Although Bobbi and her husband Nick have claimed for decades they were the couple that appeared on the Woodstock album, in 2019, Jessie Kerr, a Canadian woman residing in British Columbia, Canada claims that the photo of the couple was of her and a man named John, whom she met in Montreal a few weeks prior to the festival. They decided to hitchhike from Montreal to Woodstock after he suggested that she join him at the music festival. Her account of the story was covered by a reporter of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) in August 2018. The photo evidence that she provided of he wearing the same large glasses and spouting the same hairstyle as in the photo, plus the fact that Nick didn't have curly brown hair (his wedding photo taken two years later showed he had blonde, straight hair during that era) seriously debunks the Ercoline's claim that they were the iconic couple pictured on the album cover.
The news story "It wasn't them': Vancouver Island woman says she's in iconic photo" by CBC reporter Bhinder Sajan can be found online via an internet search.