What Price Innocence? (1933) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
What You Don't Know Can Hurt You
boblipton1 July 2019
Jean Parker is a good girl. She thinks she may be in love with Ben Alexander, but she's not sure what that is. Her mother, Minna Gombell, isn't much help, and her father, Bryant Washburn, leaves such matters to her mother. Doctor Willard Mack tries to find out what the girl he brought into the world is up to, and urges Minna to speak to her, but she refuses, insisting that she had brought the girl up right. Mack doesn't think Sunday school classes when she was ten will do the trick. It turns out he's right.

It's a pre-code picture about sex, without much in the way of sex, just young men saying they're crazy about the young women they're with and kissing them. Also, the consequences of sex. Writer-director-star Willard Mack has written a serious, didactic story, and fleshed it out with some good performers -- Betty Grable gets only her fifth credited role in this one. In fact, Mr. Mack gives the poorest performance, as he races through his well rehearsed lines.

It's not a great movie, by any means, but it's amazing to think that in a few months, Miss Parker would play Beth March in LITTLE WOMEN.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A touching tale of a family tragedy.
mark.waltz4 June 2019
Warning: Spoilers
For Bryant Washburn and Mina Gombell, life as middle-class parents has brought them two wonderful children, a boy and a girl who are decent and respectful and filled with great potential. However for daughter Jean Parker, her good fortune and promising future is only shortly lived as she soon finds herself in the family way with a boyfriend who has no intention of marrying her, having not received the facts of life from her parents and especially kept in the dark about women Lee secrets from her very proud mother. Family doctor Willard Mack cakes matters in hand, removing her from her home when he finds out the truth and sending her to a place where unwed mothers can have their children and privacy and dignity. But a visit with her parents has Parker distraught and this turns to tragedy as Gombell remains emotionally distant, setting husband Washburn against her and creating more guilt for the already fragile Parker.

This is truly an emotional story of one girl's failings in reaching womanhood, and it is made clear that the writer is on her side and not the side of the parents, particularly the mother. In fact, the older men get more respect than the older women, with Parker's friend, a young Betty Grable, getting the same treatment from her mother who finds out she is dating Parker's brother.

Certainly, this is now viewed as an exploitation film but back in the day it was a warning to parents to be honest with their children in regards to the facts of llfe that the previous generation could not understand as the younger generation faced different challenges. performances are sincere and the writing is good, and veteran black character actress Louise Beavers has a few great moments, one particularly on the phone with her boyfriend where she discusses plans to go to the movies. While the film does end on a tragic note, there was a sense of irony as Dr. Mack gets a great exit line that might be seen by some as misogynistic, what is similar in nature to Lewis Stone's exit line in "Grand Hotel".
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed