Sweetie (1929) Poster

(1929)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
I Wonder If They'll Win The Big Football Game
boblipton24 June 2019
Nancy Carroll quits her show to marry Stanley Smith, only to find out that he will not be quitting school to marry her because the football team is depending on him. When she dejectedly returns to work (after being dumped back into the chorus!), she learns she owns the school, even if not the ladies' seminary next to it. She and Jack Oakie head out to take over.

It's one of the approximately 48% of 1920s musicals concerning college and football. There is are a large number of mediocre songs. The one good number is "You Romeo, Me Juliet," sung by Helen Kane. However, her three musical numbers show up one upon the next, and by the time she was in the second chorus of this one, I was tired of her helium voice, even if she boop-a-doops a few times in it.

Eventually, you realize early on, there will come the show--ending football game against the school's rival. I began to wonder "What if they lose? Won't life go on? Won't this journey also end in lovers' meetings?" I doubt it would surprise you if they win in the end.

In the end, this is a college musical exactly like every other college musical. If you like college musicals, you'll like this. If you're as tired of them as I am, you won't.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A mixed bag....but not bad for 1929.
planktonrules29 January 2020
Had this film debuted into the 1930s, I would have given it a lower score. However, films from 1928-29 were a rather crude lot because the sound systems they were using were so antiquated and they weren't yet able to film well outdoors or in more natural environments because of this bulky sound equipment. So, comparing them to later films doesn't seem fair and I cut these early sound flicks some slack.

"Sweetie" is a college musical comedy. And, like nearly all college films of the day, the students never seem to go to classes. Instead, they go to parties and football games...and that's really about it!

The star of the school's football team has a secret--he's planning on eloping with his girlfriend Barbara. But the coach appeals to the young man's school spirit and he reluctantly agrees to stay. Barbara is not happy about it but soon after she ends up inheriting this college (huh??). Soon she's running the place and with this comes lots of inexplicable singing and dancing. And, now things are very tense between the two...and she takes it out on the football team. In the end, it all boils down to the cliched 'big game'.

In addition to Nancy Carroll and Stanley Smith in the leads, Helen Kane, Stu Erwin and Jack Oakie are on to provide comic relief. As for Kane, depending on who you read, was the inspiration for Betty Boop and her main talents in this film consist of her singing and sexually harassing Stu Erwin...and sounding much like Betty Boop in the process.

So is this college romp any good? Yes and no. The film has a lot of energy and a few cute moments but it also could use some closed captioning because the sound is only fair. But Helen Kane's routine does wear a bit thin and the songs are an indifferent lot.

By the way, during the game you might notice a play where a player is tackled and he hits the ground but gets up and keeps running. Back in the day, you could legally keep running until you were taken down and held there.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Cute College Musical
Maliejandra30 May 2014
Stanley Smith is an obscure actor today, but in 1933 he was to take Dick Powell's role in Footlight Parade when Dick got sick with pneumonia. When Dick got well, Stan was out, and he never amounted to much. Judging by his performance in this film, I can see why. He reminds me of Lawrence Gray, who was adequate but lacked that something special that made audiences want to see him again.

The film also stars Nancy Carroll who was quite beautiful, Helen Kane who won me over with her cute voice and silly antics (she is introduced sitting in a tree shooting the man she loves), and Jack Oakie who is quite attractive here in this early part, and brimming over with the personality that made him famous. The scenes are incredibly beautiful, mostly set on a college campus, and the music is fun but none of it is very memorable, except for "Alma Mammy" which turns the alma mater into a jazzy Jolson-style number.

This college romp was screened at Cinevent in 2012.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Alma Mammy
drednm3 August 2010
Cute early musical starring Nancy Carroll as a chorus girl who inherits a men's college where her ex-boyfriend (Stanley Smith) is a star football player. She tries to sabotage his career until she gets school spirit. An original musical for the screen, SWEETIE boasts a good cast and some solid tunes.

Helen Kane co-stars as the troublemaking Helen who boop-a-doops through "He's So Unusual" and does a mean "Pep Step" with Jack Oakie, a brash hoofer who follows Carroll to college and enrolls. William Austin is the silly college dean, and Stu Erwin is a dumb-blond football player who is usually the target of Kane's pop gun.

Carroll and Smith sing a few songs, but it's Oakie's "Alma Mammy" that flows through the film as a theme song after Oakie is told that alma mater is Latin for dear mother, which he converts into a Jolson-like MAMMY song.

Nancy Carroll was Paramount's top musical star in early talkies, and she's stunning, but this film belongs to Helen Kane and Jack Oakie.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mammy!
CinedeEden30 September 2022
Betty Boop... whoops i mean helen kane makes a wonder perfomace in this early talkie as well as Nancy Carroll who does well in this musical drama but wished she did more singing in this picture. Some scenes were corny and rushed but then again this was the early days of sound. It is a wonder how early colleges looked liked in the 1920s and wonder how it would be during the great depression. Football is depicted as it was in the motion picture "so this is college" also a film that came out in 1929. Most of these college productions of the early days of hollywood dont show a classroom or the students even attending any classess.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Chorus Girl Inherits College
view_and_review2 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Sometimes a movie has a good premise, yet it's ruined by the execution. Sometimes a movie has a ridiculous premise that's made watchable by the execution. "Sweetie" has an asinine premise and it wasn't helped at all by the characters or the script.

Barbara Pell (Nancy Carroll) was a chorus girl all set to marry her sweetheart, Biff Bentley (Stanley Smith), a student at Pelham College. Biff was going to surreptitiously quit the football team and quit school then run off to marry Barbara who'd quit her chorus gig. Before Biff could run off his coach got wind of it and convinced him to stay. They had a big game coming up against their rival who'd dominated them for years and now they have a chance to actually win, but only with Biff on the field.

Biff sheepishly told Barbara he wanted to postpone the marriage until the end of the school year. She didn't want to hear it. She couldn't care less about football or school. She wanted to get married to Biff and that's all she wanted.

Barbara left Biff scorned and hurt, but she'd have a chance to get even. Not too long after their split Barbara got word that she inherited Pelham College. It turns out that Pell was short for Pelham. This was Barbara's golden opportunity to repay Biff for his slight and how dumb of a concept this was.

She decided she'd punish the entire football team and by extension, the entire school by making Biff ineligible for the upcoming big game. Not only that, she planned on selling the school (or maybe just giving it away) to the headmaster of Oglethorpe (Pelham's rival) who was going to promptly shutter the school.

In other words, Barbara was so simple-minded and petty that she would ruin the lives of hundreds of people to get back at a boy who wanted to play football for the last time. If that's not one idiotic idea for a movie plot I don't know what is.

The movie only got worse when the football team (or maybe the choir) all dressed in blackface to sing their new school song. It was like the director wanted to throw gasoline on an already raging tire fire.

I couldn't watch this movie silently even though I was by myself. I was raging at the screen like they made the movie to personally attack me.

Of small and insignificant interest in the movie was the character Helen Fry (Helen Kane). I'd seen her in "Pointed Heels" (1929) where she did her "boop boop-be doop" Betty Boop-style number. She did the same number in this movie where she moaned and pined for a boy so hard I thought she was going to die of horniness. Her character added nothing to the movie but more shame if anything.

"Sweetie" is a lousy movie not worth the kilobytes of ones and zeros it now exists as online.

Free on Odnoklassniki.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Great fun with Helen Kane!
Sterling-331 December 1998
Helen Kane steals the whole show at Pelham College. She does the "Prep-Step" with Jack Oakie and watches the boys from a tree . .. until she gets caught.

Lots of good songs. Nancy Caroll sings "My Sweeter Than Sweet" and Helen sings "He's So Unusual" later made famous again by Cyndi Lauper.

They used to show TV prints of this one but now . . .who knows where it is. Paramount films are disintegrating fast.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sweetheart of the Campus - That's Nancy!!!
kidboots6 August 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Paramount was a studio that was well known for it's pictures of flaming youth with it's roster of vibrant players - Clara Bow, Charles "Buddy" Rogers, Nancy Carroll and Louise Brooks etc. Theirs was the first college film to make a splash and unlike a lot of the other college based movies (and there were a lot) it didn't take itself too seriously and most of the players genuinely seemed to have a good time. Motion Picture News said "It doesn't pretend to be realistic". Based on the 1920 play "The Charm School", Paramount had filmed it numerous times, once with Wallace Reid and another "Someone to Love" only the year before with Charles "Buddy" Rogers.

It is love at first sight for Barbara Pell (Nancy Carroll) and Biff Bentley (Stanley Smith), Captain of the Pelham College Football team when he sees Barbara in a Broadway revue. Biff plans to leave the school for "something bigger than this" but hearing the boys sing "Bear Down, Pelham" and the coach wax nostalgic about Pelham's glory years has him thinking twice. Barbara, in her eagerness, drives out to the college to see him - and it is not long before an orchestra is heard and "This is the song he wrote for me" "I've prepared a love song... for My Sweeter Than Sweet". That is before Biff tells her the wedding is off and she tells him "well back to school, recess is over".

The big surprise is Barbara Pell is really Barbara Pelham and she has now inherited the boy's school where Biff is enrolled. She plans to install herself as Principal and teach Biff a few lessons!! Next door is Miss Twill's School for Girls, where the most lively girl is Helen Fry (Helen Kane) - she carries a gun and always gets her man. Her man of the moment is "Moose" (Stuart Erwin - as a blonde!!) but "He's So Unusual" that "he drives her wild" - he prefers football to petting!!! She instantly goes into "The Prep Step" an amazingly catchy song with lots of animated dancing and plenty of boop boop a doops!! At the football dance - Barbara looks wonderfully fetching. Tap Tap (Jack Oakie, one of the best things about the movie) Barbara's Broadway dancing partner, who takes to college like a duck to water, wows everyone with "Alma Mammy" - when all the college girls do the dance, using all the actions it is absolutely super.

Next day the worst happens - Barbara organises an English test and all who fail will not play in the big football game. Moose, their star player, thinks a preposition is getting a girl to say yes!! so the boys are in trouble. Biff is determined to keep Moose up all night studying, with the result that he is the one who fails!! - and Barbara's name is now mud!!! Never mind, Helen gets a chance to sing the provocative "I Think You'll Like It", Barbara has a change of heart and offers Biff a re-examination and of course he passes and saves the day but only after a big mistake is cleared up. (Biff thinks Barbara has only let him play so she can sell the school, so he purposely sets out to lose!!!) but everything turns out okay and there is another rendition of "Alma Mammy" - this time sung in black face.

The story behind one of the movies most popular songs "Alma Mammy" was that Jack Oakie had been performing a Jolson parody at Hollywood parties and Whiting and Marion wrote the song to give him an opportunity to do a similar number on the screen. The really big hit of the movie was only heard once - "He's So Unusual" was sung by newcomer Helen Kane, moaning about her unromantic boyfriend ("and when we're riding in a taxi, he converses with the chauffeur", "when we're walking in the moonlight, he says "I don't like the moonlight, aw let's not park in the dark"") all sung in a suggestive "boop boop a doop" voice. She became a sensation - she had already introduced her unique singing style to Broadway when she ad-libbed part of "I Wanna Be Loved By You". She had the look and personality that was very much in vogue in the 20s but like all novelties a little bit went a long way. Her popularity didn't last very long - by the next year, 1930, her style was passé.

Highly, Highly Recommended.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed