For the Common Defense! (1942) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Saludos Amigos!
planktonrules20 November 2013
One seldom talked about part of the American war effort that most people today probably don't know about is our so-called 'Good Neighbor Policy'. What this meant is that the US wanted to strengthen ties with Central and South America because there was concerned that some of these nations MIGHT join the Axis powers or covertly assist them. A part of this program included encouraging American movie makers to visit these countries if possible or at least make films about these countries. This explains why Twentieth Century-Fox made quite a few musicals set in South America (such as "Down Argentina Way") as well as which featured Carmen Miranda. It also explains why Disney made some rather boring features like "Saludos Amigos" and "The Three Caballeros"--and part of this process included Walt himself taking his executives and other employees on a very lengthy tour of South America. In light of all this, "For the Common Defense!" makes a lot of sense--though, compared to the rest of MGM's Crime Does Not Pay series, it was definitely sub-par.

Most of this film is set in Chile and a bit is set in Columbia. However, being a short film, MGM didn't send the crew to the continent nor did they hire South Americans. No, it's a sound stage-bound film with gringos filling in for Chilean officials. Additionally, the film is interesting because it's one of Van Johnson's first films--and he has BROWN hair, not his usual red.

The film is about, what else, evil Axis agents in South America who are trying to stir up trouble and sabotage. The German and Japanese agents were, naturally, evil BUT destined to fail. After all, this was clearly intended as a propaganda film to bolster the American resolve--and it really, really was needed in early 1942 when this one debuted.

The movie is fairly enjoyable but no more. It is a bit preachy and I personally preferred the gangster baddies you used to find in the shorts before the war began. Still, it's not bad viewing.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
"I wish we had this system in the United States"
boblipton24 May 2019
A retired gangster hiding out in Chile gets roped into working with Nazis counterfeiting Colombian money in this wartime CRIME DOES NOT PAY two-reeler.

John Litel is the Chilean policeman who touts the system of universal registration that makes tracking down bad guys so easy, and who gets to shoot the bad guys. Van Johnson also appears as dark-haired US agent. It's wartime propaganda, intended to tout cooperation between the governments of the Western Hemisphere.

Although this series had begun as an interesting experiment and produced some fine melodrama, by this point it had lost much of its early zip. This one feels like a feature cut down to only the scenes and dialogue that serve to advance the plot.... and give the good guys the chance to shoot the bad guys.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed