start to the series
Tomniboos25 September 2017
I'm a big fan of Philip K Dick's work so was looking forward to this series. Anthology series generally open with one of their stronger stories and on that basis this is a worrying start. The acting was dry and the script dull, some reasonably well known actors appeared weak working on this. I rarely give up on a TV episode when I start one but this one pushed me to my limits.
6 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not sure what I watched.
moreall24 September 2017
Having seen this episode, I can only hope the rest gets better. In my opinion it was too dark (I get the feeling darkness in a movie/TV show is usually designed to hide the poor scriptwriting). Too quiet ( Straining to hear speech). And too slow. As I said hope it improves, will give it another couple of episodes.
10 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed