Crafts are having a moment and Tv channels have finally wisened up to their potential as reality-tv concepts. As someone who knows nothing about smithing, this show is fascinating. Unlike too much Tv around, there is little to no emphasis on the candidates' backgrounds and interactions, which is pleasent and allows more focus on the smithing itself. Every concept or technique is explained, and we can follow along nicely.
My only critiques would be regarding the judges, especially Doug Marcaida. He is dubbed a martial arts expert. That is very vague, what martial art? For how long? Where? To what level? All he does is make slashing motions when testing a blade, and grin when estimating whether or not a blade could kill.
Which brings be to my second critique. Like a lot of shows on the History channel, this is geared towards people with less formal education, and pretty specifically the white alt-right working class. The presenter is an ex-army guy with what passes for good looks, a lot of contestants fit the "neckbeard" stereotype and seem very proud of how much damage their work can do as opposed to their level of skill. The tests often involve realistic dummies that are designed to be gored realistically to everyone's joy. Is it necessary? Do many of us fight hordes of attackers in backalleys? A lot of the contestants seem to give little thought as to how their work is used and how they are promoting their profession, they prefer the machismo of bragging about belonging to the isreali forces, or how Conan the Barbarian, a cartoon character, inspires their work.
Still it is a great introduction to an ancient craft and maybe could inspire some to look it up further.
My only critiques would be regarding the judges, especially Doug Marcaida. He is dubbed a martial arts expert. That is very vague, what martial art? For how long? Where? To what level? All he does is make slashing motions when testing a blade, and grin when estimating whether or not a blade could kill.
Which brings be to my second critique. Like a lot of shows on the History channel, this is geared towards people with less formal education, and pretty specifically the white alt-right working class. The presenter is an ex-army guy with what passes for good looks, a lot of contestants fit the "neckbeard" stereotype and seem very proud of how much damage their work can do as opposed to their level of skill. The tests often involve realistic dummies that are designed to be gored realistically to everyone's joy. Is it necessary? Do many of us fight hordes of attackers in backalleys? A lot of the contestants seem to give little thought as to how their work is used and how they are promoting their profession, they prefer the machismo of bragging about belonging to the isreali forces, or how Conan the Barbarian, a cartoon character, inspires their work.
Still it is a great introduction to an ancient craft and maybe could inspire some to look it up further.
Tell Your Friends