IMDb Polls

Poll: The Critics and Audiences Agree...

The following movies have IMDb ratings and Metacritic scores that correspond exactly. Which movie did they get most right? You be the final judge: Which movie did the audiences and critics rate most accurately?

After voting, feel free to discuss here.

(Movies are listed in order of score/rating, from highest to lowest. There are several ties. Ties are listed in alphabetical order.) (Scores and ratings accurate as of July 1, 2021.)

Make Your Choice

  1. Vote!
     

    The Godfather: Part II (1974)

    Metacritic Score: 90 / 9.0 IMDb User Rating
  2. Vote!
     

    The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002)

    Metacritic Score: 87 / 8.7 IMDb User Rating
  3. Vote!
     

    The Departed (2006)

    Metacritic Score: 85 / 8.5 IMDb User Rating
  4. Vote!
     

    The Pianist (2002)

    Metacritic Score: 85 / 8.5 IMDb User Rating
  5. Vote!
     

    The Sting (1973)

    Metacritic Score: 83 / 8.3 IMDb User Rating
  6. Vote!
     

    Downfall (2004)

    Metacritic Score: 82 / 8.2 IMDb User Rating
  7. Vote!
     

    Ford v Ferrari (2019)

    Metacritic Score: 81 / 8.1 IMDb User Rating
  8. Vote!
     

    Casino Royale (2006)

    Metacritic Score: 80 / 8.0 IMDb User Rating
  9. Vote!
     

    Dallas Buyers Club (2013)

    Metacritic Score: 80 / 8.0 IMDb User Rating
  10. Vote!
     

    The Martian (2015)

    Metacritic Score: 80 / 8.0 IMDb User Rating
  11. Vote!
     

    Young Frankenstein (1974)

    Metacritic Score: 80 / 8.0 IMDb User Rating
  12. Vote!
     

    Iron Man (2008)

    Metacritic Score: 79 / 7.9 IMDb User Rating
  13. Vote!
     

    Life of Pi (2012)

    Metacritic Score: 79 / 7.9 IMDb User Rating
  14. Vote!
     

    The Untouchables (1987)

    Metacritic Score: 79 / 7.9 IMDb User Rating
  15. Vote!
     

    Drive (2011)

    Metacritic Score: 78 / 7.8 IMDb User Rating
  16. Vote!
     

    Glory (1989)

    Metacritic Score: 78 / 7.8 IMDb User Rating
  17. Vote!
     

    Breakfast at Tiffany's (1961)

    Metacritic Score: 76 / 7.6 IMDb User Rating
  18. Vote!
     

    Escape from Alcatraz (1979)

    Metacritic Score: 76 / 7.6 IMDb User Rating
  19. Vote!
     

    Inside Man (2006)

    Metacritic Score: 76 / 7.6 IMDb User Rating
  20. Vote!
     

    The Naked Gun: From the Files of Police Squad! (1988)

    Metacritic Score: 76 / 7.6 IMDb User Rating
  21. Vote!
     

    The Royal Tenenbaums (2001)

    Metacritic Score: 76 / 7.6 IMDb User Rating
  22. Vote!
     

    Superbad (2007)

    Metacritic Score: 76 / 7.6 IMDb User Rating
  23. Vote!
     

    When Harry Met Sally... (1989)

    Metacritic Score: 76 / 7.6 IMDb User Rating
  24. Vote!
     

    John Wick: Chapter 2 (2017)

    Metacritic Score: 75 / 7.5 IMDb User Rating
  25. Vote!
     

    Little Children (2006)

    Metacritic Score: 75 / 7.5 IMDb User Rating
  26. Vote!
     

    Cape Fear (1991)

    Metacritic Score: 73 / 7.3 IMDb User Rating
  27. Vote!
     

    Spider-Man (2002)

    Metacritic Score: 73 / 7.3 IMDb User Rating
  28. Vote!
     

    Shame (2011)

    Metacritic Score: 72 / 7.2 IMDb User Rating
  29. Vote!
     

    War Horse (2011)

    Metacritic Score: 72 / 7.2 IMDb User Rating
  30. Vote!
     

    Don't Breathe (2016)

    Metacritic Score: 71 / 7.1 IMDb User Rating
  31. Vote!
     

    Public Enemies (2009)

    Metacritic Score: 70 / 7.0 IMDb User Rating
  32. Vote!
     

    Clueless (1995)

    Metacritic Score: 68 / 6.8 IMDb User Rating
  33. Vote!
     

    Over the Hedge (2006)

    Metacritic Score: 67 / 6.7 IMDb User Rating
  34. Vote!
     

    Idiocracy (2006)

    Metacritic Score: 66 / 6.6 IMDb User Rating
  35. Vote!
     

    The Five-Year Engagement (2012)

    Metacritic Score: 62 / 6.2 IMDb User Rating

Recently Viewed