For Alimony Only (1926) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
What, no entertainment?
boblipton8 February 2006
This decent if not brilliant social comedy starring Leatrice Joy is a bit of a disappointment, alas.

It does turn the standard 'boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy gets girl' plot on its head in an amusing way: Clive Brook is newly divorced and paying more alimony to Lilyan Tashman than he makes when he meets Leatrice Joy in a fine 'meet cute' scene. So the object of the entire movie is to lose the girl -- in this case, Tashman.

Unfortunately, the middle of the picture sags: what should be played at high speed with fast cuts for door-crashing farce is played at a moderate pace for little impact. And Brook is pretty much of a stiff all the way through. Joy is fun, however, and Tashman too, as is Casson Fergusson as a sheik with a receding hairline and no chin.

What is notable about this film is its easy acceptance, in the mid-20s, of women's rights -- and duties. Hubby Brook is not bringing in enough money to make ends meet, so Joy goes out and gets a job without batting an eye. Alas, this sort of attitude vanished with the years: a decade and a half later, when Stevens directed WOMAN OF THE YEAR for Metro, the big scene was the one in which Hepburn tried to make breakfast and failed miserably -- thereby demonstrating that she was not a real woman.

I think I prefer this movie.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fun Romp
movingpicturegal6 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Silent romantic comedy/farce starring Leatrice Joy who plays Mary, a young art student who meets a man, Peter (Clive Brook), in a book shop who thinks she is a boy (she's dressed in the exact same male haircut and mannish outfit with sensible shoes worn in Leatrice Joy's previous film "The Clinging Vine"). Having just gone through another divorce where he must now pay his gold-digger of an ex-wife $5 a month (or was it a week) alimony - he tells the "boy" how easy it is to get along with another male compared to a female. Oops - when he finds out she's a woman, he decides to date her (what's that all about?!). Well, they are very soon married, but struggling financially to keep up with the $5 alimony payments which the blonde vixen of an ex-wife is constantly making demands for (she even has him jailed when his payments are past due) and all the while she is busy dating a leech without a job. Mary must take work as a decorator to help make ends meet, and, coincidentally, meets via her job the same leech man/boyfriend of the ex-wife, and he continually hounds her for a "date". To try and get his ex to reduce the alimony, Peter must agree to go out with her (fickle?, what's that all about?!) and they end up at this inn where they dine in a "private" room - the inn, apparently, infamous for trysts as the cops are soon there to bust things up, but smart Leatrice/Mary works out a way to end the alimony forever!

This film is pretty entertaining, Leatrice Joy seems to be an expert at making herself look masculine and her performance here is very well done; Lilyan Tashman smoothly brings the gold-digger to life. I saw this almost a week ago and the memory of what Clive Brook even looks like in this is completely gone (and I've seen this man in several other films, I still can't place his face) - so not exactly a memorable performance there. All in all, a light, fun film - not great, but quite an enjoyable watch.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed