User Reviews

This was my first look at Mickey Rooney''s "Andy Hardy" and it turned out to be best of the four Hardy films I have viewed. This one is the sixth installment of this series, and this is one time I agree with the critics who label this as one of the best, if not the best, in the series.

Rooney looked a tiny bit old to be playing a high school junior, but I guess with his boyish looks and short stature, filmmakers thought he could get away with it.

The appeal of this movie is the old-fashioned goodness and innocence of the time period. You certainly don't see characters portrayed like this in movies anymore. Yes, everyone here has flaws but all of them are still nice people who pull for each other. It's also refreshing to see a father and his son confide in each other. Lewis Stone makes for a good father (and judge) figure. This is certainly different from modern Hollywood which usually portrays Dad as no good.

The teacher whom Andy falls for is played by someone whom I am not familiar with, but was very impressed with: Helen Gilbert. She is another of these nice, pretty and wholesome people with has a wonderful way about her. She is the kind of strong moralled woman seen in nice movies of the 1930s and 1940s.

Yeah, it's a lightweight piece of fluff but it's so refreshingly innocent and different from today most stuff seen on film - in any era, frankly - that I recommend you give it look if this sort of thing appeals to you. I don't promise a memorable, exciting or profound film.....just an hour or two of going back in time and feeling good about people.

I think the title says it all. Andy Hardy Gets Spring Fever occurs when after seeing his on and off girl friend Ann Rutherford entertaining a young naval officer, Mickey Rooney gets down in the dumps. But he perks up after seeing the new drama teacher Helen Gilbert and she's got a project for the kids at Carvel High School. She wants to do an original play and the one she picks was written by the love struck Andy Hardy.

The older generation of the Hardys has its problems too. Of all people Lewis Stone gets himself conned by a pair of grifters, Stanley Andrews and Byron Foulger, who tell him that some land he owns has a nice deposit of bauxite on it from which aluminum comes. Using the Judge's well known reputation for integrity to work for them, they fleece a lot of potential investors.

Of course business and financial problems do kind of sort themselves out for both generations of Hardy men. They always do.

Andy Hardy Gets Spring Fever is a better than average feature from the series. It has the presence of Woody Van Dyke who usually was assigned to A list films for MGM and he did right by his cast. I guess Louis B. Mayer must have had nothing else for him at the moment and the moguls never liked for their contract people to be idle.

Whatever it was, it worked.

I certainly watched the wrong Andy Hardy movies first. Love Finds Andy Hardy and Andy Hardy Meets Debutante are so silly, all ridiculous pantomimes of a teenage boy's hormones, but the other fourteen films aren't like that. They're supposed to be about the patriarch, Lewis Stone, who helps his children through their problems, a precursor to television shows like Father Knows Best. The series even uses the same theme music during the opening credits in every film, like a television theme-only these movies were made before television. Much of Mickey Rooney's character is how he tries to handle his raging hormones, but much of it isn't. In this one, he falls for his drama teacher, Helen Gilbert, and while sometimes he's goofy when trying to act like a grown-up and speaking in a different, theatrical voice, sometimes he's heartbreakingly real and insecure in his feelings. He talks it out with Helen and with his dad, and they both help him through it.

Mickey makes his character human, and even though he does his signature whooping, he gives a lesson to his teenage audience: it's okay to want to grow up, but don't rush it. Learning to take responsibility should be a slow process, and you should be able to enjoy being a kid without complications ruining things. In this one, he gets chosen by Helen to write the school play, and that's enough responsibility for any high schooler. "He's a regular T.A. Edison!" Lewis Stone exclaims proudly, a foreshadowing-and perhaps plugging-of Mickey's next year's film Young Thomas Edison, because his play has volcano pyrotechnics incorporated in the script. Fay Holden and Cecilia Parker are in this one, of course, but they're not prominently featured. If Mama Hardy and Marian are your favorites, check out You're Only Young Once and Love Laughs at Andy Hardy.

Andy Hardy Gets Spring Fever (1939)

*** (out of 4)

The seventh film in the series finds Andy (Mickey Rooney) heartbroken after Polly (Ann Rutherford) refuses to see him because she gets a crush on a Navy guy. Andy's heartache quickly turns around when he gets a new drama teacher (Helen Gilbert) and quickly falls for her. Meanwhile, Judge Hardy (Lewis Stone) finds himself in trouble when he gives his life savings for a business plan, which turns out to be a scam. If the innocence of the Andy Hardy series is something that's going to bother you then I'm sure this entry isn't going to change your opinion but fans of the series should find enough good things here to make it worth viewing. I was actually quick shocked to see how much more drama there is rather than comedy. When you think 1939 and hearing a plot about Andy getting a crush on his teacher you pretty much expect it to be handled in a slapstick, silly manor but that's not the case. The film is extremely serious about Andy's love for this teacher and there are a couple quite dark scenes where the two talk about certain boundaries that shouldn't be crossed with a teacher and her student. I thought the screenplay handled the drama extremely well and this is especially true towards the end of the film when the kids are putting on a play written by Andy and he gets to spill his emotions out for everyone to see. Rooney's performance during this dramatic sequence is actually some of the best acting I've seen from him as the power is certainly there. With that said, Rooney also gets to show off his comic timing early on and no one could ever say he didn't bring fire and energy to the role. Rutherford is also excellent here and thankfully her character is given a much more important role than what she had previous seen. The two of them make for a great team and really sell the film well. Stone, as you'd expect, delivers another very strong performance as does the other regulars like Cecilia Parker, Fay Holden and Sara Haden. Gilbert didn't have a very large career but I found her to be very good here as well. ANDY HARDY GETS SPRING FEVER isn't the best of the MGM series but it has enough charm and good will to make it worth viewing.

This installment in the Hardy Family series finds Andy perturbed about the strapping naval officer who is lavishing attention on Polly Benedict. But his feelings are assuaged when a beautiful new teacher takes over the drama class. She inspires his artistic tendencies and arouses romantic stirrings in Andy. Meanwhile, Judge Hardy participates in a get-rich scheme that involves a plot of land he owns.

Teacher Rose Meredith is played wonderfully by Helen Gilbert. It is easy to understand Andy's feelings for his muse/crush.

The banter between Andy and sister Marian (Cecilia Parker) is at its best in this film. They could have played up their humorous relationship more in other films.

The script does a good job with the sensitive subject of Andy's love for a teacher. That serious story is balanced well by the humorous parts of the film.

It's springtime. Judge Hardy gets tricked into a crooked business deal. Polly continues to try making Andy Hardy (Mickey Rooney) jealous. Instead, he falls for his new drama teacher, Miss Rose Meredith.

It's the seventh film in the Hardy family franchise. This one is mostly an Andy Hardy film. The Judge's story is almost secondary and Marian gets folded into it. I don't really care about that story. The rest of the family becomes support characters. It's Andy and his teenage hormones. I would have made Polly much more jealous. This is a silly puppy love crush but the movie loses me when Andy starts planning their future together. I know people got married much younger back in the day and Rose is young enough to not look that creepy. Andy is crushing too hard. I just want more distancing with the crush and do more with Polly. It's a little awkward. The twist ending is an excuse to let Andy off the hook. Rose could have mentioned the surprise a lot sooner.

ANDY HARDY GETS SPRING FEVER (Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, 1939), directed by W.S. Van Dyke II, marks the seventh installment to the "Judge Hardy's Family/Andy Hardy" series, and second film of three film releases of 1939. Being the first in the series directed by someone other than George B. Seitz, it also marked the second in the series bearing "Andy Hardy" in its movie title, following LOVE FINDS ANDY HARDY (1938). By this time, it was the teenage son, Andy, who becomes the center of attention rather than the fatherly judge, who is always around for those "man to man" talks with his son whenever there's a problem. For this entry, it's not Andy who gets into situations he must handle, but his father as well. Though Andy doesn't get a fever of sickness during the spring, its term "spring fever" is actually in reference to falling in love, which happens in most cases in the spring. This time, Andy has fallen in love with someone other than a girl of his own age.

The story opens traditionally in the courtroom where Judge James K. Hardy (Lewis Stone) is fining a young man $10 for kissing a young lady in a parked car. Because it's spring, he suspends the fine. In his chambers, Hardy is visited by James Willett (Stanley Andrews), a chemist, and Mark Hansen (Byron Foulger), his partner, who inform him that his aquaduct property, consisting of a mineral used to making aluminum in its soil, is valuable. Hardy later involves friends and associates to take part in the investments for the property, and soon permits his daughter, Marion (Cecilia Parker), to work as secretary for these two gentlemen, who now have a business office in town. As Hardy's 17-year-old son, Andrew (Mickey Rooney), he becomes jealous of his girlfriend, Polly Benedict's (Ann Rutherford) involvement with the extremely tall Lieutenant Charles Copley (Robert Kent) of the United States Navy, Andy's concerns are easily forgotten when the girl crazy Carvel High School teenager takes a "romantic" interest in his substitute dramatics teacher, Rose Meredith (Helen Gilbert). As Andrew's original story, "Adrift in Tahiti" becomes the subject of the upcoming school play, he not only helps with its staging with cast members, but soon steps over his bounds by falling in love with his 23-year-old teacher and wanting to marry her. With this being a worry for the judge, more problems arise when the wise old man carries a burden of guilt as to whether or not he's been swindled out of the $17,000 he's given to those two men. Also in the cast are series regulars, Fay Holden (Emily Hardy); Sara Haden (Aunt Milly Forrest); Addison Richards (George Benedict); Erville Alderson (Henry, the Bailiff); and Georgie Breakston ("Beezy" Anderson). Terry Kilburm, who played Tiny Tim in A CHRISTMAS CAROL (MGM, 1938) starring Reginald Owen as Scrooge, appears as one of Andy's younger classmates, Harmon Higgenbotham Jr., better known as "Stinkin' Plastor"; and Sidney Miller, a semi-regular of the series, appearing briefly as Sidney.

An agreeable "Hardy Family" production that contains two situations for the price of one, first the judge's problem, then the major one involving Andy's crush on his schoolteacher. How these situations are handled make this installment worth viewing. The teacher in question is played by an attractive young woman named Helen Gilbert in her movie debut. While the "Hardy Series"has become a good introduction for its MGM starlets that included popular likes of Esther Williams or Kathryn Grayson in later years, Helen Gilbert remains unknown and someone who would become labeled in "Whatever became of ? ..." listing. Gilbert did appear in other film productions for MGM (A segment in the "Doctor Kildare" series in 1939 for example), other studios and later television through the 1950s, but to no lasting appeal. ANDY HARDY GETS SPRING FEVER shows her off at best advantage as the mature speaking teacher with personal problems of her own. Fans of the series would enjoy this one.

Formerly available on video cassette and later DVD, this and the additional 15 segments of the series, can be found on cable television's Turner Classic Movies. Next in the series, JUDGE HARDY AND SON (1939) (***)

Andy Hardy is, as usual, an embarrassing teen to watch in "Andy Hardy Gets Spring Fever". Why? Well, he's fallen in love with his drama teacher and now he's acting insufferable after having written a play for his high school. It really is rather cringe-worthy...even compared to the other Andy Hardy films. Trust me on this...it's a bit painful to watch!

The Hardy films usually have several plots going on simultaneously. Other plots involve Polly (Ann Rutherford) having a handsome Ensign and Olympic champion staying with her family as well as Judge Hardy's unwise decision to invest in a local Bauxite mine run by some apparent swindlers.

Overall, this is an okay entry into the series but certainly not among the best. Most of the problem is the creepy romance Andy wants with this much older teacher...which today seems even creepier.

It's spring and a young man's fancy turns to thoughts of love. We all know what that means for our favorite teenage heartthrob Andy Hardy. After Polly Benedict turns her attentions to a handsome naval officer, Andy is dejected. But that changes when he meets his pretty new drama teacher (Helen Gilbert) and falls head over heels for her. Meanwhile, two con men put one over on Judge Hardy. Nice continuity in this subplot involving the aqueduct land that figured prominently in an earlier Hardy film.

The cast is great, as they always were in these movies. This is one of the best in the series for Mickey Rooney to showcase his acting chops. Lovely Helen Gilbert is terrific. Director Woody Van Dyke films her with an almost angelic glow about her. The plot of the teenage boy with a crush on his teacher is hardly original, even for the time, but it's handled with a remarkable sensitivity and maturity. That should come as no surprise to fans of this great series from MGM. All too often these movies are dismissed as corny sentimentalism but they're actually well written and acted dramas with touches of comedy and, yes, homespun Americana that is extinct today. Oh and dig that old-timey lawnmower Lewis Stone uses in one scene. Love little windows into the past like that.

This mildly more serious entry in the Hardy Family series centers on a more dramatic Andy and a school play. As with the previous film, he falls for an older woman and all that drama gets in the way of the humor. It isn't a bad film but I prefer a lighter touch and honestly 80 year old school scenes don't hold much appeal. While the scenes around the town of Carville seem pleasantly nostalgic, school films from this era just feel quaint.

... practically. Watching this film with modern eyes is I imagine a night and day experience as compared to how audiences must have reacted to it back in the day... or is it completely? Andy's beautiful young drama teacher that he's in thrall of does warn him about a line that teachers and their students must not cross. I wonder where that was coming from exactly? Anyway, I don't think it's possible for any modern viewer post Mary Kay and her like to view this without imagining the worst and most sordid possibilities. On another note, this in my opinion is the best of the Andy Hardy series. One particular scene in a classroom at night has an atmospheric mise en scene that goes far beyond what we can expect from an Andy Hardy movie; Helen Gilbert who plays the teacher is terrific; the high-school play that Andy wrote and stars in opposite his usual crush, Polly Benedict, goes off the rails with hilarious results; and the usual Judge Hardy subplot is a good one.