His musical, "The Full Monty," was performed at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre on Broadway in New York City with Patrick Wilson, John Ellison Conlee, Jason Danieley, Romain Fruge, Jane Connell, Lisa Datz, Andre De Shields, Annie Golden, Marcus Neville, and Emily Skinner in the cast. Jack O'Brien was director.
Terrence McNally and his musical, "The Full Monty" at the Kokandy Productions Theatre was nominated for a 2015 Joseph Jefferson Non-Equity Award for Musical Production.