Before Morning (1933) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Not a Heart Attack, But Murder
boblipton12 May 2019
Louis Jean Heydt (in his first movie role) has come from the premiere of his first Broadway show. He drops in on Lora Baxter, and tells her that if it is a success, he wants her to star in his next. She turns him down. She's retiring and getting married. After he leaves, her old lover, Russell Hicks comes in. He doesn't feel too well and lies down. When Miss Baxter checks on him, he is dead.

She makes some phone calls. A dead married man in her apartment is not something she wants bruited about. In comes Doctor Leo Carillo. He says it was not a heart attack, but nicotine poisoning, that he found Hicks' will in his breast pocket -- where people always keep them -- and it leaves $200,000 to Miss Baxter. He suggests that he can take the corpse to his sanitarium and report the death as a heart attack for $200,000 in cash by the next day.

This interesting written murder mystery suffers a common issue for Poverty Row dramas of the era: very stagy line readings. However, the excellence of the story and Leo Carillo makes it very worthwhile. Although Carillo is probably best remembered as Pancho on TV's CISCO KID, and frequently played with a Mexican accent, in truth he came from a wealthy Los Angeles family who could trace themselves back to the Conquistadors. His grandfather had been the first provisional governor of California, and his father the first mayor of Santa Monica. Carillo himself was a trained engineer and cartoonist. In the 1930s he excelled at playing threatening villains, although his career turned into one of more standard accent parts in the 1940s. He died in 1961 at the age of 80.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Worth a remake
westerfieldalfred4 September 2019
So many bad films are being remade of classics these days, you have to ask how anyone could be so stupid. The films that need to be remade are those that have great possibilities, but, for some reason, never fulfilled their promise. The plot of Before Morning is wonderful, with twist after twist. The screen play held my interest, despite the poor direction and acting. I was hoping that other IMDb reviewers would tell me it had been remade. Alas, no. There must be some way to bring Before Morning to the attention of some venturesome producer.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
It's not, 'Elvis'...
Cumquat-Barry11 January 2014
In answer to a previous reviewer, the opening line is clearly: "Good evening, Albert."

I agree the film is in a very poor state, though it's not surprising nobody bothered to preserve it - the direction, staging, and acting, along with photography and editing are appalling, even for it's age - there were hundreds of decently, and professionally made films at that time - this is not one of them.

I expect it worked better in the more intimate environment of theatre but it's transference to the screen leaves a lot to be desired... Even many silent movies were more exciting than this.

The gaps in the delivery are almost big enough for the 'prompter' to get the words in... :)
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Unwatchable
lor_25 February 2024
The opening reel is so dull, it's the opposite of a grabber: if multiplexes had been invented by 1933 (too bad they invaded en masse in the '70s), patrons would have skipped for another screen on the premises showing a different movie after about 10 minutes. Low point immediately follows, as lead Lora hums (with sudden musical accompaniment from nowhere) a lullaby over the phone at the request of her adorable (not) kid in the hospital while her sugardaddy old fart Russell Hicks lies dying in the bedroom.

Things fail to pick up when Carillo enters as a shady sanitorium doctor who takes over the show. The "hit stage play" this was based upon is not opened up at all in basically a single-set movie drama, and nothing happens as the wax figures yammer on screen. Final reel of twists involving mystery and scandal are merely hot air, unconvincing and stupid. Carillo remains boring throughout until the final minute when the plot is explained stupidly.

Carillo's big line is: "For the love of Mike, get me a cigarette", a bit ironic in that the script has poisoning (presumably from an insecticide) with a capsule of nicotine as the murder weapon.

Acting and direction by Arthur Hoerl is so flat and static it could have been executed via animatronics rather than live actors.

Though ethnic Leo Carillo gets the lead role, the era's discrimination has a Black actress relegated as usual to playing the heroine's strictly functional maid Jenny, and gets no credit at all. The other characters say "Jenny" in conversation dozens of times, so one would think that the role of Jenny would be listed in the credits. And the bland leading man who has plenty of lines and is scheduled to mary Lora goes uncredited, too.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Stagy and quite slow....and the acting isn't especially good as well.
planktonrules20 September 2018
"Before Morning" was originally a play and it looks as if they were filming a play when they made this movie. This is NOT a good thing....as the acting is very stagy, there's no incidental music and the pace is glacially slow. It's a shame, as the basic idea of the story isn't bad at all.

An actress is planning on getting married and she tells a male friend about this. The man isn't feeling very good and goes to her bedroom to lie down. Soon, however, she finds the friend is dead and she is worried what the man's wife will think. Nothing happened unseemly, but she's worried about the appearance of impropriety. One of her friends recommends they call a trusted doctor (Leo Carillo). Unfortunately, this plan is not a good one, as the doctor is evil and uses this as an opportunity to shake down the actress as well as the man's wife!

As I said, the idea was interesting...the execution was clunky and dull. I blame the director for this...as the pacing and acting are his responsibility. It also didn't help that the big twist came long before the movie ended and the film kept dragging on and on afterwards.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
"Nicotine!"
mark.waltz9 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I had to look this up to confirm, but indeed, used in ways outside of a cigarette, nicotine can be used as a poison, but every time I heard Leo Carrillo say it here, I started laughing at the ridiculousness of that aspect of the plot. I've seen plot lines of movies with practically every kind of poison used, but what should be a serious twist ends up being eye rolling. In watching many movies of all kinds, I have determined that there are several types of truly awful movies. The most obvious is the cheaply made science fiction or horror with a ridiculous looking monster, but those get laughs, so they are fun overall. Another is the type with horrendous dialog and hideous acting, but then again, they are fun to laugh at too. The third and possibly worst of the bad movie offenders is the case in which "Before Morning" falls: plot twists and elements and characterizations that become so ridiculous that you end up screaming out, "Oh, come on! Really?" at your TV screen or public revival house.

This is actually a fairly lavish looking Z grade melodrama with basically just a single set of the apartment of actress Lora Baxter who has decided to give up show business for love, much to the frustration of a playwright who wants her for his next play. When her old lover (Russell Hicks) shows up and finds out that she's going to get married (to the rather dull Blaine Cordner), he begins to show signs of getting sick. Going to lie down in her bedroom at her suggestion, he suddenly dies, and the heartsick Baxter calls up old friends who are at a party downstairs to get rid of the body for her. A short time later, doctor Leo Carrillo shows up and proceeds to blackmail her in a rather lengthy speech that is only interrupted by the arrival of Hicks' wife (Louise Prussing) who has a few secrets of her own. The twists get more and more preposterous with one coming out towards the end that had me truly frustrated. Slow pacing makes this sometimes excruciating to put up with, and you might be in shock to look at your watch afterwards to realize that only an hour has gone by.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"From the Great Broadway Stage Success"!!!
kidboots12 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
...the credits trumpeted, maybe hoping no-one would notice that the play had already come and gone!! Hardly a success at only 28 performances, it starred Jessie Royce Landis as Elsie Manning, the actress who wants to give up the stage for marriage.

It made a pretty interesting film whose Agatha Christie style plot was a lot better than many of the "let's make it up as we go along" potboilers of the day. Lora Baxter had the lead and while she did come across as stagey, I was surprised to find that this was her only film. She is giving up the bright lights to marry Horace but she still has a former flame waiting in the wings. He is Jim Nichols who would have loved to marry her but has never been able to secure a divorce from his wife. When Jim takes a bad turn and dies, all her friends rally around to take the body to the local sanatorium to avoid a scandal.

Events take an interesting turn with the arrival of sinister Dr. Gruelle (Leo Carillo brings his usual comic quirkiness to the role and really lifts the film) - he is the supposed owner of the hospital but he is more intent on extorting money from distraught Elsie as she learns that Jim was poisoned and everything points to her!! Gruelle is willing (for a huge lump of money Jim has left her in his will) to cover up the evidence of foul play so his death will officially be seen as heart failure. He then summons icy Mrs. Nicholls to the flat - playing them off against each other as he tries to appeal to their baser instincts. Elsie is not having a bar of it but Mrs. Nicholls confesses that there is someone she is now seeing (if so why wouldn't she divorce Jim!!)

Leo Carillo is the only name in the cast - the rest were from the stage. Taylor Holmes was the father of Phillips Holmes who had made a name for himself in films, Lora Baxter's biggest stage success was as Cecilia opposite Leslie Howard in "The Animal Kingdom" - unfortunately for Lora, Myrna Loy was given the part in the film version and never looked back. Also Lora never got another part of note on Broadway and died in her mid 50s.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Interesting plot
yonhope4 July 2013
The bad things about this movie are mainly due to its age. It is black and white. The sound and picture quality are not up to most movie goers expectations. The acting is very slow. There are long pauses between the spoken sentences. It is like the actor or actress is waiting for a truck to drive by.

The good thing is the end of the movie. It actually goes somewhere. It could be redone today with a crisp delivery and the right cast. There are a few surprises that make the movie worth watching.

Leo Carrillo is actually good, but for some reason the acting is slowed down in almost every scene. There also is a great concern about a man and woman having an affair, which seems laughable today.

Is the first line "Good evening, Elvis?" I think that is what she says. Watch it and give me your opinion. This film was made two years before Elvis was born.
5 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interesting Film
jjbanzer-930-46463521 February 2014
I agree that the first line is "Good morning, Elvis." There is no doubt about it in my mind.

Louis Jean Heydt's part in the film is interesting, as it was his first motion picture. And he played many parts in movies from 1933 until his death in 1960. There are a few awkward times when his performance in this movie. That is no doubt due to his inexperience.

At the time of Heydt's death, he was appearing in a production of the play There Was a Little Girl, and his co-star opposite was Jane Fonda. He died of a heart attack immediately after the first act of that play, and the performance went on by understudy William Adler.

I love the old movies dating back to this era. Who cares if it moves a little slow at times? There could be a counter-argument made that today's films move much too fast. I also agree with the observation that this one, with its engaging storyline, could be successfully remade today.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed