"The Sinner" Part VIII (TV Episode 2017) Poster

(TV Series)

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
15 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Healing process
aslisonceley12 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This final episode achieves a convincing possibility of forgiveness of self and others. The show arrives at this point through very complex layers of events and reasoning entering Cora's mind. What's great is that the show avoids villainizing Cora's perpetrators cartoonishly. Instead each character is studied in a psychoanalytical perspective. Each violent or malevolent action holds a valid reason, and some amount of internal righteousness which lets characters justify their choices. They are vulnerable to their circumstances, and lose a sense of making the right choice.

Secondly the show achieves a clear link between Harry and Cora's distinct characters. They are related by trauma inflicted by others, resulting in behavior that relentlessly blames self. As the season progresses we witness Harry, trying hard. We watch him work with discipline and creativity at his job. Although he is the hardest worker, he is also the least confident at and celebratory of his achievements. He does not simply want to get the job done and close the paperwork. He wants real resolution. Finding relief for Cora is meaningful for finding relief for his own neurosis. It proves hope for him.
16 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Amazing dramatic, emotional drama!
chazken-1437225 June 2020
Shockingly, powerful and emotional drama. I salute Jessica Biel for her amazing and brave performance. The young actress Nadia Alexander, who plays her vulnerable but very brave sister had me in tears at the end. Note I watched the first season on Netflix.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The truth got lost in the missing past!
Reno-Rangan24 February 2018
SEASON 01:

I did not think there's more to come just after watching episode one. When the crime had happened, I thought that's it and what might follow is could be a simple courtroom drama. Then episode after episode, the tale had started to take twists. Especially detective Harry Ambrose was the one turned it all. With his detective instinct, the story kept growing suspense till the season finale.

The 8 episodes are a short season. What was once called a mini-series. But it was great to keep the plot tighter. Then each episode being 45 minutes long, the overall season did not have sufficient pace to go forward without a drag. Usually that's how the series develops its storyline. So there's nothing bad about it, just it took its time to come to the point. Obviously saving the best part for the final.

A mother has been arrested on a murder charge. She knows she's guilty, so not making any further complication in the court. But a detective working on that case does not agree it all. He decides to dig deeper into that case for something, a reason, particularly from her past. Without seeing any success, it drags a bit. But towards the end, the twist brings all the changes the tale needed just before the conclusion.

Based on the book of the same name. Biel is a decent actress, but her recent feature films are not making any buzz. This is her television entry with a bang. It is one of the best crime-drama-mystery. Definitely not a masterpiece. On a common sense, it's utterly a nonsense. But it was good in the entertainment aspect. I hope this mystery ends here itself. What I want in the season two is about her two years of stay in the prison. About her struggle to get over those periods. But there's no news yet about the next season. Meanwhile, it is surely one of the best series of the year, which means you should watch it.

7.5/10
21 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Just binged season one in 2 evenings
mysprouts-740-81385628 April 2020
It deeply affected me. As someone who's trying to recover lost memories, it was a powerful show. Coras memories are so deeply interwoven because how she was raised affected her decisions that fateful night. And she takes ownership of those decisions, so we the viewer know she will be ok. The detective however, still has more story to tell. Looking forward to season 2.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A very good season 1!
Irishchatter19 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Jessica Biel did such a great job at playing as a character who has dealt through a lot of crap in her life and has Bill Pullmans character assisting her to get the justice she really needs to get her own life back. I gotta say lads, episode one was such a shocker and I'm glad that we were able to see Biels character finally get a happy ending. Watching 8 episodes of this season was so addicting, now we move to season 2 and see how it goes for the other person!
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
S1: Engagingly obtuse in how it unfolds, even if it is a bit too overwritten in some ways
bob the moo9 March 2019
It was being rewarded a second season that brought this show to my attention, otherwise I had never heard of it nor really what it was about. Playing out as a whydunnit, we are left in no doubt about the violent murder that brings the first episode to life, but why it happened is a mystery. We follow a troubled cop as he digs deeper to identify motive or root cause. Mostly it is an engaging narrative as we unfold memories and mystery, finding out more about the lead character in a mix of partial revelation, and flashbacks. Unusually for American television, it is a short run of episodes, and it has a decent pace through them - never moving fast, but giving enough in a sharp way to keep the viewer moving with the material.

As a whole it is well constructed, leading out of a convincing character, and into an oddity that keeps you watching to see how it ends. There are plot holes, convenient writing, and other issues with the way it plays out, but the pace and general air of mystery keep you watching. Having just watched Sharp Objects, it did strike as interesting to see another famous actress starring and ex producing in a show that draws so much from a toxic religious maternal relationship, but it was only a curio as a side note. This core construct though does give the show a real base to work from, because you can see the destination and the start, and the rest feeds in slowly over the episodes. That this is convincing and engaging means that some weaker aspects of the writing are covered or carried, but there are other strengths that do the same.

The style of production, the editing, and other technical and aesthetic aspects help this too, as it is well constructed in these ways. The performances are the main reason it works though. Biel is great in the lead; she sells her character's confusion, fear, and general sense of deserving whatever comes even though she doesn't really know why. Pullman doesn't have as much to work with, although he does well with what he has - but mostly it is his quality that makes more of a role that could have just been generic and lost behind Biel. The supporting cast are solid throughout in different roles - no obvious weak links.

It does have problems in the writing, and in the way it plays out, but overall the mystery, pace, cast, and production standards all carry it to be better than these. Not sure I would follow Pullman into a second season, but certainly the first season was worth a look for what it did well.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"Pain" is the sister of "Joy..." under this roof called "Life!"
hamidullahgenc3 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
From the establishment of the science of Psychology and the emergence of the Cinema in the late 19th century, these two cooperated to benefit each other.

It may be in a surreal imagery (Un Chien Andalou - 1929), or in a subconscious panorama (Le Voyage dans la Lune - 1902), or in a sustaining horror (Nosferatu - 1922).

In fine, this is what this relation seems like in the early 21st century in the form of a series called "The Sinner."

It might not be best at keeping the viewer interested in and concentrated on the story. Well, it might even have been a bad idea to do flashbacks that divide the story between million pieces that results in not confusion, but distaste for the viewer.

Sure, Mr. Bill Pullman keeps it up with his somewhat interesting, life-like performance, and Ms. Jessica Biel suits the role more than she knows (only if she knew and tried a little harder), and Mr. Christopher Abbott proved that he can do better in time so that he has a strong talent / face for drama.

Where the show paints itself into a corner is that it has a good intention of pointing out the drug / alcohol related abuse along with the family abuse; but it abstains from revealing / or at least hinting at the obvious problem that kept us going... that is the mind control, conspiracy of the monarch program... etc.

Hey, we would not have wanted any of these evil occurrings and doings. But clearly, they left the story to our imagination from time to time... and the result just would not satisfy us. Not in a "biblical" way. (I am not of a Christian culture. But it felt like a good instrument to explain a (Christianity based) cultural /American product.)

So, the show would pace between the genius and the par...

Lastly, one could claim that we suffer from freedom... of letting the ego get the best of us. This world has but little... to ensure the happiness of all. So, death takes dear Ms. Phoebe too soon?.. The show makes us think like that?.. Well, not all of us... One could claim that there is more... A better world. The real and eternal world. One without the evil whisperings of the ego furthered by the Devil... The Paradise.

Sorry. We humans get carried away... Forwhy the pain of Mr. Bill Pullman and Ms. Jessica Biel touch our hearts with sorrow.

"Mankind were one community, and Allah sent (unto them) prophets as bearers of good tidings and as warners, and revealed therewith the Scripture with the truth that it might judge between mankind concerning that wherein they differed. And only those unto whom (the Scripture) was given differed concerning it, after clear proofs had come unto them, through hatred one of another. And Allah by His Will guided those who believe unto the truth of that concerning which they differed. Allah guideth whom He will unto a straight path. Or think ye that ye will enter paradise while yet there hath not come unto you the like of (that which came to) those who passed away before you? Affliction and adversity befell them, they were shaken as with earthquake, till the messenger (of Allah) and those who believed along with him said: When cometh Allah's help? Now surely Allah's help is nigh."

The 213th and the 214th Verses of the Chapter (called the Cow) in the Gracious Koran; so believe I.
12 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Quite the Overlap
Hitchcoc31 July 2023
So much happened along the way that I'm overlapping Parts VII and VIII. Of course the former is the story of how Cora gave her sister Phoebe one night of joy, even though it was in a den of criminals. She and Cora and planned to be normal for a long time. Unfortunately, she was mistreated after death, as we find out later. There is great tension.

Then we have the trial. Harry manages to break up a drug ring but it does nothing to help Cora's case. She is sentence to 30 years. Harry has one last chance. A glance at a sign in an empty storefront gives him thoughts about seeing one more person. That person was thought dead for a while. This leads to an un-peeling of some wallpaper at a suspicious home. There are some really complex undercurrents that are revealed and some blackmail. While Cora must answer for her crimes, there are some mitigating issues with the judge. It is a bit contrived, but the ending is satisfactory. Harry is left sad but hopeful.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A great season
mslulucao16 April 2023
Unlike some reviewers, I think the pace is perfect. All the "boring" stuff are very important pieces of the puzzle. The pace makes me follows Cora's steps, looking for the lost memories with her, and untangle the clues to a straight storyline.

From the very beginning, I see how great the main character's performance is. As someone grew up with trauma, I immediately recognized Cora's resistance to sex is related to trauma. That's next level acting.

The storyline surprised me. I thought there will be a clear villain, but in the end it's just a series of mistakes made, with intention to protect. It's beautiful when Cora forgave the people she said sorry to earlier.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good story
elkhiyarimeriem12 April 2020
I really liked the story but the show was so slow. Some details were unnecessary like the detective's life.. I think they could make the show in a 2 hours movie
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Mostly amazing.
nananow18 February 2022
I agree with many of the earlier reviews. This series was much too long; but my feeling by 4 hours. The sex was gratuitous, especially the incest was totally uncalled for and disgusting. It might have been seen as artistic, but actually just smut imo. Bill Pullman obviously was a survivor but pathetic. He has the pathetic demeanor down cold, but went too far beyond credible. His need for punishment was grisly , most of which we could have done without. The fact that he was able to glean out the victim in Biel makes total sense in the real world. I too like that they didn't make the villains rotten, just villainous. Biels husband was the star I believe. The state LEO was laughable and both sets of parents cracked beyond repair. Of course, I'm headed for season 2 now!
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
So incredibly slow and doesn't make sense
jimmietee23 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
So she thinks it was the best thing to happen to Phoebe but she murders the guy that was having sex with Phoebe when she died. What a slooooooow series and Jessica Biel is not the actress to pull off a complex character. Mom thought h They ran away so made up a lie and told cops her daughter died. Seriously? No. Nothing just n. This "drama" makes any sense.
6 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Stellar performances
IPyaarCinema9 March 2022
Review By Kamal K

I really enjoyed the complex storyline! And the twist was mouth dropping! Also very touching I kinda got emotional through the end when everything was unraveling.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Season One Review
southdavid1 February 2019
When unhappy wife and mother Cora (Jessica Biel) murders a man who is seemingly a stranger, in a frenzied attack on a highly populated beach most of the police seem happy enough with the slamdunk conviction. One officer Harry Ambrose (Bill Pullman) just can't let the case go though and is convinced that there must be more that meets the eye.

I suppose, my lingering feeling about this first season of "The Sinner" was that it was "alright". The performances are really good even if there's not really anything new or endearing about any of the characters. At eight episodes, there was about the right amount of plot to keep me interested but I'm glad it didn't run to any more. Content wise, it was a bit of a slog and I'm not sure that I'd really recommend watching it because of that. There's clearly an ordeal that befell Cora that we're going to find out about. As it turns out, what actually happens is a bit nicer that what I was anticipating.

Views on the second season to follow in due time.
7 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
final episode wraps it up
mathomas-2805320 September 2017
This excruciatingly boring series was not, thank heaven, extended into a second season. The final episode actually wrapped it up, and was by far the most watchable of the eight episodes. Only the central killing was explained; Bill Pullman's strange attraction to his ugly dominatrix was not. (I hope THAT'S not the hook for season 2. Ugh.)

This whole story could have EASILY been told in two hours. It was a feature-length movie at best; never a mini-series. 90% filler crap.
19 out of 105 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed