City of Shadows (1955) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
An old dog teaches a new dog lots of old tricks.
mark.waltz1 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Veteran actor Victor McLaglen who goes back to the silent era commands the attention in this typically violent mid-1950's crime drama where he shows foster son John Baer how things were done in the old days while trying to reform his protection racket business as Baer strives to turn his life around and need a respectable life. Things become complicated when Baer becomes involved with Kathleen Crowley, the sister of his college pal Nicolas Coster and daughter of an influential judge. An accidental murder by cohorts of McLauglen's who don't want him to legitimize his business leads to all out war and a dandy shootout finale on a ski lift.

Veteran Oscar winner McLaglen is the main reason to tune in to this interesting crime drama that features mainly newcomers including future soap star and veteran character actor Nicolas Coster. Baer mixes the toughness of his street upbringing and the education that he has received to give an interesting performance that did not leave him into becoming a star. there are some moments that the plot line becomes a bit convoluted, but the script quickly gains back its momentum and keeps the audience glued through the almost comical shootout at the end that turns the ski lift into a snowy shooting gallery. It doesn't fail in its attempts to entertain, but it's one of dozens that is easy to forget even though it's not really forgettable.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Nice Big Slice Of McLaglen Ham
boblipton13 February 2024
Victor McLaglen is a marginal operator, about to be put out of business by the big-time crooks, when he catches a kid raiding his slot machines using slugs. He cuts a deal with the boy to do that to his competitors. Fast forward a dozen years later, and now McLaglen is the big man, and the kid, grown into John Baer, is about to graduate from law school, and already keeping McLaglen out of prison. But Baer meets Kathleen Crowley and her nice family, and decides he wants to be an honest man. McLaglen loves him, so he lets him go, and starts running into real trouble.

It's a role tailor-made for McLaglen as the big, sentimental slob of a crook, and under William Witney's efficient direction, it's a lot of fun in a stereotyped way, mostly due to McLaglen's hammy performance. With Anthony Caruso, Richard Travis and the voice of Art Gilmore.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Houston Branch could recycle with the best of them.
horn-510 December 2005
One only has to get about five minutes into the film before realizing that it is derivative of about two-dozen other films----low-ranking gangster adopts and educates a young street hoodlum only to have his protégé turn against him.

Dan Mason (Jimmy Grohman), a twelve-year-old newsboy, is an expert at figuring all the angles; so, when Kink (billed as Kay Kuter), veteran bartender at Billy's Steak House, catches him winning a big jackpot in the battered old slot machines that belong to seedy Tim Channing (Victor McLaglen), he not only defies them to do anything about it but shows Tim how he can corner the slot-machine racket and, at the same time, put his big-racketeer competitors Tony Finetti (Anthony Caruso) and Angelo Di Bruno (Richard Reeves) out of the running.

Thusly begins a partnership between the larcenous---but big-hearted---Tim and the precocious newsboy that lasts and prospers while he is growing up. (A plot premise not new then and still being used today.) Reaching college age Dan (now John Baer)studies law, showing a greater aptitude for finding loopholes in the law than an inclination to uphold it, despite the advice of his law-school Dean (John Maxwell) and the wholesome companionship of his roommate Roy Fellows (Nicolas Coaster), whose father (Charles Meredith) is a retired judge.

But Dan meets Roy's sister Fern (Kathleen Crowley)and his family, and the sincerity and friendliness of Roy's parents and the open adoration of Fern make him begin to work on the right side of the law instead of against it. So, after graduating from law school, Dan agrees to go to work for his old friend Tim...but only if it is honest work.

Tim promises him it will be, but then Finetti and Di Bruno show up from the old days and Tim is put into a compromising position..and things aren't going just exactly as Dan planned and Tim promised...oh, you've seen it several times and can finish it from here? Thought so.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not enough unintentional comedy to save this clunker
meaninglessname17 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is driven by one of the characters' supposedly brilliant schemes. Since these are either unexplained or senseless, and the rest of the script is dull and plodding, the simplest advice is "skip it."

Tim Channing (Victor McLaglen) catches 12 year old newsboy Dan Moran using slugs in a slot machine in his bar, but lets him go when Moran gives him a brilliant plan for taking over the town's rackets. The brilliant plan? An army of newsboys putting slugs in the other guys' slot machines. At least it's no less far-fetched than the later evidences of Moran's brilliant mind.

Ten years later, Channing, now mob boss, is putting the grownup Moran (John Baer) through law school, where he discovers an unspecified law that clears Channing of unspecified charges, and an equally mysterious one that prevents one of his henchmen from being extradited for murder.

But after graduation, Moran, now in love with a judge's high-class daughter, played with all the hauteur of a waitress in a diner by Kathleen Crowley, wants to go straight. He invents a new legitimate business, that makes no sense, for Channing, which is undermined for no reason in a way that makes no sense by Channing's associates. But don't worry, the DA's office is somehow gathering evidence by substituting pencils using a special lead in Moran's office.

Finally we get to a shootout on a ski lift (presumably because the makers of this cheapo epic had access to a ski lift), as incomprehensibly edited as the rest of the movie, and there it ends, as if a couple of guys getting shot ends everyone's legal problems.

Unfortunately the moments of unintentional comedy are too few, and the rest is just boring. There are tons of old movies available and this one is near the bottom of the list.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Standard "B" crime potboiler, a cut above many
aromatic-227 May 2000
This movie is so low-budget, and the cast generates so much goodwill, that you have to be kind to it. Plot is nothing special, but told with enough of a twist, and with enough smiles, that it deserves notice. Victor MacLaglen is marvelous as an aging thug, and Nicholas Coster makes a striking debut as a young law student. Nothing special, but it moves fast, and you'll have a bit of fun with the production values and stock footage.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
a '50's Gangster movie with all the low-budget trimmings
rollo_tomaso1 January 2001
Victor McLaglen has a ball as Big Tim Channing in this forgotten, yet enjoyable, 1950's gangster movie. With all the stand-by's (Frank Ferguson as crusading D.A., Paul Maxey as crooked lawyer, Anthony Caruso as a two-bit thug), this "B" actioner delivers what you would expect, and a bit more. It probably was intended to elevate the career of its lead, John Baer. As such pretty boys go, he's not too bad, but I never heard of him again. Still, it's a good way to kill an hour and change.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed