Rock, Pretty Baby! (1956) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Somewhat surprising JD fare
funkyfry30 October 2002
Relatively harmless Universal-International JD flick. Mancini supervised the music, which is mostly NOT rock and roll, as much as Saxon, Mineo, their girlfriends, and eventually hip parents shout that it is!

The quality of the photography is much higher than that of the film in general, reflecting U-I's overabundance of talent relative to its lowered late 50s production standards. This results in transforming the conceivably banal -- a beachside conversation with light "necking" -- into a fabulous play of light and shadows in the old Germanic tradition. Or, in other words, something truly lovely emerging from a pic that was meant to last a week.

Anyway, the film itself is pretty engaging, but much too long. Not enough thrills or "crazy" speeches to satisfy those strictly into JD "kicks", and not enough rock to really roll.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Teenage angst and rock and roll, tossed in with the fuddy duddies of the older generation.
mark.waltz28 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
It seems that the parents of the 1950's didn't understand their growing children, forgetting that they had once scandalized the older generation in their teens by swinging and jitterbugging. Here, the parents of guitar playing teenager John Saxon are King Kong's girlfriend, Fay Wray, and the future big boss of "Get Smart", Edward Platt. Handsome Saxon isn't interested in heading straight into college right after high school to study medicine, preferring to entertain with his rock and roll band with the winsome Sal Mineo on drums. A T.V. contest looking for the best teen rock band is the ultimate prize that Saxon is after, not a medical license. That's all there is for plot with the conflict between generations more understated confusion than any real gap. The movie really heads into Donna Reed/Brady Bunch territory with the novelty song, "A Picnic by the Sea".

The adults gets to say lines to the teens like, "Put on your shoes before your feet start to look like Idaho potatoes!" and "It's a good thing you didn't need a grand piano. You would have hocked the house!" The film is probably 65 percent music with moments of plot thrown into give the band a break. The songs aren't bad with "Can I Steal a Little Love?" having stolen my heart especially with Mineo's charm oozing off the screen as he winks his way into the audience's adoration with that winning smile. The real problem here is that these are simply just really nice kids, and considering what was going on was truly worse than even the toughest of conflicts here. At times, the film seems almost cartoonish with its goofiness and sweet natured view of teen life.

George "Foghorn" Winslow gets some great lines, insulting his older sister and desperate for attention from his parents and heroic older brother. At times, Saxon seems to be emulating a more clean-cut version of a young Brando, and when he has a heart-to-heart talk with dad, it is straight out of Andy Hardy territory as two different generations come to an understanding, admitting that really nothing changes in parent/children relationships but the date. That really proves the innocence behind the plot line even though there is a brief fight scene at a dance when Saxon's girlfriend Luana Patten shows up with another date after a misunderstanding. I just wish that Mineo had more to do than look cute. Some overly dramatic music tries to make the situations seem more serious than they are, but if my recollection serves me right, every problem I faced as a teenager seemed more dramatic than they probably really were. The dramatic moments which explode at the end seem forcibly inserted, twisting the light-hearted first two thirds into a very over the top last third, but it is very satisfying to hear Platt tell Saxon, "Sometimes it takes a father to grow up slower than his children".
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Rock, Pretty Baby was an okay teen/Rock 'n' Roll drama from the '50s
tavm25 March 2017
This is another of the '50s movies I've watched of late showcasing teens, Rock 'n' Roll, and the troubles they get into. John Saxon is the teen wanting to play guitar instead of studying medicine as his father-played by Edward Platt years before becoming Chief on "Get Smart"-did. His mother is Fay Wray-yes, the original damsel in distress in the original King Kong. Former Disney child actress Luana Patten is Saxon's girlfriend Joan. Sal Mineo, previously a friend of James Dean in Rebel Without a Cause, is one of Saxon's band members as is singer/songwriter Rod McKuen. Oh, and young emerging teen Shelley Fabares-several months before her role in "The Donna Reed Show"-is Saxon's little sister. The drama veers between pretty compelling to bland in spots. Still, it's worth a look if you're curious about seeing all the films of all I just mentioned above.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Typical Artifact Of It's Time
Brainy-24 November 2001
One look at the box cover, and you pretty much know what you're in for should you decide to rent this film. Lots of moralizing and stilted dialogue that's fairly typical of low budget youth oriented movies of this vintage. Like Leslie Neilsen, Ed Platt's overly serious deadpan delivery would prove to be much more effective when put to comedic purposes nine years later on "Get Smart."

Prolific actor John Saxon broods a lot, and comes across looking like an ersatz Marlon Brando. Luanna Patten, as his romantic interest, is equally as dour. Only the ever reliable Sal Mineo and the then 13-year-old Shelley Fabares seem to be genuinely enjoying themselves. Even when she has to perform such obligatory clichés as screaming "I'll never grow up if you keep treating me like a child!" and then running up to her room and crying, one gets the impression that she's in on the fact that this ain't exactly Shakespear, and is purposely camping it up. Her character is named "Twinkie" for gosh sakes!

Other than that, this film will be of interest to trivia buffs who might be surprised to know that before becomming the well known poet/songwriter, Rod McKuen actually had a brief film career in low budget productions such as this, and even gets to croon a tune while Saxon pretends to strum his guitar...One of the great running gags of this film is the fact that it is so obvious that the activity of his fingers never even remotely resembles the music emanating from his instrument. Sal Mineo, on the other hand, appears to be really playing the drums, A talent he would put to good use a few years later in the "Gene Crupa Story."
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Surprisingly good.
planktonrules7 November 2023
In the 1950s and 60s, Hollywood made a bazillion films geared towards teens and young adults. Most of them are, frankly, pretty poor...and they lack depth and good writing. However, surprisingly, I did like "Rock, Pretty Baby!"...and recommend it.

Jimmy (John Saxon) is a high school senior who is in a rock 'n roll band. But the guy has some problems. The first set of problems is his dad, the Doctor. Dad (Ed Platt) expects Jimmy to be a doctor one day and has little respect for Jimmy's music...and that's a problem since Jimmy needs an electric guitar and cannot afford one. Jimmy's girlfriend, Joan, is also a problem...and you'll just have to see the film to see what I mean.

I liked this film because the music is nice and the writing is excellent. Jimmy's family is NOT filled with cliched characters and you really care for and understand them. Well worth seeing...even if you are an old grouch like me!
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed