The Square Deal Man (1917) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Hart and Company well up to standard! The print, alas, is not!
JohnHowardReid12 August 2011
Warning: Spoilers
In this scenario by J.G. Hawks, William S. Hart plays the title character, Jack O'Diamonds, a saloon owner and professional gambler who decides to reform when Preaching Dan (Milton Ross), who is happy to accept donations from dance-hall girls, refuses his contribution and that of his side-kick, Two Spot (J.J. Dowling). After a handsome win from Colonel Ransome (J. Frank Burke), Jack, Two Spot and the orphaned child, Blossom (Mary Jane Irving) take a job helping out the colonel's daughter, Virginia Ransome (Mary McIvor). Virginia is being threatened by her Mexican foreman, Pedro (Darrell Foss) and his pal, Anastacio (Thomas Kurihara).

Interesting characters and a few neat twists keep our attention at a high level in this William S. Hart entry, despite the poor condition in which the movie survives. Originally, the screenplay came to a fine action climax – but unfortunately most of this is now missing.

Never mind, we still have the fascinating characters. One of the saloon regulars, for example, is an educated four-flusher, Broadway Hammersley (ingratiatingly enacted by Charles O. Rush), who is in much demand because he can actually translate legalese into plain English.

Director, Lambert Hillyer, adopts a pleasantly realistic, steady-as-she-goes style. The photography by Joseph August was no doubt up to his usual high standard (hard to tell in the present, washed-out print). Art direction is credited to Robert Brunton. Thomas Ince supervised. Original release date: 25 May 1917.

The movie was never copyrighted, however, and has always been in the Public Domain. Despite this latitude, the film survives in only two prints, one of which has lost the entire last half of the movie, and the other (this one!) missing around 10 minutes from the action climax.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fascinating!
JohnHowardReid25 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
THE PLOT: In this scenario by J.G. Hawks, William S. Hart plays the title character, Jack O'Diamonds, a saloon owner and professional gambler who decides to reform when Preaching Dan (Milton Ross), who is happy to accept donations from dance-hall girls, refuses his contribution and that of his side-kick, Two Spot (J.J. Dowling). After a handsome win from Colonel Ransome (J. Frank Burke), Jack, Two Spot and the orphaned child, Blossom (Mary Jane Irving) take a job helping out the colonel's daughter, Virginia Ransome (Mary McIvor). Virginia is being threatened by her Mexican foreman, Pedro (Darrell Foss) and his pal, Anastacio (Thomas Kurihara).

COMMENT: Interesting characters and a few neat twists keep our attention at a high level in this William S. Hart entry, despite the poor condition in which the movie survives. Originally, the screenplay came to a fine action climax - but unfortunately most of this is now missing. Never mind, we still have the fascinating characters. One of the saloon regulars, for example, is an educated four-flusher, Broadway Hammersley (ingratiatingly enacted by Charles O. Rush), who is in much demand because he can actually translate legalese into plain English. Director, Lambert Hillyer, adopts a pleasantly realistic, steady-as-she-goes style. The photography by Joseph August was no doubt up to his usual high standard (hard to tell in the present, washed-out print). Art direction is credited to Robert Brunton. Thomas Ince supervised. Original release date: 25 May 1917. The movie was never copyrighted, however, and has always been in the Public Domain. Despite this latitude, the film survives in only two prints, one of which has lost the entire last half of the movie, and the other (this one!) missing around 10 minutes from the action climax. The DVD is available from Alpha as a bonus with Three Word Brand.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The "atmosphere" of this release is deeply impressive
deickemeyer21 July 2015
"The Square Deal Man," by J. G. Hawks, presents William S. Hart in a role of finer character than many he has assumed in the past and more powerfully presents the complexity of human nature as opposed to the worn-out theatrical idea of one-sided personality. The story also strikes a vigorous note when a fearless clergyman in a rough border town dares tell the "square" gambler, impersonated by Hart, that he is nothing more than a "parasite," a degraded human outcast, existing by contemptible means of getting his living, for there is no meaner and more despicable creature on earth than the professional gambler. This particular gambler has never before had it brought to his attention that the suffering he causes reaches out to innocent women and children; he was under the impression that he was fleecing a certain class of men "born every minute." The tragic death of a man who had lost his entire possessions at the game, leaving penniless a petted daughter in the east for whom he expected to provide. A tremendous and perfectly logical conversion of character follows and the gambler decides to be a real man. He goes to the border ranch he now owns and restores order among Mexican cow punchers with a distinct purpose of handing over the property to the rightful owner when she arrives. Her appearance on the scene as the supposed owner sets up a very interesting situation not sufficiently developed or thrust aside for some mock heroics, but the story holds in spite of its lack of love interest at this stage, possibly because of superb treatment. Ranch life is so adequately pictured that the "atmosphere" of this release is deeply impressive; it is pure artistry. With such artistry of presentation, fine acting by Hart, when he keeps within the limits of human experience and vigorous subject matter, "The Square Deal Man" should prove an attraction on any program. - The Moving Picture World, March 24, 1917
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed