The Cowboy Star (1936) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Never Met a Man From Arizona Who So Clearly Came From Massachusetts
Miles-1019 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Warning Potential Spoilers: Charles Starrett reminds me of other actors. Undeniably handsome, he looks a little like Gary Cooper, and in his manner there is even a dash of Humphrey Bogart (mainly in his rare sophisticate persona). His voice reminds me of the genteel Joseph Cotten. In any case, the plot of this movie is practically post-modern because Charles Starrett in real life was a movie-screen cowboy not unlike Spencer Yorke whom he portrays in this archetypal oater. Except that Yorke is supposed to be a real cowboy--from Arizona no less. (Starrett was scion of a Massachusetts tool manufacturing fortune.) As oaters go, however, "Cowboy Star" is as inoffensive as milk and even entertaining. I liked the bad guys particularly. Sure one of them let their only hostage go too easily, but it was made clear that he was a complete idiot.

The biggest hole in the action sequence is that Yorke has an opportunity to catch the gang leader at one point but instead runs all the way back to where he started, then goes back AGAIN to the gangster by which time the bad guy has re-loaded his gun and practically gotten in his car. Well, if Yorke had done the smart thing, there would not have been an amusing if improbable chase scene involving a multi-horsepower automobile versus a one-horsepower...horse.

Since one of Yorke's complaints before leaving Hollywood is that he doesn't get to do his own stunts, I expected that he would be offered the option to do stunts himself when his former producer later tries to entice him to return to the movies, but Yorke isn't offered anything of the kind. Indeed, one can imagine all of Yorke's stunts in this movie being done by Starrett's double.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A cowboy is tired of being a movie cowboy.
michaelRokeefe7 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Columbia Pictures back in the day knew just how to get the best, and most, out their B stars. Cowboy hero Charles Starrett plays just that in this Black and White sagebrush drama. Spenser Yorke(Starrett)is a cowboy turned movie star who turns down his Hollywood producer(Landers Stevens)offering a new contract. He wants to get away from the picture business and buy a ranch in Arizona. He is sure that retirement is just the thing for him under the assumed name of George Weston. He arrives in Taylorsville, practically a ghost town and buys property from a pretty real estate lady named Mary Baker(Iris Meredith). Miss Baker's little brother(Wally Albright) doesn't really fall for the fake name, because he recognizes his favorite cowboy star. When Weston/Yorke rescues the little brother from kidnappers, he reveals his real identity and convinced that he must go back to Hollywood and once again be the hero of all kids everywhere.

The good guy makes the bad guys pay the price with a hail of bullets. And some romance with kissing. Ah shucks...the hero is suppose to get on his horse and ride. Chemistry between Starrett and Meredith is smooth as can be; they only made almost 20 Westerns together. Other players include: Marc Lawrence, Ralph McCullough, George Cheseboro, Silver Tip Baker and Si Jenks as sidekick Buckshot.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Should Please Front Row Kids of all Ages
dougdoepke16 October 2012
Pleasant little matinée western that ought to please front row kids of all ages. The format is different since the main character, Yorke, (Starrett) is both a real and a movie cowboy. I love that opening where Yorke is sneakily revealed as a movie cowboy while using movie tricks to make us think the action is real. But Yorke's tired of the Hollywood fakery and wants to get back to the open range. So he turns down a big new movie contract and relocates to the real West where he meets the winsome Mary Baker (Meredith) and other fine folks. The trouble is that modern day (1936) gangsters (Lawrence) are also hiding out there. This sets up an interesting contrast between a traditional cowboy like Yorke and 1930's desperadoes like Dillinger and Pretty Boy Floyd. Then too, I like the way Yorke learns a different way of looking at the cowboy hero as a result of clashing with these desperadoes. Overall, it's a nifty little time passer with a cleverly constructed positive message.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Take Me Back To My Boots and Saddles
bkoganbing9 October 2012
Not that Charles Starrett in the film and real life wasn't making a good living using both, but The Cowboy Star casts Starrett as a movie cowboy who was once a real cowboy before being spotted by a Hollywood producer. As he's about to sign with his picture company again, Starrett refuses telling all that he just wants to get back to being a real cowboy without the celebrity trappings. So he and real sidekick Si Jenks pull out and head for an obscure part of Arizona to buy a ranch. All under assumed aliases.

The future Durango Kid and Jenks get themselves involved with the local manhunt of three public enemies, the baddest of them played by Marc Lawrence. And Starrett gets involved with Iris Meredith who has a hero worshiping little brother Wally Albright who knows Starrett is his cowboy hero and not some nobody.

The Cowboy Star was a nice idea, but it went astray like some maverick. You will not believe how stupid these Most Wanteds are and how a kid pulls the wool over their eyes.

Still I'm sure the Saturday matinée crowd enjoyed this in 1936.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Cowboy Hunk
HarlowMGM12 March 2007
Cowboy movie star Charles Starrett tires of of Hollywood phoniness and decides to abandon his career and become a real-life cowpoke. He lands in a remote area where basically nobody knows movie stars and eventually proves his worth with the locals. Naturally, there are bad guys to fight and a pretty girl to woo. This 56 minute B western was the first of a whopping 100 plus "B" westerns Charles Starrett would make from 1936 into the 1950's for Columbia. The story is slight (although it seems to have inspired the 1990's film PURE COUNTRY starring country singer George Strait) but it moves fast (naturally) and Charles Starrett is an above-average actor for "B" westerns and is absolutely the most gorgeous hunk of man who ever had a major career in the genre with dashing looks to rival Tyrone Power or Robert Taylor. You will be hard pressed to decide which is the most appealing Charlie - the dashing cowboy or the dashing sophisticate in black tie and tails (which he also dons in this picture). The cowboy won out and Starrett abandoned mainstream films and his career as a hunky leading man for the likes of Billie Dove, Constance Bennett, and Carole Lombard for further adventures on the prairie with Iris Meredith as his perennial leading lady.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Back to the Simple Life!!
kidboots10 May 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Spencer Yorke (Charles Starrett) was a ranch hand who since coming to Hollywood has hit it big as a movie cowboy - and is completely fed up. He begs the director to let him at least ride a real horse instead of a mechanical one, he has to use face cream and powder and, to put it simply, his whole life is a fake, his every movement caught by reporters and photographers!! He decides to retire from pictures, buy a ranch and get back to the simple life - his friends give the pampered star a couple of weeks!!!

During the thirties when westerns had slumped in appeal studios found a novel way of bringing fans back. A minor cycle about the making of Westerns - "It Happened in Hollywood" (1937) had Richard Dix as a washed up western star, "Scarlet River" (1933) had Tom Keene as a reel life Westerner taking on real ranch hand baddie Creighton Hale and this one with Charles Starrett who as a pampered star is not even allowed to ride a real horse. As George Western he makes a dramatic entrance into the sleepy town of Taylorsville by rescuing a little girl from a runaway wagon. But is it all an illusion?? because when he tries to rescue Mary (pretty Iris Meredith) he almost succeeds in breaking her ankle and she is not impressed. Her little brother Jimmy (Wally Albright) is convinced he has seen Western before - on the movies as Spencer Yorke but the town is in for even more excitement when a group of city bank robbers led by Johnny Sampson (Marc Lawrence) hides out in the old ghost town and - you guessed it - little Jimmy sneaks off to explore.

Again, this different slant on an old familiar genre is great fun - everyone thinks they know George from somewhere, one of the robbers is convinced he is a G man as his face is just so familiar. Another highlight is seeing Starrett ride down the villain's nifty roadster on his faithful Palomino!!

Starrett's career as a beefy leading man was also in a rut by the mid 30s and Columbia who was looking around for a successor to Tim McCoy found what they were looking for in him. Unfortunately he became mired in sagebrush pot boilers often making up to 7 or 8 a year and poor old Iris Meredith (who I thought really resembled Sally Blane) was roped along as well - she co-starred in 19 of his films!!

Highly Recommended.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed