Here I Am a Stranger (1939) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Like father like son? That's what mother is afraid of.
mark.waltz27 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Not wanting to raise her son around an alcoholic athlete, a young mother takes her son away and remarries, determined to bring him up right. He grows up into a fine young man with great respect for his stepfather who adopted him but when he goes to college, meets a professor who knew his natural father and still thinks of him as a hero. The smart young man (Richard Greene) decides he wants to meet his real father (Richard Dix) and finds thatin spite of still having a drinking problem, he wants to have a relationship with him. His mother (Gladys George) advises him against it, wanting to keep past hurts from affecting her son, but ultimately it's up to Greene to discover the truth. With some of the people in his mother social circle being rather snooty, learning some life lessons from his down-to-earth natural father entices Greene to spend more time with him.

This obscure 20th Century Fox drama is actually worth rediscovering because of the amazing resemblance between young Greene and veteran actor Dix. I had to keep looking at the cast to determine who is who because of the large number of characters introduced quickly into the film. Roland Young gives his typical eccentric performance as the Bohemian English Professor who befriends Greene, with Brenda Joyce playing his feisty daughter who taunts Greene in early scenes but it's obviously a better match than the uppercrust girls his mother introduces him to.

It becomes an opportunity for mother to let son go and for Greene to find a relationship with his natural father as well as the man who raised him (George Zucco). The film encompasses family drama, young romance, a bit of screwball comedy and even a bit of sports. That's a lot of territory to cover in a film that doesn't reach 90 minutes but it is interesting from the perspective that you rarely see films about fathers and sons, and especially one that is sympathetic to someone with an alcohol problem but seems to be functioning. It is that uniqueness of this film that makes me ranked at as a good, if not great film, and another surprise to come out of 1939.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Bringing Up Father
boblipton16 July 2019
Gladys George left Richard Dix nineteen years ago. He couldn't hold a job, drank, and the Great Novel he was working on was going nowhere. Now she is married to George Zucco, and Miss George's child with Dix is grown to be Richard Greene, about to go off to the college where his elders all went. A friendship with professor Roland Young and his daughter, Brenda Joyce, leads Greene to Dix.

Father and son help each other grow. Dix quits the booze and gets a job on a newspaper. Dix's attitude towards people knocks the snobbery out of Greene. It all comes to a head when David is in the car when a fellow college student strikes and kills a woman, and David is expected to lie to protect a member of his class, while Russell Gleason, who's working his way through college, will take the rap.

It's a fine cast under the direction of Roy Del Ruth working on a good script. Richard Dix, as he does whenever he gets a chance to actually act, is superb; Roland Young is wonderful (of course) and Brenda Joyce gets a fine part as the unlikely ingenue. It's Greene who gives a performance that is an eye-opener: not so much in the way he speaks his lines, but in the way he moves just like Dix does.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A most unusual story.
planktonrules9 February 2021
When the film begins, Clara has had enough of her husband's drinking and irresponsible lifestyle. Not surprisingly, she takes her baby and leaves.

Decades pass. The baby is grown and now David (Richard Greene) is heading off to college. He soon makes friends...both with a nerdy farm boy who is also a student as well as with one of his professors (Roland Young). As a result of getting to know this English professor, David learns that his biological father, Duke (Richard Dix), was one of his students long ago and Duke was apparently a star football player at the college long ago. So, David goes to meet him and soon David and Duke establish a relationship. Duke is still irresponsible and a drinker, but he wants to be someone his son can respect...and he cleans himself up and gets a good job at the local paper.

Now here is the odd part. All this that I've told you really has very little to do with what is coming next! It involves a hit and run death and a pack of liars....and you'll just have to see it for yourself to know where it's all going next.

The acting in this one is very good all around....Greene, Dix, Young and the rest. The odd twist towards the end is generally good, but also seemed hard to believe. I still am not sure if I liked it or not! Overall, a decent film but one which left me a bit confused.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed