Mickey (1948) Poster

(1948)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Nothing more calculating than teenagers setting the parent trap.
mark.waltz10 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
How do you prevent a widowed parent from marrying somebody you really can't stand that you know will turn their world upside down? Try to find somebody else, of course, and for teenaged tomboy Lois Butler, the snooty town busybody Rose Hobart just won't do. There's not only the fact that she hates Hobart's geeky son (Leon Tyler), but the fact that Hobart, a still attractive widow, acts as the moral finger-wager for their entire small town. When a heartbroken former resident (Irene Hervey) returns from New York, Butler instantly sees that she would be a perfect step-mom and sets up a dinner date for Hervey with her very busy doctor father (Bill Goodwin) present. Goodwin has been spending most of his free time with Hobart so Butler knows she must move fast, or face the unacceptable consequences.

This variation of an old Deanna Durbin style plot has the singing Butler performing such familiar tunes as "Some Day My Prince Will Come" and "If You Were the Only Boy and I was the only Girl", going from a base-ball playing tomboy to dress wearing singer. In one scene, her baseball pals suck on lemons outside the window where Butler is practicing her singing so she can loose her voice and thus be free to play baseball. In another scene, she gets into a fight with pal Skip Homeier while Tyler is playing his violin in a crowded auditorium, literally interrupting his performance by flying out onto the stage with a thud. The mixture of music and comedy keeps the film moving at a brisk speed and provides a combination of grins and laughs, as well as a few minor groans.

Delightful in one of her last screen appearances as Goodwin's devoted cook, Hattie McDaniel acts as a mother figure to Butler and provides more than just a stereotypical characterization. It is obvious that she is as important a part of their family, even though she reminds Goodwin of his responsibilities as a father and of the fact that she has her own family that she needs to look in on. A great scene has Butler telling the crowded auditorium audience off for gossiping about her without knowing all the facts, and it is satisfying to see Hobart crunching down in her chair, knowing that she's the culprit behind it all when they applaud her moxie.

The Tru-Color is faded, a cheap alternative to Technicolor that the minor studios used in the mid-late 40's. These films don't hold up as well to look at, and might have been better suited in black and white, although you must give the poverty row studios credit for trying to move on technically. "Mickey" isn't a story you haven't been seen before, but entertainingly done, it is one that can be enjoyed with the benefits of a mostly obscure cast doing quite well in spite of the less than high budget.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Tomboy with a Voice
Sylviastel20 May 2014
Lois Butler made her film debut in the title role. She lives with her father and housekeeper Bertha (played by Oscar winner Hattie McDaniel. Of course she plays the maid and perhaps Mickey's mother figure in the story. Mickey is a tomboy who prefers to play baseball than take piano and voice lessons. She tries to set her father up with her neighbor's single aunt because she doesn't like her father's taste in women. This is fine melodrama with decent acting. The writing could be better. The quality of the screen color is poor between black and white and color. It's too dark in some scenes. You can't even tell whether it is black and white or early color. I don't hold it against the film.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Mickey the tomboy discovers boys!
planktonrules16 May 2021
When you watch "Mickey", don't expect much when it comes to the color. This is because like many B-movies of the late 40s and early 50s, they used Cinecolor. Cinecolor was a two-color process which produced a noticeably inferior look compared to three-color Technicolor because it didn't exactly have true color*...and some colors, such as blues, purples and yellows don't look right. And, over time, Cinecolor tends to degrade and turn the print orange-green. So why did they pick Cinecolor anyway? Well, it was cheap...about the same price as black & white film stock....and MUCH cheaper than a full colored print.

When the story begins, you see that Mickey is a tomboy....a girl who would rather play baseball than go on dates or sing....though she does have a lovely singing voice. However, through the course of the film it becomes obvious that this teen is starting to notice boys...and her father's lady friend (Irene Hervey) offers her help in changing her style and attracting boys. Unfortunately, the small town has a busybody. Mrs. Matthews and her son, Robbie, are backbiters and do their best to make Mickey out to be some sort of skank...which she clearly isn't. Plus, this awful woman has designs on Dr. Kelly (Mickey's dad)...as they both are spouseless. Is dad going to wise up or are they destined to marry this hellish woman and make her Mickeys step-mom?!

This is a generally enjoyable and sweet coming of age film. It is hindered by some occasional poor writing...especially with how Mickey's father is written. He seems a bit too stupid and is quick to believe the worst of his lovely daughter...which is especially so since he's a doctor! But Mickey was written well and the story works well despite a few minor hiccups.

As for Mickey, Lois Butler was very good and it's a shame she made so few films and TV appearances. I have no idea why, as she seemed like a great successor to Deanna Durbin, who was no longer young enough to play these sorts of roles.

One final note. The nice lady who helps Mickey is played by Irene Hervey. For some reason, an internet meme which has spread far and wide (and often) and posts a photo of Irene Hervey...saying it's Irene Ryan (who played Granny on "The Beverly Hillbillies"). This is stupid...they look nothing alike and each time I've seen the post, it shows an autographed photo...one that says IRENE HERVEY on the signature! Oh, those dumb social media rumors!!

*There were several other two color processes, such as Two-Color Technicolor and TruColor. Amazingly, TruColor, despite its name, is anything but true!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Charming, seemingly "lost" souvenir of a bygone era.
sdiner825 December 2002
Back in the '50s, before the major studios released their old movies to TV, several so-called "poverty row" companies (Republic, Monogram, PRC, etc.) filled the void with the television equivalent of "garage sales" of their low-budget 'B' products. Because of the paucity of old movies on TV in that era, a number of these films were shown over and over again--and proved, to viewers' delight, that an economy budget didn't necessarily spell mediocrity. Case in point: Eagle-Lion's sprightly "Mickey," a thoroughly disarming tale of a feisty teenaged tomboy coming of age in small-town America. A charming young actress with a lilting soprano voice, Lois Butler played the title role, supported by such pros as Bill Goodwin as her understanding widowed Dad, and the always-lovely Irene Hervey as their next-door neighbor. The likeable Skip Homeier supplied additional charm as Mickey's highschool crush, and the magnificent Hattie McDaniel added her customary zing as--what else?--the wisecracking housekeeper. Released the same year as MGM's glossy, big-budget, all-star "A Date with Judy" (1948), "Mickey" was no match for that MGM blockbuster but exudes its own unpretentious charm. A dated artifact of its era, to be sure, but nevertheless a breezy, endearing portrayal of the trials and tribulations of small-town teenagers way back when. Films like "Mickey" shouldn't be ridiculed and forgotten but cherished and enjoyed for their candy-coated portrayal of a bygone era. A la Jane Powell, Ms. Butler even gets to sing a few tunes (most memorably "Someday My Prince Will Come") and the pleasing production is further enhanced by the pasteled Cinecolor cinematography. A modest, beguiling treat--long overdue for a re-discovery and restoration (are you listening, TCM?)
17 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Rote
boblipton16 November 2023
Lois Butler is 14, transitioning from being a tomboy to being in love. Her mother is dead, and father Bill Goodwin speaks every line like a radio announcer. Between trying to make sure he doesn't marry Rose Hobart and stopping the movie so she can sing a song -- she does a nice version of "If I Were The Only Girl In The World", it looks like a by-the-numbers movie by people who have no sense of how people behave, but have seen every Andy Hardy and Henry Aldrich movie, and have a contract with Eagle-Lion, working its way out of its PRC origins.

Despite an interesting cast that includes Irene Hervey and Hattie McDaniel, it never attempts to exceed its rote expectations, despite a script by Agnes Christine Johnston.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Refreshing and memorable treat
gdavenport24 August 2004
I love this movie. I saw it when I was a kid and then again many years later. It holds up quite well. The performances are very sincere, and I will never forget Hattie McDaniel, in the kitchen, putting vanilla extract behind her ears for perfume. I also love the muted color photography and the title song. Lois Butler is great, and she has wonderful support from the rest of the cast, especially Irene Hervey. It was also the first film I saw featuring Skip Homeier who continued in movies for many years, mostly in western roles. This 1948 film reminds me of those wonderful days when I would go to the neighborhood theatre for a Saturday matinée and live alongside all the characters on the screen.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great reviews, thanks
aatpct29 April 2010
Lois is my aunt. She was my favorite person. She would always sing to me when I was young, she always had a beautiful smile and I loved her very much. I am so happy that people liked "Mickey", I thought it was a darling movie. Thanks for all the positive responses. She was also married to Hall Bartlett, producer of "Jonathon Livingston Segull". He was a gorgeous man with steel blue eyes and black wavy hair. He wanted her to continue her career but she wanted to have children and raise a family. She married a wonderful man after Hall. He was a dentist. They moved into a great home that had been owned by Chuck Conners previously.
16 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Another fond memory from childhood days.
negevoli-4430 June 2000
Like "Montana Mike," another childhood film I loved, "Mickey" was avidly watched by my brother and me as children in the early days of television. I don't remember it in detail, but it used to be aired fairly frequently and my brother and I would both eagerly anticipate its broadcast. I do remember that Mickey was a "tomboy" and we both thought "Mickey" was the greatest. I think children today might enjoy it too, although I am not so sure that it would stand up for me as an adult. But who knows? It should be released on video if only as a cinematic artifact of a more charming and innocent period in American history.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Much Better Than I Expected
randwolfray10 September 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I will never forget the time when, after looking at some color photos from the 1930s, it suddenly dawned on me that people who lived in the '30s actually experienced those years in color! I guess watching black-and-white movies from that era had subconsciously conditioned me. Well, the charming movie "Mickey" reminds us that the late '40s were in color, too!

I got this movie in a Shirley Temple collection I bought in the bargain bin at Wal-Mart for five bucks. The fourth disk had some unrelated films which Mill Creek Entertainment thought Shirley Temple fans would like, and "Mickey" was one of them. The print and the audio were atrocious, but I can overlook that as long as the story and acting are good, and boy are they good in this movie! Like other reviewers have said, it needs to be cherished as a reminder of what life was like once upon a time here in America; but it is more than that as well.

The plot has plenty of twists and turns to keep you watching. Just when you think the action is pretty much over, something new turns up. And it has some humorous lines as double entendre that we find unexpected for that era (which I won't mention here to avoid being a spoiler, but see if you can find them).

I doubt if young people today could relate to this film, except those broadminded enough to realize that if they hopped into a time machine and went to 1948 things would be different. And that is why I like to watch old movies that are not considered "classics." Because they are not so artfully crafted, forgotten films sometimes reveal more of what real life was like. I hope you get to watch this film and enjoy it as much as I did, and may a remastered DVD be available soon.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed