North of Shanghai (1939) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The fifth column in the newspaper
VanheesBenoit1 January 2010
Helen Warner, a famous US newspaperwoman is send by her boss to Shanghai. Gangsters -angry about her exposing them in front page articles- have threatened the newspaper. So her boss thinks she deserves a break, a holiday far away, and expenses paid. Little did he know she would stumble across yet another scoop and… a sweetheart!

Traveling by boat took quite some time in those days, and all sorts of people took the opportunity to get acquainted. Remember Bogart meeting Mary Astor in "Across the Pacific". Helen too meets her love interest-to-be, in the shape of Jed Howard, a somewhat noisy but sympathetic war reporter. During the same trip, a strange incident takes place: an intruder was waited in Helen's cabin, and insisted in getting the film from her camera. He explained he was upset about being recognizable on some of her pictures. Somewhat irritated but also rather puzzled, Helen hands over the film.

When Helen and Jed arrive in Shangai,they hear about the Japanese invasion of the north of China. Jed decides to go there with his Chinese cameraman. Helen -who hasn't told Jed she's a famous reporter too- decides to drop her holiday. She gets in contact with the local antenna of her newspaper. Soon she finds out that quite strange things are happening in that office. To begin with, the man who took her film on board of the ocean liner pops up here of all places. Although he denies having left the country recently, she identifies him via a scar. Helen also quickly has complaints about the strangely unprofessional and clumsy behavior of her local boss. But there is something bigger going on... Jed's cameraman is murdered in the street. Soon, it becomes clear that a fifth column is very active in providing valuable military information to the invaders. (Although it's never clearly said they are working for Germany –the movie is from 1939-a decoration behind the main plotters throws a strange shadow, in which something that looks like a swastika can be identified)

No impressive action scenes, no dialogs which are nice little verbal ping pong games, and the baddies don't have the charisma of let's say Sydney Greenstreet or Peter Lorre. A nice little B-spy movie though, not particularly brilliant but still quite enjoyable. Rather something for completists. 7.5/10
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
This one definitely gets the gong.
mark.waltz5 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Slow moving and convoluted, this deals with early world war issues between Japan and China and the presence of American reporters (Betty Furness and James Craig) who are harassed by spies from the moment they leave the states. Craig encounters his pal Keye Luke in Singapore, tries to get rid of Furness by sending her to Bombay, and then the real weirdness begins.

This second rate Columbia B spy drama may only be an hour long, but that hour is filled with just too many weird sordid characters that turn out to be nothing but red herrings. The dialogue is often spoken in a very slow monotone, making for a tedious hour where weird art direction give stereotypical views of the Asian world. You'd think there be some good wise cracking conversation between Craig and Furness, but sadly there isn't. It seems so much longer than it really is, and isn't even saved by some nice shadowy photography that would later become prevalent in classic film noir.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed