User Reviews

Saga Of Death Valley has villain Frank M. Thomas shoot down Lane Chandler in cold blood so that he can gain control of the water Chandler has on his ranch. One witness was left, the younger child of Chandler who grows up to be Don Barry who becomes his number one enforcer.

This western plays a lot like a Warner Brothers gangster feature with Thomas running a real nice protection racket with the ranchers in the valley. That is until the other and older son of Chandler shows up to claim his birthright and settle some scores and that of course is Roy Rogers.

Roy's leading lady is Doris Day, not THE Doris Day, but another actress with the same name who sang not a note with Roy. Can you imagine the nice music that Roy and the other Doris could have made? We might never have heard of Dale Evans who was several years in Roy's future.

Although Saga Of Death Valley has nothing to do with the real Death Valley of alkali, cactus, and borax, the film has a nice plot, good acting and is one of Roy's better early features.

When Roy Rogers was a boy, his father had owned a ranch in Death Valley. But fellow rancher and owner of the only source of water, Frank M. Thomas, had gunned his father down and and taken Roy's brother as his 'nephew'. Now Roy has returned under a fake name, with only Gabby Hayes to recognize him, to buy back the old spread and begin a war against Thomas, who's also running 'protection' against cattle rustling, under the charge of Roy's unremembering brother, Don Barry.

Rogers starred in nine movies for Republic in 1939, so he must have been pretty busy. That said, it's a good outing, well written by Karen DeWolf, and directed by the indefatigable Joseph Kane. That's the best way to become a star: good work and lots of it. Plus some decent songs, including "Peeping Through The Knothole."

SAGA OF DEATH VALLEY (1939) is a lean, action-packed B-western about a land grabber in a generic ranch valley (no relation to the real Death Valley) who comes up against a new ranch owner who's willing to fight back. Roy Rogers stars as Roy Rogers, whose father owned the Circle R Ranch and was killed by land baron Ed Tasker (Frank M. Thomas) when Roy was an adolescent. Tasker had snatched Roy's younger brother, Tim, and raised him to be an outlaw, leading raids on other ranchers' stock and forcing all the ranchers in Death Valley to pay protection to Tasker. When Roy comes back to the valley as an adult he forms the Death Valley Riders to combat Tasker's efforts. This gets him into a confrontation with his own brother, although neither knows their family connection. Roy also hooks up with Ann, his childhood sweetheart (played by Doris Day, an actress who left movies five years before the more famous Doris Day turned up at Warner Bros. in 1948). Because of the complicated family history at the root of the film's drama there is a richer subtext than usual for a Rogers western and a more tragic ending.

The film is beautifully photographed by Republic Pictures house cameraman Jack Marta, much of it on location in the area around Lone Pine, California in the foothills of the Sierras. The action is fast and furious and the cast includes lots of Republic Pictures regulars, most notably Gabby Hayes as Roy's ranch foreman. Donald Barry plays Jerry, who's secretly Roy's brother Tim. Barry would next co-star as Jesse James with Roy in DAYS OF JESSE JAMES (1939) and went on to forge a notable career as a B-western star in his own right. He didn't sing and had a darker quality than most western heroes, making him, in all likelihood, the first B-western anti-hero.

"Saga of Death Valley" begins many years earlier...when Roy Rogers was a kid. His father is murdered by the local baddie, Tasker, and he's seen doing it by Roy's little brother...so Tasker kidnaps the boy. But although a thug, he hasn't the heart to kill the boy so he raises him...and the boy grows into manhood (Red Barry) and thinks 'Uncle Ed' is his uncle. He's also his uncle's henchman who often does much of Tasker's dirty work.

After a long absence, Roy returns to town....and goes by the name Roy Reynolds. He is, of course, coming to investigate what happened to his father as well as to establish himself in the local community. While he appears to be a peace-loving man and is willing to put up with Tasker's huge fees for water, on the sly (get it?) he leads a group who call themselves the Riders of Death Valley...and they vow to stop Tasker. But what will Roy do about Tasker's henchman? After all, Roy recognizes him and realizes he's his long lost brother.

The location for this shoot is Lone Pine, California...in the Sierras and near Mt. Whitney. This was actually the location for nearly 1000 films....mostly, but not exclusively westerns. This isn't very far from Death Valley....although one reviewer erroneously said that the film has nothing to do with THE Death Valley. I've made a few mistakes in my many reviews...so I understand that these things happen.

Overall, a better than average Roy Rogers film due to the interesting plot. Additionally, the film is a bit grittier than his later movies...something I really appreciate.

Ed Tasker kills Roy Rogers, Sr. over a land dispute and the only witness to the crime is his 3 year old son Tim, who is kidnapped by Tasker and led into a life of crime. Years later, Tasker is controlling the water rights for the valley, along with the adopted son, now named Jerry. Rogers' other son Roy, arrives in the valley under an assumed name to reacquire his father's old ranch. When Tasker starts charging Roy and the rest of the ranchers outrageous prices for the water, Roy organizes a group of night riders to disrupt Tasker's plans. Tasker sends out Jerry to stop the night riders leading to a showdown of brother versus brother, even though neither of the two know it. The idea of brothers separated at birth was definitely not new when this B western was made, but so far of the ones I've seen this is definitely the best, obviously helped out by the opposite characterizations performed by Rogers and Barry. Excellent directing by Kane, as well as an interesting characterization by outlaw Taliaferro, contemplating to blow up the dam in the film's shoot out. Rating, based on B-westerns, 10.

The shocking opening sets the stage when Rogers Sr. (Lane Chandler) refuses to falsify an assayer's report on water rights and is killed by Ed Tasker (Frank M. Thomas). Toddler Don 'Red' Barry is a witness and is kidnapped and raised by Tasker. So it's brother seeking brother and lover seeking lover where Doris Day comes in. She's not as famous as the later era Doris Day but just as beautiful. Rogers ups the ante against the villains when he forms a vigilante group from among his cowhands. Great roles played by the best sidekick ever, Gabby Hayes and the best henchmen sidekick ever, Jack Ingram. Look for a great scene at the dam with Hal Taliaferro and a dazzling dance scene with Gabby and Fern Emmett.

While westerns endure in one form or another, and some are surely among the best movies ever made, not every variety thereof stands as tall now as they might have in years past. Roy Rogers is certainly best known for his antics as a singing cowboy, a genre that's decidedly gauche and carries old-fashioned sensibilities that today are most associated with early sitcoms of 1950s television. This doesn't mean that they can't be earnestly worthy and enjoyable, but even at their best they tend to be very direct in their storytelling, which itself is an odd flavor characteristic of their contemporary pictures. Suffice to say that such movies may not appeal to all viewers - though it should be noted that in this case, 'Saga of Death Valley' rather deemphasizes songs compared to some of Roy Rogers' other pictures, and also adopts a slightly darker tone. Still brusque in its plot development (including the jarringly sudden ending), ham-handed at times (there are, yes, fragments of song), and otherwise claiming some of the same indelicacies or inelegance, there's no confusing that it's cut from the same cloth. But for what is done particularly well here: for those who have especial difficulty with such fare, this could be a relatively fair point of entry, and it's definitely gratifyingly strong at large.

The plot bears familiar strains of small town corruption, with bad guys taking advantage of the innocence, virtue, and peace of ordinary folks. That's perfectly fine, though, for it's a compelling story even if it smacks of something we've seen before. Furthermore, this rendition can boast a couple small details that help it to stand apart a little bit, with the result that the film is even more engaging, and even genuinely thrilling. More, perhaps, than some comparable titles, there are a lot of action sequences here, and Joseph Kane's practiced direction realizes them all with terrific finesse, stunts included. Even where action is sidelined, any lighter (and cheesier) moments are counterbalanced by harsh drama that's decidedly a bit more dreary than what we've gotten from some of this picture's brethren. It's a credit to screenwriters Karen DeWolf and Stuart Anthony that 'Saga of Death Valley' kind of bucks the trend of Rogers' other features and focuses so squarely on a more robust notion of storytelling. Why, I might go so far as to say that while the presentation here is emphatically curt, the substance of the narrative is just as meaningfully absorbing as what we might hope for from any western of the years to follow.

The chief weakness, I think, is in the editing. Sound (including music on the soundtrack) cuts abruptly and roughly at no few points, or even prematurely before the sequencing of the imagery catches up. Lester Orlebeck's editing in the latter capacity is less glaringly faulty but still far from perfect, primarily in that it's simply overzealous. Not least during action scenes, we sometimes get such a rapid-fire burst of movement from shot to shot that the value of each is dampened; it's the same deficiency that plagues even modern action flicks, substituting the empty flash of the cutting room floor for the major impact that a melee strike, stunt, or effect could have if we actually, fully saw it. Seeing as how this clocks in at under an hour, the picture would have lost nothing whatsoever if even just a scattered few shots were allowed to linger longer, letting us truly soak them in. On the other hand, much more so than not this is quite well made. Jack A. Marta's cinematography is active and dynamic, a credit to his skill, and all the crew behind the scenes put in good work. The production design, art direction, costume design, hair and makeup work, and props are all just as splendid as we expect from the genre, helping us get into the spirit of the Wild West. It may be kitschy at times, with a couple weak spots in the writing, and the editing is troubled. Yet far and away 'Saga of Death Valley' is a much better and more satisfying film than I'd have possibly assumed sights unseen.

Anyone who has difficulties abiding older films, westerns, or this picture's kin may not have their minds changed strictly speaking, though it's possible that this title is just different enough that it could serve as a gateway. For wider audiences, however, I believe this 1939 feature is so well done, engrossing and even exciting, that it does, indeed, stand tall and remain quite worth watching even more than 80 years later. Don't feel like you need to go out of your way for it, but if you have the opportunity to watch, I'm as surprised as anyone at just how solid 'Saga of Death Valley' is, and I'm pleased to say it earns my hearty recommendation!