Battle Zone (1952) Poster

(1952)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Korean War drama
blanche-219 November 2015
John Hodiak, Stephen McNally, and Linda Christian are on a "Battle Ground" from 1952, produced by Allied Artists, a poverty row company. The film also features Martin Milner and Jack Larson, both of whom recently died.

Danny (Hodiak) is a Marine, a vet of WW II, who re-enlists to fight the Korean War. He's a combat photographer and joins a photo unit. To his dismay, his rival, Mitch (Stephen McNally) is on board as well. Jeanne (Linda Christian), a nurse with the Italian Red Cross, stands in between these former friends.

Mitch, in fact, is now engaged to her. Danny keeps trying, however.

I have to say I found this a pretty friendly rivalry. Danny made no bones about trying to get Jeanne back, and a secure Mitch took it with good humor. They also worked very well together, at one point going behind enemy lines.

Lots of battle sequences -- it moved along but was still on the boring side.

Jack Larson, who went on to play Jimmy Olsen on "Superman," was a dear friend and a wonderful man. He's adorable here. It's sad that Jimmy wrecked his acting career, but he went on to produce and write librettos. I wish he'd written a book; he had the most wonderful stories.

Martin Milner is also easily recognized by Baby Boomers, thanks to "Route 66." He worked in movies from the time he was a teenager.

Hodiak and McNally both gave good performances. Linda Christian, despite the ads for the film, isn't in it all that much. She was a real beauty with a gorgeous figure, and also very intelligent. In 1952 she was married to Tyrone Power, and their wedding in Rome in 1949 was bigger than any celebrity wedding we see today, getting a full spread in Life magazine, and coverage everywhere, with 10,000 people outside the church. Cruise and Holmes married in the same place and there 1000 people outside the church.

Just so-so; all of these people made better films.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Aired on Pittsburgh's Chiller Theater in 1970
kevinolzak3 April 2013
1952's "Battle Zone" came from Poverty Row's Allied Artists, a Korean War programmer featuring native Korean Philip Ahn (Master Kan on KUNG FU) fighting the good fight in one of Hollywood's earliest efforts on the Korean front. There is the usual love triangle, between John Hodiak, Stephen McNally, and Linda Christian, compensated by the main storyline focusing on the filmmakers responsible for taking the battlefield footage, risking their lives right alongside the soldiers. Linda Christian, one of Mexico's loveliest exports, was just rekindling the career that began with "Tarzan and the Mermaids," while Stephen McNally went on to play the villainous one eyed Count opposite Richard Greene and Boris Karloff in "The Black Castle." Many of these early Allied Artists titles have been difficult to find, as Monogram was trying to upgrade their stature, despite the continuation of the Bowery Boys series. Curiously, this war picture was among five that aired on Pittsburgh's Chiller Theater during the 1969-70 season, alternating between straight films, often Italian, and more typical genre fare. Ironically, "Battle Zone" turned out to be the very last non horror item broadcast that year, on April 18 1970, paired with Larry Buchanan's "Zontar the Thing from Venus." Linda Christian's best known horror title, "The Devil's Hand," from Crown International, was a far more frequent guest on Chiller Theater.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Smile, you've been killed in action!
hollywoodshack29 September 2020
As much as bronco riders hate to see rodeo clowns because they show up after injuries, combat photographers held the most hated jobs in World War 2 since they took photos of troops killed in action. So, it seemed a stretch to make a film about heroic combat photographers. I found the frequent grinning of Hodiak and McNally uncomfortable from the start. They certainly defy logic to run on the battlefield with large 1920's era cameras, giving away locations of their own eagerly while they photograph secret enemy locations. Linda Christian is given the romantic interest of someone you might meet 15 minutes waiting to see the doctor only once, never to be seen again. No hugs, kisses, come on brave boys, you can do better than that!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
One more rocker
bkoganbing6 November 2013
John Hodiak and Stephen McNally star as a pair of Marine combat photographers who are sent to Korea and the war seems just a big old bit of hijinks for them. McNally stayed in the corps and is now a sergeant. But Hodiak left after World War II and re-enlisted. But before that made sure he came back in as a sergeant with one more rocker on his sleeve. That is a bone of contention between him and McNally, but it's far from the only one.

They're also rivals over an Italian nurse they met in World War II, Linda Christian. Now I'm not aware of any Marines in the Italian theater in World War II, but this is a B film from Allied Artists. These two keep trying to top themselves to impress her.

The climax is when the two and their unit get stuck behind the lines and get some great footage the better when Matt Ridgeway starts retaking territory. It's all on the GI Joe level of combat.

I wasn't expecting much and was not disappointed with Battle Zone.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
From The Halls of Montezuma's Revenge to the Shores of Triple Cheese
seaslug-535896 June 2023
Unrealistic cheesy film, but as a former Marine who was once stationed at Camp Pendleton, I enjoyed seeing it along with the real archival combat footage dubbed in this movie. Unmentioned is the short life expectancy of USMC combat photographers. My father led a 14-man USMC combat photography squad in WW II through Saipan, Guam, and Okinawa. They were all KIA except for my father who was WIA on Okinawa having been shot through his shoulder and sent to a field hospital. I wonder if he ever saw this movie but I doubt it; he tried to forget his wartime memories. Because of his experience, when I announced on my 17th birthday that I was joining the Marines, my father exclaimed "congratulations son! You're joining the world's largest suicide squad!" I still have his Purple Heart medal, the only thing he kept after 4 years in the Corps.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The plot sucks, but what a wealth of Korea Era uniform details.
caters200128 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Silly plot right off the bat and from a Marine standpoint, so many little details as to make you want to slap the technical advisor.

MSgt introduces himself to a corporal with his first name... Same corporal giving the top ranking MSgt dating advice.... PSgt saying derogatory things about a senior SNCO in front of the class. One Marine PFC in the first barracks scene wearing a web rifle sling as a belt with his khaki trousers. Guess they just flat ran out of web belts on all of Pendleton that day.

Love the combat footage from the combat in Seoul and elsewhere in Korea. Some thrown in from WW2 island battles, but I figure they thought in 1952, the public wouldn't know the difference. Great footage of the Chosen Reservoir campaign. I do 1/6 scale USMC historical figures and this pic I'd never seen is a wealth of research material.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Korean War on a Budget
gordonl561 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
BATTLE ZONE – 1952

This Korean War film is about a group of combat photographers and the dangers they face. John Hodiak and Stephen McNally are WWII vets sent to Korea to teach the new bunch how it is done.

The soldiers are soon shipped to Korea and take part in the UN attack to retake South Korea. It follows the team up into North Korea, and then the retreat back south after the Red Chinese launch their counter-offensive.

After the front has more or less settled down, the team is sent out on a secret mission to film Chinese preparations for further attacks. Needless to say this does not come off as planned, and the group has to fight their way back to UN lines. Of course they manage to bring out the needed footage with them.

Also in the cast are Martin Milner, Dave Willock, Carleton Young, Philip Ahn, and in an early bit, Charles Bronson. Linda Christian plays the love interest, who gets between Hodiak and McNally.

While not a barn-burner by any means, the pace is keep moving by veteran B-film helmsman, Lesley Selander.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
weak war film
SnoopyStyle28 May 2023
During the Korean War, Danny Young (John Hodiak) and Mitch Turner (Stephen McNally) are Marine war photographers fighting over Red Cross nurse Jeanne (Linda Christian). The war lasts longer than expected especially after the Red Chinese.

This is a weak war film. I don't care about these characters. The actors are non-descript. They don't have much charisma. The story is uninspiring. The combat scenes are either stock footage or weak action. I do like some of the stock footage, but the action filming is pretty weak. I'm guessing they filmed this in California. Maybe they're higher up for the snowy scenes.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Something or nothing
Marlburian8 January 2022
I've just watched this on the Fast32 streaming service. Very ordinary as war films go, though there's the novelty that it's about a Marine team that films combat action, sometimes with little regard for their own safety. Did they really use those clunky stills cameras?

The love interest was contrived, and I was unconvinced that the footage they took behind the lines would have been of much use.

John Hodiak and Stephen McNally do well enough.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed