J.D. Vance’s best-selling autobiography “Hillbilly Elegy” isn’t the most natural fit for the big-screen treatment, an often unwieldy mix of heartbreaking memoir, personal observations couched in sociological chatter, and cherry-picked factoids. In trying to understand how and why his Appalachian family faced hardships like domestic abuse, drug addiction, and poverty, critics noted that Vance’s perspective often revealed, at best, the limitations of his experience.
At worst, other critics said that Vance’s story was rife with racist and sexist ideology, a reliance on easily dispelled fallacies, and a resistance to blaming any of it on government and culture. As Sarah Jones put it in a searing “New Republic” piece, the book is “little more than a list of myths about welfare queens repackaged as a primer on the white working class.” It was also a bestseller, and one that many hoped might shine a light on segments of an increasingly divided America.
At worst, other critics said that Vance’s story was rife with racist and sexist ideology, a reliance on easily dispelled fallacies, and a resistance to blaming any of it on government and culture. As Sarah Jones put it in a searing “New Republic” piece, the book is “little more than a list of myths about welfare queens repackaged as a primer on the white working class.” It was also a bestseller, and one that many hoped might shine a light on segments of an increasingly divided America.
- 11/25/2020
- by Kate Erbland
- Indiewire
Similar News
Phoebe Dynevor is in talks to star in the new untitled shark movie from Violent Night director Tommy Wirkola
- 5/14/2024
- by EJ Tangonan
- JoBlo.com
10 Biggest Nickelodeon Stars of 2000s, and Where They Are Now
- 5/14/2024
- by virginia-singh@startefacts.com (Virginia Singh)
- STartefacts.com
Carla Gugino’s Favorite ‘House of Usher’ Scene Went Against Every Natural Instinct
- 5/14/2024
- by Proma Khosla
- Indiewire
“I didn’t think America had any business in…”: George Rr Martin Would’ve Fought in WW2 But Firmly Objected USA’s Involvement in Another Conflict
- 5/14/2024
- by Santanu Roy
- FandomWire
“This maybe my answer to Tolkien”: George R.R. Martin Openly Criticizing Lord of the Rings for a Very Real Reason is Too Humiliating for Lotr Fans
- 5/14/2024
- by Laxmi Rajput
- FandomWire
House Of The Dragon: Westeros Rides To War In Epic New Season 2 Trailer For Game Of Thrones Prequel
- 5/14/2024
- ComicBookMovie.com
‘Spectateurs! ’ Debuts Trailer Ahead of Cannes Special Screenings Premiere (Exclusive)
- 5/14/2024
- by Addie Morfoot
- Variety Film + TV
Guillermo del Toro is the Perfect Director to Turn Tolkien’s Abandoned 13-Page Manuscript into a Dark Lord of the Rings Sequel
- 5/14/2024
- by Adya Godboley
- FandomWire
Torresblanco, Murray Launch Hangtime, Transatlantic Production Firm, in Time for Cannes
- 5/14/2024
- by Lily Ford
- The Hollywood Reporter - Movie News
IMDb.com, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy.