Dune holds a special place in my heart as one of my all-time favorite books that has never received the same level of mainstream attention that the Star Wars universe has, which is some sort of cosmic irony considering how much Star Wars lore owes to the Dune novels and also to Jodorowsky's Dune. (Disclaimer: I am an unabashed Star Wars fanatic. Please don't take this as a slight towards my favorite fandom). Much like the Star Wars vs. Dune conundrum when it comes to popularity, Denis Villeneuve is one of my favorite directors who holds a special place in my heart because he has made a lot of great movies that unfortunately haven't been box office sensations. Another modern director that he often gets compared to is Christopher Nolan who unlike Denis not only makes great movies, but has had a lot more financial box office hits. While I am extremely happy for Nolan especially since I rank him high on My Favorite Directors list, Denis Villeneuve continues to bring out the inner sci-fi nerd in me because he has arguably been the best sci-fi director of the 21st century. Sci-fi when done right, is my favorite genre of fiction whether it be books, video games, tv shows, or movies, Up until this point, Denis had made four straight films that were deemed hits by audiences and critics alike, but he never did reach mega box-office success. I couldn't be happier with the success that Dune Part 2 has had.
The day was Saturday, March 2, 2024 and I was finally going to see my most anticipated movie since Dune [Dune: Part One]. As I sunk into the plush theater seat, I was swept up by a wave of nostalgia mixed with anticipation. The metallic voice of the Sardaukar pierced the silence, uttering those immortal words: "Power over spice is power over all". With that we were whisked back to Arrakis and got to experience for the next 2 hours and 46 minutes, one of the most influential stories of the sci-fi genre finally being told in a way that would be accessible to most audiences.
From this point on there will be spoilers to both the book and the film below.
Dune's accessibility to a broader audience marked a significant departure from some of the more intricate aspects of the original story. For instance, in Frank Herbert's novel, Alia, Paul's sister, is portrayed as a preternaturally gifted child who ages rapidly due to her exposure to the spice mélange in the womb while also receiving the knowledge of all of the Reverend Mothers before receiving any agency herself. However, in Villeneuve's adaptation, Alia is reimagined as a fetus communicating telepathically with Lady Jessica, her mother. This alteration not only simplifies Alia's character arc but even more importantly, it saves Denis Villeneuve the trouble of having to find a toddler actress that not only is capable of quality acting, but also has parents who would be comfortable enough with letting their little girl crawl/walk around a movie set and then have the task of stabbing and killing Barron Harkonnen. Good luck casting department.
Another way that Denis elected to make the film more accessible to modern audiences was with the portrayal of Fremen culture. While Herbert's novel meticulously details their strict customs and rituals, including the practice of water discipline and the importance of the sietch (Fremen underground dwellings), Villeneuve's adaptation opts for a more simplified approach that focuses more on showing us that the Fremen adapted to the desert without telling us how to everything. Which for a film, is almost always the correct approach. The film emphasizes themes of unity, cooperation, and resistance against oppression, showcasing the Fremen as a fiercely independent and resourceful people. But the biggest thing that the film changes about Fremen culture is that they portray the Fremen as a society where men and women are seen as equals. Whereas in the book, Paul goes through a ritualistic transfer of ownership after defeating Jamis in single combat acquiring his wife and children in the process. Purists will of course be upset with this alteration, but I think Denis made this change to make us empathize with the Fremen and highlight the contrast with outdated customs upheld by the Empire and the Bene Gesserit, such as the transfer of power through marriage, as seen with Princess Irulan. With the adaptation's alterations in mind, let's delve into the performances of the cast, who brought these reimagined characters to life on the screen.
Timothy Chalamet's portrayal of Paul Atreides was nothing short of remarkable. His every scream, every whispered command, felt like a visceral punch, thanks to the impeccable sound editing that transported us directly into the heart of Arrakis. It's almost as if Paul was wielding the Voice, compelling us to follow his every move. Paul emerges as a more relatable and empathetic figure, grappling with the weight of destiny and the burden of leadership. He finds himself torn between the survival of his people and the potential devastation of billions. The conflict between his personal desires and his duty to the Fremen, his family, and the entire universe is palpable in Chalamet's portrayal. This was the level of acting and writing I wish was present for Anakin Skywalker in the film Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith. Thankfully, Matthew Stover's novelization of the film does the story justice and I can't recommend it enough for any Star Wars fan out there. It truly blows that film away.
But anyway, back to Dune. Chalamet skillfully navigates Paul's journey, portraying him as a man trapped by fate, forced to confront his own mortality and the inevitable consequences of his actions. What sets Chalamet's performance apart is his ability to convey Paul's internal struggle and conflicting emotions. He portrays a character who must reconcile his own desires with the greater good, knowing that his choices will shape the fate of worlds. Ultimately, Chalamet's portrayal of Paul Atreides elevates the character to new heights, imbuing him with humanity and complexity and I am excited to see where his character goes in the upcoming Dune Messiah movie.
Austin Butler's Feyd Rautha practically leapt off the screen with intensity and I loved every scene that he was in. His portrayal of the Baron's lovely Feyd seamlessly embodied the ferocity and cunning nature of House Harkonnen, delivering a performance that leaves a lasting impression. From his commanding presence in the electrifying introduction on Giedi Prime to his pivotal role in the intricate plots of the Bene Gesserit, Butler captures the essence of Feyd's character with intensity and depth and he just looked like he was having the time of his life playing the sociopathic villain. Though as great as Austin Butler was, what truly makes the character of Feyd so memorable is the meticulous setup crafted by Denis Villeneuve. In the books, on top of being a monstrous figure, Baron Vladimir Harkonnen was heavily implied to be a pedophile that had a sexual preference for "young men" and was particularly attracted to his nephew Feyd. He explained to Feyd that all of his schemes and the chaos he unleashed was for Feyd to take over House Harkonnen and to ascend to the throne of the emperor. This intricate web of "plans within plans" adds depth to the Baron's character, positioning him as a master manipulator to set Feyd Rautha up as a rival for Paul. While the book delves deeper into the nuances of the Baron,'s character, the film amplifies Feyd Rautha's threat, portraying him as a significant player in the power dynamics of the Dune universe.
Prior to the audience's introduction Feyd, we see Princess Irulan having a conversation with the Reverend Mother shedding light on the intricate power dynamics at play, revealing the Bene Gesserit's plan for the succession to the throne. Irulan learns that the only way for the Shaddam family to retain power is through marriage. She is presented with two potential suitors: Paul, whom the Bene Gesserit are determined to prevent from ascending, and Feyd Rautha, whom Irulan protests is a sociopath. However, the Bene Gesserit are undeterred by Feyd's character flaws. They are solely interested in determining if he can be controlled because they know that they cannot control Paul.
Enter Giedi Prime: the planet with a Black Sun that absorbs all color. The scene on Giedi Prime is a masterclass in visual storytelling. Shot with infrared cameras to emphasize the stark brutality of the Harkonnen home world, it immerses viewers in a world of darkness and danger. Amidst this backdrop, Feyd Rautha's character shines, embracing the challenge of combat with a sociopathic zeal. His fight is not just a display of physical prowess but a testament to his formidable nature and unyielding determination. Feyd relished every moment of the brutal combat, showcasing a level of derangement that even for a Harkonnen was chillingly unique.
After the battle was over, we encounter the steadfast Lady Fenring, a stark contrast to the defiant Lady Jessica. Where Jessica chose to defy the Bene Gesserit's plans by bearing a son, Paul, Lady Fenring embodies unwavering dedication to their schemes. Her relentless commitment to the Bene Gesserit cause stands in sharp contrast to Jessica's independent spirit and serves the purpose of letting the audience know of how deep the Bene Gesserit's manipulative influence goes.
Meanwhile, the scene culminates in a crucial revelation: the realization that Feyd Rautha has the potential to be a candidate for the Kwisatz Haderach! This revelation was brought to light by his successful passage of the Gom Jabbar test. Additionally, Lady Fenring being impregnated by Feyd, and following the Revernd Mother's explicit instructions to ensure that the baby was a girl, ensures the continuation of the Harkonnen lineage as they, the Bene Gesserit, desire thus solidifying the Bene Gesserit's influence behind.
The day was Saturday, March 2, 2024 and I was finally going to see my most anticipated movie since Dune [Dune: Part One]. As I sunk into the plush theater seat, I was swept up by a wave of nostalgia mixed with anticipation. The metallic voice of the Sardaukar pierced the silence, uttering those immortal words: "Power over spice is power over all". With that we were whisked back to Arrakis and got to experience for the next 2 hours and 46 minutes, one of the most influential stories of the sci-fi genre finally being told in a way that would be accessible to most audiences.
From this point on there will be spoilers to both the book and the film below.
Dune's accessibility to a broader audience marked a significant departure from some of the more intricate aspects of the original story. For instance, in Frank Herbert's novel, Alia, Paul's sister, is portrayed as a preternaturally gifted child who ages rapidly due to her exposure to the spice mélange in the womb while also receiving the knowledge of all of the Reverend Mothers before receiving any agency herself. However, in Villeneuve's adaptation, Alia is reimagined as a fetus communicating telepathically with Lady Jessica, her mother. This alteration not only simplifies Alia's character arc but even more importantly, it saves Denis Villeneuve the trouble of having to find a toddler actress that not only is capable of quality acting, but also has parents who would be comfortable enough with letting their little girl crawl/walk around a movie set and then have the task of stabbing and killing Barron Harkonnen. Good luck casting department.
Another way that Denis elected to make the film more accessible to modern audiences was with the portrayal of Fremen culture. While Herbert's novel meticulously details their strict customs and rituals, including the practice of water discipline and the importance of the sietch (Fremen underground dwellings), Villeneuve's adaptation opts for a more simplified approach that focuses more on showing us that the Fremen adapted to the desert without telling us how to everything. Which for a film, is almost always the correct approach. The film emphasizes themes of unity, cooperation, and resistance against oppression, showcasing the Fremen as a fiercely independent and resourceful people. But the biggest thing that the film changes about Fremen culture is that they portray the Fremen as a society where men and women are seen as equals. Whereas in the book, Paul goes through a ritualistic transfer of ownership after defeating Jamis in single combat acquiring his wife and children in the process. Purists will of course be upset with this alteration, but I think Denis made this change to make us empathize with the Fremen and highlight the contrast with outdated customs upheld by the Empire and the Bene Gesserit, such as the transfer of power through marriage, as seen with Princess Irulan. With the adaptation's alterations in mind, let's delve into the performances of the cast, who brought these reimagined characters to life on the screen.
Timothy Chalamet's portrayal of Paul Atreides was nothing short of remarkable. His every scream, every whispered command, felt like a visceral punch, thanks to the impeccable sound editing that transported us directly into the heart of Arrakis. It's almost as if Paul was wielding the Voice, compelling us to follow his every move. Paul emerges as a more relatable and empathetic figure, grappling with the weight of destiny and the burden of leadership. He finds himself torn between the survival of his people and the potential devastation of billions. The conflict between his personal desires and his duty to the Fremen, his family, and the entire universe is palpable in Chalamet's portrayal. This was the level of acting and writing I wish was present for Anakin Skywalker in the film Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith. Thankfully, Matthew Stover's novelization of the film does the story justice and I can't recommend it enough for any Star Wars fan out there. It truly blows that film away.
But anyway, back to Dune. Chalamet skillfully navigates Paul's journey, portraying him as a man trapped by fate, forced to confront his own mortality and the inevitable consequences of his actions. What sets Chalamet's performance apart is his ability to convey Paul's internal struggle and conflicting emotions. He portrays a character who must reconcile his own desires with the greater good, knowing that his choices will shape the fate of worlds. Ultimately, Chalamet's portrayal of Paul Atreides elevates the character to new heights, imbuing him with humanity and complexity and I am excited to see where his character goes in the upcoming Dune Messiah movie.
Austin Butler's Feyd Rautha practically leapt off the screen with intensity and I loved every scene that he was in. His portrayal of the Baron's lovely Feyd seamlessly embodied the ferocity and cunning nature of House Harkonnen, delivering a performance that leaves a lasting impression. From his commanding presence in the electrifying introduction on Giedi Prime to his pivotal role in the intricate plots of the Bene Gesserit, Butler captures the essence of Feyd's character with intensity and depth and he just looked like he was having the time of his life playing the sociopathic villain. Though as great as Austin Butler was, what truly makes the character of Feyd so memorable is the meticulous setup crafted by Denis Villeneuve. In the books, on top of being a monstrous figure, Baron Vladimir Harkonnen was heavily implied to be a pedophile that had a sexual preference for "young men" and was particularly attracted to his nephew Feyd. He explained to Feyd that all of his schemes and the chaos he unleashed was for Feyd to take over House Harkonnen and to ascend to the throne of the emperor. This intricate web of "plans within plans" adds depth to the Baron's character, positioning him as a master manipulator to set Feyd Rautha up as a rival for Paul. While the book delves deeper into the nuances of the Baron,'s character, the film amplifies Feyd Rautha's threat, portraying him as a significant player in the power dynamics of the Dune universe.
Prior to the audience's introduction Feyd, we see Princess Irulan having a conversation with the Reverend Mother shedding light on the intricate power dynamics at play, revealing the Bene Gesserit's plan for the succession to the throne. Irulan learns that the only way for the Shaddam family to retain power is through marriage. She is presented with two potential suitors: Paul, whom the Bene Gesserit are determined to prevent from ascending, and Feyd Rautha, whom Irulan protests is a sociopath. However, the Bene Gesserit are undeterred by Feyd's character flaws. They are solely interested in determining if he can be controlled because they know that they cannot control Paul.
Enter Giedi Prime: the planet with a Black Sun that absorbs all color. The scene on Giedi Prime is a masterclass in visual storytelling. Shot with infrared cameras to emphasize the stark brutality of the Harkonnen home world, it immerses viewers in a world of darkness and danger. Amidst this backdrop, Feyd Rautha's character shines, embracing the challenge of combat with a sociopathic zeal. His fight is not just a display of physical prowess but a testament to his formidable nature and unyielding determination. Feyd relished every moment of the brutal combat, showcasing a level of derangement that even for a Harkonnen was chillingly unique.
After the battle was over, we encounter the steadfast Lady Fenring, a stark contrast to the defiant Lady Jessica. Where Jessica chose to defy the Bene Gesserit's plans by bearing a son, Paul, Lady Fenring embodies unwavering dedication to their schemes. Her relentless commitment to the Bene Gesserit cause stands in sharp contrast to Jessica's independent spirit and serves the purpose of letting the audience know of how deep the Bene Gesserit's manipulative influence goes.
Meanwhile, the scene culminates in a crucial revelation: the realization that Feyd Rautha has the potential to be a candidate for the Kwisatz Haderach! This revelation was brought to light by his successful passage of the Gom Jabbar test. Additionally, Lady Fenring being impregnated by Feyd, and following the Revernd Mother's explicit instructions to ensure that the baby was a girl, ensures the continuation of the Harkonnen lineage as they, the Bene Gesserit, desire thus solidifying the Bene Gesserit's influence behind.
Tell Your Friends