Shéhérazade

The film nails its colours to the mast right at the beginning. We see immigrants from Algeria arriving in France (not a hijab in sight), the slums and shanty towns they are lodged in after their arrival and then the dreadful council flats and tower blocks finally provided to them. I've seen this type of place in the cités (ghettos) - huge structures teeming with crime, drugs and violence. It's a vicious circle as employers won't even employ someone with an address in the ghetto so there is no way out except for crime.

I speak good French, but I had to watch this with subtitles; the accents were authentic as was the slang and I'm too old to keep up with that these days and French from Marseilles is different from what I learnt in Paris and the north. I just caught half of what the kids were saying. The only scenes I could follow completely were in court or with the examining magistrate when the officials were speaking in "correct" French and the youth attempting to do so. So, for anyone who is not French or who hasn't been living in France for many years, I'd advise the subbed version despite some of the nuances being untranslatable.

The kids reflect the chaos of their upbringing and where they grew up, but there is an added, unpleasant element, namely the admixture of perversions of religion, particularly Islam, added to the equation. Girls are despised especially if they are not virgins and if they are prostitutes, they are beyond the pale and fair game for anyone. Gays and transvestites are worse and Zach justifies his revulsion of tranny Zelda by referring to god. It's a complete dichotomy because these kids are shown as totally amoral in other contexts yet they stick to a twisted set of religious values when it suits them and they clearly don't know the true values that Islam espouses.

The feeling of the film is one of drift. They drift through life, Zach drifts into pimping, they drift into and out of relationships. Money, although it's the cause of the criminality seems almost incidental at times - what's it for? It's just to be blown on expensive presents, nights out or flash vehicles. Their lives are lives of reaction. They react to the Bulgarians, Zach reacts to what happened to Schéhérazade, he reacts to the insults after the court case. There's no direction in these young lives.

It's an entirely bleak vision but one that held the attention. The running time was longish but I wasn't bored for an instant. There were moments of real tension when I was on the edge of my seat and, honestly, my heart beat a bit faster on occasion. I had had this film for a month or so before watching and I should have seen it before, it was that good. I'd recommend this strongly.

I'm not really one for love stories, but this one has an edge and tells a good street-story. Definitely worth watching.

It was hard to get into it this world right off the bat. I had moments I wanted to wander off. Very specific, tough lives. But the realism and the natural magnetism of the actors kept me in.

The one motorcycle sequence which shot in a single movement is more effective than many action movies I've seen lately. The courtroom sequence flows with a matter-of-fact rhythm and holds a lot of great tension. This is the denoument of the social commentary. The characters, especially Sheherazade grew on me quite a bit in the end.

I write while I'm moved after seeing this great movie. A jewel of modern neo-realism very well done, editing, photography, dialogues and above all the performance of the young protagonist are really excellent. The gangster story in the first two acts is really tense, moreover full of desolation and misery. The surprising and courageous ending, on the other hand, tightens the heart and leaves room for true love against all expectations, against the will of all, at the high price of suffering the consequent repercussions. A redemption that proves to be the only way out. the salvation that projects the boy to mutation, to adult transformation.

There is no way anyone who hasn't grown up in France can understand the nuances this film offers. So much is in the language and in the delivery that you can't understand through subtitles.

Having grown up in the 20eme of Paris, the slang and accents hit home and truly carries this amazing film.

If you think these kids are trying too hard, it's cuz you don't have the perspective of where these kids come from. Everything in this film is genuine and true to the way minorities communicate in the inner cities of France.

If you care about French film, this is indispensable.