Romance of the Limberlost (1938) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A very enjoyable melodrama
Red-Barracuda4 June 2012
A young girl Laurie lives a life of misery with her cruel aunt in a small swamp village. The wealthiest man in the area makes a pact with the aunt so that he can take the girl's hand in marriage. This man is a drunken bully and old enough to be her father, so this is a pretty horrendous turn of events. Laurie has to rely on a few good souls to help her escape from this dreadful fate.

Romance of the Limberlost is a very enjoyable melodrama. Its success is down to a simple but engaging story with good characterisation and a likable heroine. You really care for her predicament and this is ultimately what makes the film work. It's a feel-good romance at the end of the day. It also has a sweet scene in the forest where Laurie interacts with a selection of wild animals. It's a slightly surreal moment that adds a nice touch of the fantastic to proceedings.

This is a very obscure film but it really shouldn't be. It's one of the better poverty row dramas that I have seen and is very accessible. It deserves a wider audience.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
What is true class, really?
mark.waltz21 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This second talkie version of The beautiful story by Gene Stratton Porter is slightly altered from the previous version, "A Girl of the Limberlost", but several elements remain that tie the two together. Laurie is a lovely country girl, both sweet and intelligent, brought up by a stern and seemingly hateful aunt (Marjorie Main) who promises her to a wealthy but brutish garment (Edward Pawley) who is killed right before their wedding, putting Parker's pal on trial. It us up to rising attorney Eric Linden to prove his innocence and during the trial, secrets and true emotions are revealed which change a lot of lives.

Main's character, a cold-hearted mother in the original, has been made Parker's aunt and is obviously a reverse snob, against book learning and big city folk, such as the wealthy but kindly Betty Blythe who befriends Parker and becomes her mentor. Sarah Padden and George Cleveland offer comfort to Parker who turns to them for solace over Main's brutality.

This is a simple story of human failings and the ability to forgive and atone. In several of Main's scenes, it is obvious that she is hiding her true emotions so it is easy to forgive her in her crueler moments. Parker is a sweet heroine, with Blythe excellent as the woman who helps her without question every chance she gets. Touching yet not maudlin, this is worth a look, and not a carbon copy of its predecessor.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A bit schmaltzy--but sometimes I like schmaltzy
planktonrules1 August 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is an unusual story as it's about a young lady who grows up in the poor part of town. They say she lives around the swamp—but oddly, there is no swamp in the film and the folks mostly don't seem like the trashy sort of ill-educated folk they are portrayed as being. The girl in particular has lovely diction and manners—which is odd considering her humble life.

Despite being very poor, the young lady (Jean Parker) is sweet and folks just seem to look after her and love her—that is except for her vicious aunt (Marjorie Main) who treats her more like Cinderella than her ward. Late in the film, the aunt tries to force the girl to marry Jed Corson—the meanest and most violent brute of a man. However, just before the wedding, Corson is murdered—and one of her friends is accused of the crime. It's up to a young lawyer who is in love with the lady to prove her friend is innocent.

Despite its odd swamp setting and low budget, this film is enjoyable because of some really nice acting—in particular by The only part that I didn't like was the final scene in the courtroom—it just didn't seem realistic and didn't quite fit the rest of the movie. But, it did, however provide a nice 'feel good' ending. A rather schmaltzy film but one I still found very enjoyable…perhaps even because of its great sentimentality.

By the way, the copy of this film you can download from the IMDb link is in rough shape. The opening credits are missing and the film skips a bit here and there.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Marjorie Main Steals the Film
drednm8 September 2012
Having seen and loved THE KEEPER OF THE BEES, I was happy to find another filmed version of a Gene Stratton-Porter story.

This story centers of a young girl named Laurie (Jean Parker), raised in the limberlost (timbered swamp land in Indiana) by her bitter aunt (Marjorie Main). It seems Laurie's mother married the man the aunt wanted for herself.

Laurie is a dreamy young lady who collects butterflies, reads books, and dreams of going to the city. One day she means a city lady lost in the swamp (Betty Blythe) and they become friends. She also meets a young man (Eric Linden) who has just graduated from law school.

The local thug is also the area's richest man (Edward Pawley) who has his eye on Laurie since his wife is dead. He persuades the aunt to let him marry the girl by promising her money and clearing the mortgage debt on her shack. But Laurie has seen him beat a poor orphan boy he took in to work around his place. And she has fallen for the young lawyer.

The aunt prevails by telling Laurie that her parents were never married and that the mother killed herself. She'll tell everyone if she doesn't marry the old man.

At the joyless wedding, the townspeople stand around like statues because they are appalled the aunt has forced the girl into marriage with the brute. But the orphan boy changes everything when he threatens to shoot the old man.

This is a low budget film from Monogram studio with lots of outside filming. Parker and Linden are excellent as the young couple. Former silent star, Betty Blythe, is warm as the caring lady. Pawley is appropriately snarky as the brute. Also good are Hollis Jewell as the orphan and George Cleveland and Sarah Padden as the store owners. But it's Marjorie Main as the grim aunt who turns in a great performance. There's not a whisper of humor in her Aunt Nora.

Very enjoyable film with a good story and a solid cast.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Rustic melodrama
bkoganbing14 November 2017
There are a lot of similarities between Romance Of The Limberlost and such films as Shepherd Of The Hills, Trail Of The Lonesome Pine, The Yearling, and Spitfire all set in some truly rural areas All of those films had the advantage of much bigger budgets from bigger studios than Romance Of The Limberlost which was an item from Monogram.

Our main character is Jean Parker a free spirited lass who to escape the tyrannical bullying of her aunt Marjorie Main who has raised her since her mother died by going into the forest. She's got more critter friends than Elly Mae Clampett and a couple of human friends in Eric Linden who wants to be a lawyer and simple swamp kid Hollis Jewell.

Main is fixing to marry Parker off to the much older and richer Edward Pawley whose puss was in many a Warner Brothers gangster flick of the Thirties. He's a mean brute looking for a nice young trophy wife.

When Pawley is killed, it's Jewell who's arrested at the scene and it's Linden who defends him. During that trial a whole lot of hidden truths come out.

Limberlost is the name for the swamp area in Indiana where the action takes place. Being from Monogram this didn't have too much in the way of production values. But the earnestness of the players overcomes a lot of that.

Marjorie Main is almost a synonym for female rustic characters on screen. But the woman wasn't always comical as she was in the Ma&Pa Kettle series. She could do a dramatic turn with the best as witness by this film and her performance in that most urban of dramas Dead End as Humphrey Bogart's mother.

Romance Of The Limberlost is worth a look.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Romance of the Limberlost 1938
reggietaco24 February 2005
"Romance of the Limberlost", according to an article in a magazine review of very old Hollywood forgotten films was said to be "a lost film". I searched among my old 30's films for about 20 minutes and was surprised to find it. I thought I had it but I hadn't seen it for many years.

Romance is a campestral tale that takes place in "The Limberlost" a swamp-like area in 1905.However, one never sees anything that even suggest a swamp.It is rather a rural setting, where Jean Parker(Laurie) is an innocent young girl who would rather commune with nature and her friends than work for her aunt,(in what is apparently a white slavery nightmare.)Marjorie Main plays the evil aunt who blackmails her niece with scandalous lies.

There is a murder that brings a young boy to trial, his only friend and advocate is Jean Parker who entreats the help of a young lawyer (Eric Linden).

This is not your average 1930's story and certainly nothing that one sees today.For that reason it is refreshing, and in its innocence concerning youth and wildlife-it is beautiful and extremely rare.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A Grotesque Melodrama Is Substituted For A Warm And Kindly Story
boblipton26 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
It's a greatly altered version of A GIRL OF THE LIMBERLOST. The name change was undoubtedly to make it seem a sequel, rather than a remake of the movie version of Gene Stratton-Porter's book only four years earlier.

In this version, we are introduced to many of the same characters in slightly altered circumstances. Jean Parker plays Lori this time, and Marjorie Main gives one of her nastiest performances as the girl's aunt. Edward Pawley wants to marry the girl, and offers Miss Main the mortgage back on her house. Miss Main browbeats the girl into accepting, and it's only the murder of Pawley that ends that plot. Instead there is a murder trial.

The original novel's plot is somewhat abbreviated, causing a good deal of trouble with character, and there's some high-falutin' language that the actors have problems with. Betty Blythe is back playing the Stratton-Porter stand-in, and she seems to make up her mind and lecture the other characters quite freely.

Jean Parker is quite adorable as the lead character;she plays her much as she did Beth in LITTLE WOMEN a few years earlier. However the substitution of the Bartered Bride melodrama plays hob with the warm and gentle story that the book offered, and which was in evidence in the earlier version.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This one touches most of the melodrama bases.
horn-527 June 2007
Laurie (Jean Parker)lives in the Limberlost (swampy timberland found in the American south)with her Aunt Nora (Marjorie Main), who hates the girl because her mother married the man Nora had loved. Laurie's existence is much the same as a bonded servant and she gets no encouragement from her aunt as she tries to overcome her environment by studying. Laurie's only friends are the birds and animals of the forest, and a young boy named Chris (Hollis Jewell), a bound boy to Corson (Edward Pawley), a drunken, coarse bully who is the wealthiest man in the community. Laurie meets and falls in love with Wayne (Eric Linden)whose ambition is to become a lawyer.

In the meantime, Corson, a widower, decides he wants to marry again and bargains with Nora to get Laurie as his bride. He promises to support Nora for the rest of her life in style and wealth. Laurie agrees to the forced marriage because Nora threatens to involve her dead mother in a scandal. Chris, secretly in love with Laurie, threatens to kill Corson before he will let him marry Laurie.

On the night before the wedding, Chris follows Corson to the barn, with a gun, but the bully disarms him with a whip. Accidentally, Corson falls onto the gun which he has seized from Chris, and is killed.

Chris is charged with murder, and Wayne agrees to defend him.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed