User Reviews

While the series is pretty dated, and occasionally politically incorrect, it is an exuberant romp. Robert Newton's performance has always struck me as the definitive interpretation of the role. The production values for 1950s TV were actually pretty good. The script writing is fairly good, and the stories weather well. Some episodes are truly excellent,for example "Execution Dock" which contains a great, extended, surreal dream sequence that has rarely been equaled. I recently obtained a copy of the DVD set for my children (8 and 6) to watch, and they are entranced. I found that interesting, since their only previous exposure to the "pirate" sub-genre had been the "Pirates of the Caribbean" franchise, but the lack of special effects, and Johnny Depp silliness didn't not seem to cause any problem.

As a kid I watched this on local TV and found it very amusing. In my single digits I rarely paid attention to the perceived budgetary constraints on a film or TV series. I've always loved Robert Newton -no matter what he was in. He carries on his excellent interpretation of Stevenson's one-legged con man. Prior to the series he did a feature film, Return to Treasure Island,(1954), also starring later star Rod Taylor (Yup, he was an Aussie) as Israel Hand no less! The film segued into the series. Newton and Gilchrist stole the series with no effort. Sadly the budget was the demon here. The sets looked like cardboard and you rarely ever saw one of their ships (unless stock footage was used, and the costumes usually look like they were created by a teacher for a sixth grade play. Take a look at the governor's uniform in one episode. Hell they couldn't even afford a parrot! Looking at it nearly 50 years on it's still a lot of fun with spirited performances and well paced direction. Will today's kids, brought up on crap like the Pirates of the Caribbean "franchise" with it's naive premise and foppish "captain", not to mention the typical overuse of CGI go for this? I doubt it, as it requires them to listen and think - besides, it has a plot!

I remember watching an episode of this when I was about 4 back in 1957 in black and white. There was a scene with a skeleton lying in a clearing with a cutlass through it's chest and a chorus of pirates chanting "Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum" To this day I remember being absolutely terrified and running out of the lounge into the kitchen where I hid behind my mum's legs! I think it has to be my earliest memory!

Watched the whole series in 1985 when it was re-shown on Saturday afternoons and loved Robert Newton as Long John, but my favourite character was Purity Pinker (Connie Gilchrist).

Great adventure stories like those of Robert Louis Stevenson have long provided fine, literate and meaty projects for the Hollywood Screen. We have seen multi versions of TREASURE ISLAND. The version which comes to mind to many first of is the MGM Production with Wallace Beery as Long John Silver and Jackie Cooper as Jim Hawkins. (That's pronounced 'Awkins!) There was a European version done in 1972 with Orson Welles giving us his interpretation of the peg-legged pirate.

But it was Walt Disney (Himself) who gave us perhaps the most memorable rendition. His Production of TREASURE ISLAND (Walt Disney Productions/RKO Radio Pictures, 1950); that is considered to be tops. In it we saw Bobby Driscoll as Jim Hawkins and Brit Robert Newton playing the central role of Long John Silver. Arguably, this Disney Film is the best version; but as to who gave us THE definitive characterization of Long John belongs to Mr. Robert Newton, hands down!

It would appear to be no small feat in winning the Silver Sweepstakes. He after all, beat out two of the most prestigious names in Cinematic History to do so. Wallace Beery had been in films ever since 1913. That first hiring was for the Essanay Company's comedy films and a supporting role for Gloria Swanson. But his film career and roles were widely diverse and was a natural progression from his experience on Broadway and in traveling Stock Companies. And a 2 year hitch with a Circus preceded that.

Orson Welles, of course, was the Boy Genius of 1930's Stage and Radio; before getting everything he wanted from RKO Radio Pictures in a super huge deal following his famous and infamous Mercury Theatre Radio Production of WAR OF THE WORLDS CBS Radio, 1938). Little projects such as CITIZEN KANE (Mercury Productions/RKO Radio PIctures, 1941) and the likes of THE MAGNIFICENT AMBERSONS (Mercury/RKO, 1942) followed.

But the enormously talented Mr. Welles gained a mortal enemy with the release of KANE in the person of real life Newspaper Tycoon, William Randolph Hearst. Mr. Hearst, "boyfriend" of Film Actress Marion Davies and a dabbler in film himself, did his best to make life miserable for Orson and Welles went from Wonder boy to wanderer in a few short years. You see KANE was obviously based on Hearst's life and notoriety.

He did some more of 'his' own Films, like THE STRANGER (1946). He otherwise accepted a variety of roles (like this Long John Silver part in 1972). Her always took his acting and film making seriously; giving his all, no matter the movie.

SO that leaves Robert Newton, who other than his Long John Silver portrayals (2 Theatrical Films and the "ADVENTURES OF LONG JOHN SILVER" TV Series, 1955), is probably not very well known; certainly not as familiar to the public as Messer. Beery and Welles were and still are. But a search of his credits would reveal a cornucopia of great work, much of it in British Noir films in the Post War years. Our recommendation is his role in ODD MAN OUT (Two Cities Films/U.F.A./Universal Pictures, 1947); which is a drama about the Irish Republican Army and the Struggle for Independence starring Mr. Newton and James Mason.

That his L.J. Silver was impressive and memorable is surely an understatement. Newton probably was the single most powerful presence in the Disney Production. The memorable Tour-de-Force could not limit itself to the one film and begged to be reprised. A non-Disney LONG JOHN SILVER (Treasure Island Pty, Ltd./ Distributors Corporation of America, 1954) from an Australian company followed. The same company hatched the idea of TV and THE ADVENTURES OF LONG JOHN SILVER was born in 1955.

Like all other adaptations to the small screen and ½ hour weekly series format, LONG JOHN underwent somewhat of a metamorphosis. The downsizing of length and the slashing of budget rendered of necessity a new, episodic & continued story, though by no means a serialized 'Cliff Hanger'. The former Pirate became a sort of Crusading Trouble Shooter. The situations encountered were not so different from those of a Detective story or a Western; albeit in a very different setting. In this case, if my memory serves my well, it was at least part of the time, back in Merry Olde England of the 17th or 18th Centuries. The stories involved others like Jim Hawkins (Kit Taylor).

Much like so many of the other of those 1950's series, it was Syndicated. Series in Syndication,such as THE CISCO KID, ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN, SEA HUNT and HIGHWAY PATROL still had their own sponsors. Often times the main Series Character would don at least one of the Commercial Messages for their Monetarily $ponsoring Benefactor$. Hence, we saw the likes of SEA HUNT's Mike Nelson (Lloyd Bridges) plugging Old Style Beer, Duncan Renaldo as the CISCO KID hawking "Tut-tut, nothing' but Butternut Bread" or George Reeves as SUPERMAN speaking about Kellogg's Corn Flakes or Sugar Frosted Flakes.

In the case of LONG JOHN SILVER, it was no different. The series did this obligatory commercial shtick. But even then, there was a slight variation; which brought the whole character identification with $ponsor'$ product to a much higher plane. Just picture this: We have Robert Newton sitting in some seaport café; when, with his heavy Cockney Accent and exaggerated facial expressions he bellows, " I BE LONG JOHN SILVER AND I ALWAYS DRINKS DEAN'S MILK!"* Honest Folks, it really happened, Scouts Honor! And you haven't lived until you've heard this with your own ears.

You should put it on your Bucket List!

NOTE: * Dean's Milk was the sponsor in Chicago, but the name could be different in another market. The same was true for THE CISCO KID, as "Butternut Bread" was a name owned by Interstate Bakeries; but other names were used outside the Windy City area.

POODLE SCHNITZ!!

Although the editing and colour is pretty ropey. Fans of British actor Robert Newton in his classic role as British pirate turned semi-respectable citizen Long John Silver, will want to see more of him in this vintage TV series. Six episodes from the series were released as a three video set in 1999 (in the United States).

Filmed in Australia before Australia themselves even had television, and created to air on ABC (the American one) in 1955, The Adventures of Long John Silver follows up on the previous two films of immense success with a budget family serial. The series sits at 26 episodes at length before cancellation, though only the first 13 were available to me, and looking online I couldn't find the others with relatively ease, some may be considered lost. Not as much of a shame as you might think, the series never made it to prime time, and wasn't even on the list for top 25 series in the seasons it aired. Again following the titular pirate captain Long John Silver after his adventures trying to find the famous Treasure Island, the series takes place after John has acquiesced to giving up piracy and joining a life of relative peace in the Caribbean. Each episode follows a new adventure as they need a young islanders tooth pulled, to recoup funds for a local tavern, or simply to rescue a far off sinking ship. The plots are simple and the acting and sets are simpler. Most of this series was shot in an inside studio and you can really tell (especially the "far off at sea" ship scenes. Halliwell's television companion even brings this up and gives the series a quaint review: "Cramped, studio-bound adventures of a rascally pirate, notable chiefly for preserving a famous star performance." And that's probably all you need, while it did re-enforce the famous pirate voice we now all expect from pirates everywhere thanks to the lead Robert Newton who played Long John Silver, if you must check out this performance I would highly recommend you instead just watch the original 1950 film Treasure Island. And honestly maybe even skip that one too.