The Family Next Door (1939) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
An amiable old domestic comedy.
planktonrules20 April 2017
During the 1930s and 40s, W.C. Fields, Guy Kibbee and Hugh Herbert, among others, made quite a few domestic comedies where the husband was a decent sort and the family pushed him to make his fortune. And, by the end of the film, miraculously, they manage to strike it rich despite themselves.

In "The Family Next Door", Hugh Herbert plays a plumber. However, his wife (Ruth Donnelly) has ambitions of mingling with the rich and famous and insists that the family better itself. So, she tries a variety of stunts to try to impress her high brow neighbors...all to no avail. So how is this nice but occasionally annoying family going to manage to move up in status?

This family and film is not nearly as good as the best of these films ("It's A Gift" with W.C. Fields is the ultimate version of these sorts of films). The kids and wife are a bit more annoying than I would have preferred. Still, it's an amiable little time killer and Herbert, fortunately, only does his trademark laugh once!
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Amusing Hugh Herbert "B"
JohnHowardReid12 July 2009
Neatly directed by Joseph Santley, this six-reel support provides more than passable entertainment. Not only is Hugh Herbert in top comic form, but he receives solid backing from Ruth Donnelly, Joy Hodges, Juanita Quigley and Cecil Cunningham. Even Eddie Quillan and Thomas Beck contribute something. And all the players are most attractively lensed by Milton Krasner's camera. The use of standing sets gives the film's production values an "A" look. What's more, the script doesn't strain for effects, but finds plenty of humor in credible and familiar domestic incidents. Some may be a bit dated, but they still carry a ring of truth which adds to the movie's appeal.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Who wants to be a millionaire? Wifey does!
mark.waltz5 August 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Tired of her struggling existence as the wife of a rather unsuccessful plummer (leading actor Hugh Herbert), housewife Ruth Donnelly decides to take steps towards financial independence by becoming involved in a "sure thing" real estate deal. Thanks to oldest son Eddie Quillan, Donnelly invests the entire family's savings in a plot of land that leads to potential financial ruin. This ends up being a lesson in biting off more than you can chew and having dreams of grandeur that are obviously unrealistic and definitely pretentious. It's only when the family faces disaster that they come together to help each other which leads to a surprising conclusion.

"I haven't seen you in 10 years. You haven't changed a bit. You looked just as old as you do now", says Herbert to society matron Cecil Cunningham, Donnelly's hopeful ticket in society. Of course, having money doesn't bring on class, and it's hysterically funny to watch Donnelly's frustration at a party she throws as her family shows the indignant Cunningham what they are really all about. Black character actress Lillian Yarbo (perhaps the only thin African American actress regularly seen on screen during this time) is delightfully amusing as the tactless maid Donnelly hires, adding more humiliation to her efforts to rise above her station.

The pairing of Hugh Herbert and Ruth Donnelly reminds me of the earlier pairing of Victor Moore and Helen Broderick in a few of the Astaire/Rogers pictures which lead to several films where they were the leads. Herbert isn't nearly as dizzy as he was in most of his films, and Donnelly's desire to rise above lower middle class gives her a phony accent that is delightfully funny. Cunningham, while not as naive as Margaret Dumont or other similar society matrons, is a sort of second string Edna May Oliver who deserved to be a bigger character actress star than she was. Bennie Bartlett, later one of the Bowery Boys, is very funny as the younger of the two sons, causing all sorts of havoc during Donnelly's party which leads to disaster. I could see this having lead to a series of family comedies to off-set the sometimes unrealistic depiction presented by MGM's "Andy Hardy" series. Sitcomish for sure, but entertaining? Definitely!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Lemon into lemonade
bkoganbing20 November 2019
Hugh Herbert who was usually a second banana in so many films gets a chance to do a film I have to believe W.C. Fields passed on. In The Family Next Door Herbert is the henpecked husband of Ruth Donnelly who rules the roost over at their place. He's only good for paying the bills. Kind of like a 30s Al Bundy.

Ruth Donnelly gives over the family fortune as it were to their half smart son Eddie Quillan who makes a bad investment. But the family has the distinct possibility of turning the lemon into lemonade.

One of the best WC Fields vehicles without the man himself, Oh yes.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed