Dear me, look at all these proponents of the "Great Man of history" perspective wherein the putative prime mover of a historic incident or epoch helms the story, rather than the myriad lesser figures without whom the story would never occur. But hey, telling a story from the perspectives of all the minor players would make the heads' of studio moguls explode-"what's this 'Resan' crap?" they'd doubtless inquire-so for good or ill we're left with tales told from more abbreviated perspectives, to the chagrin, it appears, of many penning reviews here.
Somehow I suspect those scribes proudly count themselves as champions of the little people, except when it comes to posting effete and disdainful reviews of movies from the perspective of one. However, had those scribes stopped to ponder, there are, at root, three available narrative points of view-first, second, and third person-with sundry variations on these narrative themes such as found here-telling the story through the eyes of a bit and transitory player-so I'm surprised these haughty critics that might otherwise claim to stand with with the little people disdain a film that actually does so.
And does so while conveying messages worth heeding: speak truth to power, even if doing so does not serve one's interests; beware of the hangers on attracted to fame and fortune as they won't be there for you over the long haul; genius makes its own rules and needs to be nurtured; and indeed, to thine own self be true. Pretty pedestrian stuff for those who otherwise stand with the little people and indeed perhaps the true sin of this movie as they see it: not only eschewing the first person narrative perspective of the bohemian's bohemian Great Man, but also tossing in an insufferable dose of middle class mores that has no place in any post-modern piece of cinema.
To their eye perhaps no scene was more inappropriate than one where the Great Man's perhaps best known work was referred to, perched unseen in an easel, as his major muse states "no one who has seen this will ever forget it," perhaps the most straightforward metric by which great works of art can be judged. Alas, so succinct a definition does not require critics to tell you what to think about a piece of art, needs no deconstructive folly-swaddles whereby critics cast the piece in their frame, has no place for an unctuous gallery owner to pass a photocopy off for a lithograph, shoehorns no interpreter of airs and means between the artwork and its viewer and hence leaves no platform for a champion of the little people to pronounce therefrom.
Given the two-dimensional dreck shills regularly extoll around here, it's not much of a surprise when their peers faintly praise, if they praise at all, a minor yet quite watchable work that well tells the story of a bit player that finds himself buffeted amid the Great Man's vortex, watches as that Man acts as though he can direct that wind, and then fades as all winds, vortices, and humans eventually do. If hagiographic and inevitably sanitized stories about larger than life women and men is what you need to keep you seated in front of a film then perhaps this movie isn't for you. But if you don't need the focus to be on a George C. Scott strutting about the screen replete with ivory handled revolvers to hold your interest, then give this pic a look.
Somehow I suspect those scribes proudly count themselves as champions of the little people, except when it comes to posting effete and disdainful reviews of movies from the perspective of one. However, had those scribes stopped to ponder, there are, at root, three available narrative points of view-first, second, and third person-with sundry variations on these narrative themes such as found here-telling the story through the eyes of a bit and transitory player-so I'm surprised these haughty critics that might otherwise claim to stand with with the little people disdain a film that actually does so.
And does so while conveying messages worth heeding: speak truth to power, even if doing so does not serve one's interests; beware of the hangers on attracted to fame and fortune as they won't be there for you over the long haul; genius makes its own rules and needs to be nurtured; and indeed, to thine own self be true. Pretty pedestrian stuff for those who otherwise stand with the little people and indeed perhaps the true sin of this movie as they see it: not only eschewing the first person narrative perspective of the bohemian's bohemian Great Man, but also tossing in an insufferable dose of middle class mores that has no place in any post-modern piece of cinema.
To their eye perhaps no scene was more inappropriate than one where the Great Man's perhaps best known work was referred to, perched unseen in an easel, as his major muse states "no one who has seen this will ever forget it," perhaps the most straightforward metric by which great works of art can be judged. Alas, so succinct a definition does not require critics to tell you what to think about a piece of art, needs no deconstructive folly-swaddles whereby critics cast the piece in their frame, has no place for an unctuous gallery owner to pass a photocopy off for a lithograph, shoehorns no interpreter of airs and means between the artwork and its viewer and hence leaves no platform for a champion of the little people to pronounce therefrom.
Given the two-dimensional dreck shills regularly extoll around here, it's not much of a surprise when their peers faintly praise, if they praise at all, a minor yet quite watchable work that well tells the story of a bit player that finds himself buffeted amid the Great Man's vortex, watches as that Man acts as though he can direct that wind, and then fades as all winds, vortices, and humans eventually do. If hagiographic and inevitably sanitized stories about larger than life women and men is what you need to keep you seated in front of a film then perhaps this movie isn't for you. But if you don't need the focus to be on a George C. Scott strutting about the screen replete with ivory handled revolvers to hold your interest, then give this pic a look.
Tell Your Friends