User Reviews

Being familiar with Yuri German's novellas, I have to admit that this movie does capture the tone and style of his books. Like most of his work, this movie tells a life story. It's of two people and few more that make the most impact on their lives. One is a boy, a young man who grows up to be a doctor. In love with a girl dreaming of becoming an actress. The man is one of honor and principles, so when a choice is to be made, he doesn't hesitate. However, she does. They get separated, then the war happens. They meet again and you can tell right away: they are in love. But, at the same time, extremely not sure of one another feelings. They get separated again and this time around, you can tell: this is an honest story - a chance for a happy end is as fat as it is in real life. The story goes on and not for a moment did I lose the sympathy for 2 main characters. The acting of 2 leads is very good. Batalov is young and handsome. He just made an impact with 2 movies that came out a year before (1956), one of which was The Cranes Are Flying. His task here is the personify The Soviet Man (yes, all 3 starting with capitals - TSM) - the moral beacon, the man of principles and honor. So, at times he can seem a bit stiff, but not for lack of talent or acting skills, I believe this is the honest portrayal of TSM. And the fact that you might disapprove or disagree, doesn't change it. Not much Soviet propaganda here, hence recommended to all interested in Soviet cinema of 1960s. 8/10