Sort by Year - Latest Movies and TV Shows With Mike Mathis

1. Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes (2022)

TV-MA | 61 min | Documentary, Biography, Crime

Never-before-heard audio from the interrogation of serial killer John Wayne Gacy threads through this chilling look at his 1970s murder spree.

Stars: Sam Amirante, Greg Bedoe, Rafael Tovar, Mike Albrecht

Votes: 12,934

2. Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes (2022)
Episode: The Life of the Party (2022)

TV-MA | 64 min | Documentary, Biography, Crime

John Wayne Gacy becomes a prime suspect in teen Robert Piest's disappearance. Previously unheard audio tapes reveal Gacy's thoughts and early days.

Director: Joe Berlinger | Stars: John Wayne Gacy, Kim Byers-Lund, Sam Amirante, Rafael Tovar

Votes: 591

3. Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes (2022)
Episode: A Nicely Kept Secret (2022)

TV-MA | 60 min | Documentary, Biography, Crime

After a sprawling confession, Gacy starts acting erratically, forcing police to contend with both his behavior and a shifting investigation.

Director: Joe Berlinger | Stars: John Wayne Gacy, Patti Vasquez, Sam Amirante, Mike Albrecht

Votes: 544

4. Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes (2022)
Episode: Sane Enough (2022)

TV-MA | 60 min | Documentary, Biography, Crime

As Gacy's lawyers try to mount an insanity defense, police attempt the daunting, emotional task of identifying - and honoring - each of his victims.

Director: Joe Berlinger | Stars: John Wayne Gacy, Greg Bedoe, Dan Genty, Martha Fourt

Votes: 522

5. The Toolbox Killer (2021)

TV-14 | 89 min | Documentary, Biography, Crime

Story of two American serial killers and rapists who kidnapped, raped, tortured, and killed five teenage girls in Southern California over a period of five months in 1979.

Directors: Bob Cea, Matthew Testa | Stars: Lawrence Bittaker, Laura Brand, Dennis McCarthy, Stephen Kay

Votes: 579

6. Murder Loves Company (2019– )

43 min | Crime

In Murder Loves Company we meet people gathered together in a unique shared world. One of these people will soon be murdered, but it is always a surprise who. One of these people is the killer, but their identity is a mystery.

Stars: Jack Daniel, Nakoa DeCoite, Holgie Forrester, Harvey B. Jackson

Votes: 72

7. Murder Loves Company (2019– )
Episode: Dorm Living Nightmare (2019)

TV-14 | 42 min | Crime

A girls' movie night gone bad leads to a not so happy ending for this group of college roommates. Police investigate a murder that leads them halfway across the state in search of the killer.

Directors: Douglas Elford-Argent, Brian Puterman | Stars: Kathryn Bianco, Jack Daniel, Phil DiGennaro, Michael Gantz

Votes: 7

8. Extreme Measures (2018–2019)

60 min | Crime

These are the incredible stories of real people taking EXTREME MEASURES to solve the murder of a loved one. Those tormented by the past do everything the investigation requires for answers.... See full summary »

Stars: Diane Cardea, Jack Mahrt, Jamie McMahon, Jessica Taylor Gable

Votes: 45

9. Extreme Measures (2018–2019)
Episode: The Boy with the Dragon Tattoo (2018)

TV-14 | 42 min | Crime

A mother's love of her son compels her to go face-to-face with a local thug she thinks killed her oldest child.

Director: Jason O. Silva | Stars: Cameron Gilliam, Heidi Appe, Matthew Campbell, Diane Cardea

Votes: 11

10. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)

60 min | Documentary, Crime

When a group of people get together and take it upon themselves to kill. It can happen for a litany of reasons. But nothing is quite the same as a group murder.

Stars: Matt Riedy, Lawrence Moran, Jerreal Khari, David Adler

Votes: 229

11. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Murder Circle (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

When a North Carolina teenager becomes convinced that someone wants him dead, his friends help him lay low at an abandoned property, then the teenager winds up dead, turning all of his friends into suspects.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: Tim Drier, Billy Meade, Angela Nordeng, Sean Babapulle

Votes: 23

12. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Best Friends For-never (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

The body of a 19-year- old man turns up in Spearfish, South Dakota and police launch a nationwide search for suspects. When an informant comes forward with clues, detectives realize the murder may be part of a sexual domination plot.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: Stephen Todt, Andres J. Uribe, Timothy Bowman, David Silavin

Votes: 11

13. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Murder Pact (2016)

TV-14 | 43 min | Documentary, Crime

In Hollywood, Florida, the body of a young man is found at the edge of the Everglades, and homicide investigators must wade into a sordid case of bullying, revenge and secret relationships.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: Don Taylor Atkinson, Michael Dutko, Kevin Fernandez, Marilyn Garateix

Votes: 23

14. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Dead Lift (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

In Las Vegas, five teenagers work out constantly to optimize their strength training, then the crew's strongest member is found dead and buried in the desert, turning his best friends into murder suspects.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: David Adler, David A. Jørgensen, Tommy Kijas, Justin Hoffmeister

Votes: 19

15. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Dear Friend, Dead Friend (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

A fun-loving 25-year-old man is gunned down on the railroad tracks in Manor, Pa., turning his best friends into murder suspects.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: Michael Anthony Jr., Jensen Chambers, Timothy Driscoll, Tessa Evelyn

Votes: 11

16. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Friend Fatale (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

A popular teenager's body is discovered along an abandoned trail. Interviews reveal a dark side to his closest relationships, as a tale of jealousy and resentment emerges-along with an unlikely murder mastermind.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: John Ahle Kellar, Jax Buresh, David Cohen, Audrey Ellis Fox

Votes: 14

17. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Friends in Low Places (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

In Bellevue, NE, a group of teens venture into the very adult world of "partner swapping," only to find they are flirting with disaster when one of them ends up dead in a drainage ditch.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: Reed Burkett, Bethany Carol, Menah Carter, Pamela Daly

Votes: 13

18. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: The Rabbit Hole (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

In Bellevue, WA, a teenager is found slain in a local park. As those closest to the victim lead investigators down the rabbit hole, a conspiracy is slowly unearthed, revealing this victim isn't the only one with a target on her back.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: Jessie LaBorn, Tricia Brooks, Kyle Butenhoff, John Capellaro

Votes: 11

19. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Unholy Friends (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

In Parker Florida, a teenager is found dead days after reconnecting with his birth mother. The teen's mysterious girlfriend leads investigators into a world of occultism and revenge that exposes the secret lives of the victim's friends.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: Rene Aranda, Brian Castellanos, Alex Dee, Lila Gavares

Votes: 15

20. Murder Among Friends (2016–2017)
Episode: Dungeons and Dying (2016)

TV-14 | 42 min | Documentary, Crime

When the battered corpse of a young woman turns up on the outskirts of Fallbrook, California, detectives unravel a secret world where dominance, sadomasochism, and manipulation reign.

Director: Omar Samad | Stars: William "Will" Daubert, Alex Dee, Kristina Jimenez, Jerreal Khari

Votes: 13

21. I Still Didn't Know I Was Pregnant (2015– )

Reality-TV

How is it possible that someone could not know they were pregnant twice? In the United States only one in seven thousand women don't know they're pregnant until they go into labour. And for... See full summary »

Stars: Jamie McMahon, Danielle Rosario, Jackie Torres, Adam Matthew Bartlett

Votes: 12

22. Outrageous Acts of Psych (2015– )

22 min | Documentary, Comedy

The series continues over lists of people who play psychic tricks on camera.

Stars: Tim Dadabo, Stacy Kaiser, Riaz Patel, Reef Karim

Votes: 33

23. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Fresh Heir (2015)

TV-14 | 43 min | Documentary, Crime

In the Houston heat a lawyer and his large family enjoy the high life. One member gets too greedy, though, and sparks a multi-generational war that ends in murder. It takes an entire police... See full summary »

Director: Greg Francis | Stars: Malcolm Matthews, Judy Ho, Kaisli Kaden, Sophia Louisa

Votes: 14

24. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: A Brother's Blood (2015)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

A NASA contractor and his beautiful wife are living the dream with their three adopted children on the picturesque Maryland coast. Traditional parenting soon turns into military-style ... See full summary »

Director: Greg Francis | Stars: Michael Anthony Jr., Jeremy Boros, Brian Castellanos, Alex Dee

Votes: 12

25. Outrageous Acts of Psych (2015– )
Episode: Very Important Sheeple (2015)

TV-PG | 22 min | Documentary, Comedy

Discover the hilarious psychology behind pranks and practical jokes. Find out what happens when people are scared into fight or flight, offered unusual VIP services, and when their person space is invaded.

Stars: Tim Dadabo, Stacy Kaiser, Reef Karim, Riaz Patel

26. I Didn't Know I Was Pregnant (2008– )
Episode: This Is Happening Again? (2015)

TV-PG | Drama, Reality-TV

Add a Plot

Director: Chris Shelton | Stars: CJ Brady, Kimberly Connolly, Mannie De Castro, Tamara Goodwin

27. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Blood Is the New Black (2015)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

In the desert oasis of Tucson, Arizona, a beautiful, young family's quick climb up the corporate ladder has them flush with cash. But soon, deceit and a cold-blooded murder will turn this family's dream into a nightmare.

Director: Greg Francis | Stars: Gary Anderson, Olivia Dunkley, A.J. Flick, Cynthia Imel

Votes: 14

28. Outrageous Acts of Psych (2015– )
Episode: Emotional Support Goat (2015)

TV-PG | 22 min | Documentary, Comedy

Watch the ridiculous human psychology behind a talking crosswalk signal, a creepy weatherman in an elevator, and a break-dancing 70-year-old man!

Stars: Tim Dadabo, Stacy Kaiser, Reef Karim, Khana Lacewell

29. I Still Didn't Know I Was Pregnant (2015– )
Episode: Aloha Surprise (2015)

Reality-TV

Add a Plot

Director: Chris Shelton | Star: Andrea M. Anderson

30. Devil in the Details (2014)

TV-PG | Crime, Reality-TV

Every investigation is a hunt for clues. In the question of murder, it is the details that reveal the coldblooded truth. Devil in the Details is a six-part series that follows a trail of details to track down a killer.

Stars: Victor Herminio Lopez, Ben Maccabee, Heath Centazzo, Rav Val Denegro

Votes: 44

31. My Trip from Hell (2014– )

60 min | Reality-TV

Add a Plot

Stars: Theresa Ireland, Eric Guisinger, Heather Dowling, Wendie Weldon

32. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: 4 Women & a Funeral (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

For the DeWilds of Edgewater, CO, family always comes first. But when one DeWild threatens to break that bond, they find the only way out of this family is murder.

Directors: David Cargill, Jim Edwards | Stars: Danika Gould, Ali Iovino, Lawrence Moran, Désirée Nick

Votes: 11

33. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: He Said, She's Dead (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

With a Coral Gables mansion and membership to the local yacht club, life's a beach for accountants Ed and Maggie Locascio. But when suspicion and infidelity threatens to break family bonds, one family member will be hit by the death tax.

Directors: David Cargill, Jim Edwards | Stars: Greg Audino, Dave Bean, Andrew Bongiorno, Nadia Dawn

Votes: 9

34. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Don't Kill the Messenger (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

The Milo family's Akron, Ohio based cosmetics supply chain is one of the biggest in the country. But beauty only goes skin deep, and an internal fight for company control will expose an ugly underbelly of conspiracy, lies, and murder.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Greg Duncan, Andy Gates, Alanna Giuliani, Rich Young Lee

Votes: 11

35. My Trip from Hell (2014– )
Episode: Pilot (2014)

Reality-TV

Add a Plot

Stars: Stephanie Andersen, Peter Charnock, Tommy Cooley, Heather Dowling

36. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Duct Tape Divorce (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

For the DeWilds of Edgewater, CO, family always comes first. But when one DeWild threatens to break that bond, they find the only way out of this family is murder.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Michael Lanham, Doug Brown, Bethany Carol, Rachel DeWild

Votes: 14

37. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: House of Lies (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

The Jackson family of Borger, Texas shares the same traditional American values as their neighbors. But a dark family secret reveals at least one Jackson is a wolf in sheep's clothing poised to thin the family flock...by murder.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Jovan Adepo, Brett Kamerman, Bobbie Lee Jr., Scott Andrew Lieberman

Votes: 9

38. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Murder Mansion (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

In the town of Libertyville, IL, Bruce and Darlene Rouse appear to have everything: wealth, success and three wonderful children. But behind closed doors, a toxic mix of scorn, jealousy, ... See full summary »

Director: David Cargill | Stars: John Ahle Kellar, C. Ashleigh Caldwell, Dedan Donovan, Cruz Flores

Votes: 20

39. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Home Sweet Homicide (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

The forward-thinking Santaguida family enjoys a healthy, natural lifestyle in the hippie haven of Evergreen, Colorado. But when one family member is found brutally strangled, homicide ... See full summary »

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Susan R. Benninghoff, Tom Colitt, Kristina Cole Geddes, Amity Givens

Votes: 14

40. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Hell's Belles (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

The Allman sisters have deep roots in their tight-knit Oakland community. When drug dealers threaten the neighborhood, the family decides to stand their ground. But after their house goes ... See full summary »

Director: David Cargill | Stars: John Capellaro, Malia Dawkins, Peter Dunbar, Emily Dykes

Votes: 11

41. TLC Presents (2013– )
Episode: Outrageous 911: They Made My Burger Wrong (2014)

TV-PG | 42 min

While many 911 calls are a matter of life and death, we've scoured the country for the most ridiculous ones; from a mom who calls after a fast food joint makes her burger wrong, to a man of... See full summary »

Stars: Josiah Black, Truett Jean Butler, Rachel E. Crane, Tasha Dixon

42. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

The Byrom family of Iuka, Mississippi (pronounced eye-ooka), seem to have it all: love, success, and plenty of Southern charm. They have some very dark secrets;. a penchant for sordid sex and a passion for poison result in murder.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Donald Prince, John Bruce, Barbara Ann Duffy, Cloyce Martin

Votes: 9

43. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Desperate House Knives (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

The Bautista family of Riverside, CA is living the American dream with a nice home and two hard-working sons. But that dream will soon become a nightmare as one Bautista threatens to sever family ties and somebody loses their head.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Shannon Barney, Jean Clement, Tina Dirmann, Stacie Eldridge

Votes: 13

44. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: Southern Helle (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

For Starkville, Mississippi couple Joey and Kristi Fulgham, friends and family are one and the same. But when small town hospitality leads to dangerous liaisons, one family member decides the only way out is murder.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Drew Hellenthal, Sharon Durrett, Tyler Edmonds, Brooke Hutton

Votes: 11

45. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: So Lonesome I Could Die (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

In the small town of Munster, Indiana, the Levine family real estate business is flying high. But life for these jetsetters is about to hit some turbulence as brotherly love turns into backstabbing, revenge...and murder.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Brian T. Hoffman, Gian Keys, Scott Andrew Lieberman, Brooke McCormick

Votes: 14

46. Gator Boys (2012– )
Episode: Cat Scratch Fever (2014)

TV-PG | 42 min | Reality-TV

Ashley leaves Gator Boys to work with tigers, and Jimmy takes time off to work in his restaurant. Paul struggles to keep up with nuisance gator calls, and must figure out a way to bring order to the chaos that is engulfing the Gator Boys.

Votes: 7

47. Blood Relatives (2012–2017)
Episode: The Widowmaker (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

Barry and Anita Ford seem to have it all: success, happiness, and loving in-laws George and Jill. But behind closed doors, envy and rumored-flirtation generate toxic hostility-culminating with one Ford executed in a remote industrial park.

Director: David Cargill | Stars: Alex Allred, Max Aria, Joelle Brianne, John Capellaro

Votes: 10

48. Devil in the Details (2014)
Episode: If I Had a Hammer (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Crime, Reality-TV

In suburban Tucson, Bonnie Sanborn's kids wake up one morning to find their mom gone, blood in the bedroom and her car missing. The abandoned car soon turns up with Bonnie's body inside, ... See full summary »

Director: Greg Francis | Stars: D A Allen, Heidi Appe, Dave Beaudrie, Matthew Campbell

49. Devil in the Details (2014)
Episode: Murder, Cajun Style (2014)

TV-14 | 44 min | Crime, Reality-TV

Hot-shot young defense lawyer Chiquita Tate is found stabbed to death inside her secure office in downtown Baton Rouge. When Detectives find three hairs clutched in her dead hand, will this... See full summary »

Director: Jeremy Kasten | Stars: Mell Bowser, Prem Burns, Lessie Hookfin, Elvin Howard

Votes: 5

50. TLC Presents (2013– )

TLC opens doors to big personalities and can't-miss moments that live at the intersection of remarkable and relatable. This collection of specials features authentic, real-life stories that open eyes to a different way of life.

Stars: Al Burke, David Hill, Beau Marie, Lita Lopez

Votes: 7