God Was in the West, Too, at One Time (1968) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Spaghetti with Paella Western co-produced by Italy and Spain , being starred by ordinary genre actors
ma-cortes17 March 2014
This ¨Anche Nel West Céra Una Volta Dio ¨ (1968) by Marino Girolami¨ is based on Treasure island , classic novel by Robert Louis Stevenson , it deals with a stranger (Folco Lulli , similar role Treasure island's Billy Bones) arrives in an inn and hides a treasure map the bandits wish . Being chased by outlaws suffers an accident , then a boy (Jack Hawkins-alike) witnesses where it was hidden and he gains access to a treasure map . The kid retrieves it and passes it on to the local preacher . Later on , he persuades a guide called Juan Chasquisdo (Gilbert Roland , lookalike Long John Silver) and a priest (Richard Harrison) , an innkeeper (Roberto Camardiel) to accompany him in his search to recover it. All of them are pursued by cutthroats (Raf Baldassarre). The priest recognizes that much of the treasure was likely that from a local mission. They set out to get it before the bandits encounter it.

This Paella/Spaghetti Western is filled with action , thrills , horse riding , intrigue , betrayal and crossfire . This Ravioli/Paella Western packs violence , shootouts , high body-count and it's fast moving and some moments genuinely entertaining if you can avoid thinking too much . It contains bits of campy and refreshing events with turns and twists . Nice acting by Gilbert Roland as a rogue thief sporting an iron hand instead of a wooden leg ; he starred some Spaghetti such as Sonora, Goldseekers , Johnny Hamlet and Any Gun Can Play . Richard Harrison's performance in the movie is a bit wooden for the role of such an interesting character , but the fantastic performance by the always great Folco Lulli and sympathetic Roberto Camardiel save the show . Furthermore , a motley group of usual Spanish/Italian secondaries such as Luis Barboo , Xan das Bolas , Jose Sacristan , Ennio Girolami , Raf Baldassarre , among others . Atmospheric cinematography by Pablo Ripoll, though being necessary a correct remastering , and features a sensitive musical score by Carlo Savina , including emotive songs . This is a passable Spaghetti Western with some amusing moments and nice outdoors shot in La Pedriza , Manzanares Del Real , Colmenar Viejo (Madrid) , and interior filmed in Elios studios (Rome) .

Strong and robust Richard Harrison was a magnificent muscle-man . He was one along with Ed Fury, Brad Harris, Kirk Morris, Reg Park, Mark Forest, among others, whom to seek fortune acting absurdly muscle mythological figures, but anybody topped Steve Reeves and Gordon Scott in popularity. Harrison played in Hollywood some minor roles as ¨Kronos ¨ and ¨South Pacific¨ , while shooting another inferior character in ¨Master of world (1961)¨ produced by American International , he met producer James H. Nicholson's daughter and married her within six months. Frustrated at not being able to secure meatier roles in America , Harrison jumped at the chance when offered the first character in 1961 ,¨The Invincible Gladiator¨ , which was filming in Europe along with his greatest success ¨The seven Spartans¨. He wound up settling in Italy for the next two decades. His lead role, of course, immediately typed him as another Herculean type and, to avoid being penned in too much as a muscle man, he sought characters in routine spaghetti westerns as ¨Texas the red¨ , ¨Gringo¨, ¨Reverendo Colt¨ , ¨Joe Dakota¨ ¨ ,even the main role from ¨For a fistful of dollars¨ was offered to Richard Harrison , but he turned down and explaining : Maybe my greatest contribution to cinema was not doing Fistful of Dollars, and recommending Clint Eastwood for the part . He also starred Wartime genre as ¨Leopards of Churchill¨ and ¨36 hours in hell¨ and spy intrigue as ¨Master stroke¨ and ¨077 challenge to the killer's¨ . Once Italy closed down film production after the muscular craze had died down, he, like others, found himself unemployed. He did manage to scrape up work in Hong Kong, but a large portion of them were bottom-of-the-barrel Ninja movies.

The film was professionally directed by Marino Girolami , under pseudonym Fred Wilson or Dario Silvestri , he is father of Enzo G. Castellari and Ennio Girolami who here appears as a nasty bandit and brother of Romolo Guerrieri . He was a craftsman working in all kind of genres as Western such as "Badmen of the West" ,"Two Ringos from Texas", "God Was in the West, Too, at One Time" and specially , Terror and comedies .

Other Spaghetti Westerns freely based on famous novels and plays are the followings : ¨Apocalypse Joe¨ by Leopoldo Savona with Anthony Steffen that takes elements about ¨Hamlet¨and ¨Macbeth¨ of Shakespeare . Other Spaghetti freely based on famous play by Shakespeare is ¨The Fury of Johnny Kid¨ by Gianni Puccini with Peter Lee Lawrence and Cristina Galbo from ¨Romeo and Giuletta¨ along with "Bullets and the Flesh" by Marino Girolami . Other Spaghetti based on known and classic plays and novels are the followings : ¨Johnny Hamlet¨(1968) with Andrea Giordana directed by Enzo G Castellari ; ¨The return of Ringo¨ by Duccio Tessari inspired on the ¨Odyssey¨, and ¨John Il Bastardo¨(1967) based on books from Zorrilla and Moliere ; ¨Long days of vengeance¨ by Florentano Vancini with Giuliano Gemma and Francisco Rabal , being based on classic novel titled ¨The count of Montecristo¨ written by Alexandre Dumas .
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
BETWEEN GOD, THE DEVIL AND A WINCHESTER (Marino Girolami, 1968) **1/2
Bunuel19769 February 2008
While nothing special in itself (and in spite of its portentous title), this one scores a few points for transposing Robert Louis Stevenson's classic pirate adventure "Treasure Island" to a Spaghetti Western landscape! Folco Lulli plays the Billy Bones figure – who sets the plot in motion; 'Long John Silver' is Gilbert Roland, sporting an iron hand instead of a wooden leg! Also involved are preacher Richard Harrison, while 'Jim Hawkins' is incarnated by a Mexican boy (who, naturally, befriends the roguish Roland).

Director Girolami (using the pseudonym Dario Silvestri), who dabbled in everything from comedy to action-oriented efforts, is the lesser-known father of cult film-maker Enzo G. Castellari (curiously enough, Roland co-starred in the latter's debut feature – ANY GUN CAN PLAY [1967] – which, incidentally, is also a Spaghetti Western). The film remains watchable, thanks also to a notable score from Carlo Savina; it does, however, include a couple of almost campy moments – one in which a badman is set on fire when a Mexican girl he has attempted to rape breaks a lantern over his head, but he takes care to repeatedly shoot her prior to expiring himself(!); another is when Roland's thin cigar is lit by a shot fired from the gun being handled by non-practitioner Harrison!
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Yet Another Roadish Treasure Hunt
cengelm19 May 2005
The film starts with a road and a covered wagon that apparently has all kind of household goods. The owner probably provides distant ranches with convenience products. For $10 he has accepted a passenger who will kill him soon. The passenger turns out to be a criminal Confederate colonel who has a map of a hidden treasure. In a conflict with outlaws he gets killed and a little boy and a "stranger" without a gun get hold of it. A typical treasure hunt with only partial knowledge about the location by each of the searchers through a wild mountain landscape is about to start. Gilbert Roland and Richard Harrison together with a mixed bunch including the outlaws are able to entertain the viewer and deliver both a good performance. There are a lot of nice and wild landscape shots and the score has at least average quality. On the downside there is a certain lack of credibility in more than one situation. E.g. before starting a treasure hunt I'd try to get rid of outlaws.

Recommended for Western and Adventure genre enthusiasts.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Between God, the Devil and a Winchester
Michael_Elliott9 April 2008
Between God, the Devil and a Winchester (1968)

** (out of 4)

Mildly entertaining Spaghetti Western is a variation on Stevenson's Treasure Island. In the film, an old man shows up with a treasure map and hires a bandit to take him to the location but the old man is killed during a shoot out. A kid and a peaceful man eventually get a hold of the map and once again the bandit is taking them to the location when more double crossing happens. There are several major plot holes with this film including the fact that bandits keep being used even though the characters know very well that this is just going to lead to trouble. Every time one of the bandits are killed it seems the group brings another in for help. Another problem is that the film is very poorly made and comes off looking incredibly ugly with some very bad camera-work. Some of the tracking shots in this thing are beyond bad. Even with all that said the film does have a few good moments and that includes one scene where a woman is being attacked by the bandit so she breaks a lantern over his head. Gilbert Roland, iron hand and all, is very good and keeps the film moving. Carlo Savina's music score is certainly the highlight of the film.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
God was in the West, too, at one time
Wuchakk11 September 2016
Released in 1968 and directed by Marino Girolami, "Between God, the Devil and a Winchester" (originally titled "God Was in the West, Too, at One Time") is an Italo oater starring Richard Harrison as a pacifist in the Southwest who obtains a map from a boy that leads to a treasure allegedly stolen from a mission. Several other people want the treasure too, like Juan Chasquisdo (Gilbert Roland), but likely for less noble purposes. The story's (supposedly) based on Robert Louis Stevenson's Treasure Island, which I've never read.

"Between God, the Devil and a Winchester" has the limitations of most Spaghetti Westerns, like dubious dubbing, awkward editing, laughable sound effects and caricatures rather than characters. But, if you can look beyond these flaws, it has several attributes, like the noble Harrison as the protagonist, which is in contrast to the amoral characters (caricatures) typical of Italian oaters.

The first act takes place at a Western Inn and is highlighted by the stunning Dominique Boschero as Marta. Dominique is so breathtaking she's almost worth the price of admission; unfortunately, she's removed from the story by the end of the first act. Roland as Chasquisdo is memorable, if for no other reason than the iron gauntlet on one hand.

The next two acts involve searching for and finding the treasure and aren't as good as the opening act. For one, there are a few nighttime sequences that are too dark to tell what's happening. But the ending is decent and satisfying. Too bad they omitted Marta from the last two acts.

The film runs 98 minutes and was shot in Spain.

GRADE: C+
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Rework of TREASURE ISLAND is a tedious Spaghetti
billywiggins196712 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Several problems plague this overlong, tedious flick. For one, it takes an ideal premise and draws it out interminably as to make it excruciating. Also, your protagonists are a motley, poorly-rendered bunch for the most part.

The story is a basic rework of TREASURE ISLAND. Transpose a literary classic to a new genre, I get it. Should be fun, right? A boy whose family runs a boarding house discovers a treasure map hidden by a traveling bounty hunter. The boy, along with his own old uncle, a dapper caballero, and a wandering preacher, set out across the mountains to find the gold. They must fight off a gang of roving bandits as well as their own paranoia and suspicions of each other. The story seems to take forever to get started, and once the crew gets started on their trek to find the treasure, nothing really happens for the next hour til the inevitable showdown.

An action/adventure film like this that centers around a little boy is going to rise and fall on the performance of the boy, and here, young Humberto Sempere as Tony is sniveling, wide-eyed, unlikeable. Plus, he is voiced in a shrill, broad manner by an obviously adult female actor. That alone kills the vibe of the flick from the get-go. Similarly, the boy's uncle is given a "goofy" characterization which is truly grating. Among the other leads is the blank-faced American Richard Harrison as Pat the Preacher, who has very limited, Chuck Norris-esque range, and who doesn't even show up until 30 minutes into the show. The best of the cast is the super-classy, mucho macho Gilbert Roland. Imagine the Dos Equis Guy with a pencil-thin John Waters-style mustache and a gaudy vest, that's him! Roland is dignified and sympathetic in all his parts, and to this one he brings subtle shadings to a shady gunslinger that is at heart a decent man.

Aside from Roland's performance, the other part of the film I enjoyed is the initial setup featuring bounty killer Folco Lulli coming into town, scoping out his next mark, killing an informant and an outlaw along the way. Lulli's character, however is killed off pretty quickly, setting the scene for annoying Tony to find the map and begin the main thrust of the pic's story.

Maybe the original Italian cut of this film favors the actors better than the English dub, but even if that's so, you'd still have to deal with the tedious pacing and lack of action. For the English dub anyway, I call it a generous 5/10 stars.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Great title
BandSAboutMovies14 June 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Between Between God, the Devil and a Winchester and the Italian title of this movie, Anche nel west c'era una volta Dio (God Was In the West, Too, At One Time), I think that it has my favorite Italian western title. And despite a tagline promising "A orgy of bloodletting that very few will survive," it's actually an adaption of Treasure Island but with horses and cowboys.

Directed by Marino Girolami (Zombie Holocaust) and written by Tito Carpi (Marta, Tentacles), Manuel Martínez Remís and Amedeo Sollazzo (Primitive Love, Two MafiosI Against Goldginger), this movie works, with the desert sands being the seas and outlaws taking over for pirates. Treasure remains treasure.

Future Godfrey Ho victim Richard Harrison plays Father Pat Jordan, who recognizes that the stolen gold belongs to a mission and makes the mission his. Gilbert Roland plays the Long John Silver - he has an iron arm instead of a wooden leg - as Juan Chasquisdo. There are even eyepatches and hooks for hands out here in the west.

Sadly, the movie doesn't ever really get exciting despite the two titles that it has. It's a boy's adventure when you need Italian westerns to be filled with blood.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Between God, the Devil and Gilbert Roland
seveb-2517926 July 2023
One of several Spaghetti Westerns featuring Gilbert Roland in the 1960s, and here he is the pivotal figure in the story, rather than being more of a sidekick, along to assist a younger hero. This one is a loose adaptation of Robert Louis Stevenson's "Treasure Island" with Gilbert in the "Long John Silver" role.

As usual, having an already "market tested" quality plot to build around is a big plus in a Spaghetti Western, and I have a hunch the longer European version of this (if such a thing ever existed) could well be a minor classic. However I watched the 98 minute American cut, which turns much of the final third into montages, in order move the story along quickly and fit the hour and a half running time preferred by distributors in America back in the 1960s and 70s. This sudden change in approach is quite jarring and serves to dissipate much of the films potential for drama and excitement. I'm imagining that a two hour version could have maintained a more consistent tone and allowed the story and characters to develop better (That's my theory anyway).

The first third is very good, with plenty of colourful rogues and scoundrels, along with the enchanting Dominique Boschero. As others have mentioned it's sad to see her bow out so soon. There is no significant girl in Treasure Island either, but, within a "Western" genre setting, I think she could easily have been accommodated, riding along in one of the wagons, causing manly blood to simmer.

Gilbert Roland arrives and easily dominates the screen with his typical roguish charm. As an Hispanic actor he was never allowed to achieve his full potential in Hollywood, so it is nice to see him getting some decent Spaghetti roles late in the day and enjoying an "Indian Summer" of sorts.

Richard Harrison is pretty underwhelming, possibly because he isn't given a lot to work with. Playing a former soldier turned priest who refuses to use a gun is not the ideal part to have in a non-comedy Spaghetti Western!

The second third is not quite as good as the first, with some poor and or illogical plot development, but still moves along adequately until the characters take refuge in an abandoned Inn (the equivalent of the stockade in Treasure Island). However about the time Richard Harrison heads out to look for supplies the montage scenes begin to kick in and sap the films momentum.

There's nothing fundamentally wrong with what happens in the final third, the expected fights and shootouts and double crosses are all there in the appropriate places, it's just the execution falls flat, it feels rushed, outlined and painted with a broad brush and lacking in emotional content (as Bruce Lee would have put it). Not that it's really bad or anything, just that it felt to me like it could have delivered a bit more than it did.

Still a very nice movie for fans of Gilbert Roland to enjoy

To the reviewer who wrote "My advice to fans killing time watching low-grade Italian genre crap: take some time to watch the hundreds of masterworks from Italy - you might learn something about the human condition from the artists and craftsmen ranging all the way from Antonioni through Zurlini."

In reply I say "I live with the human condition every day and I watch Spaghetti Westerns in order to take my mind off such things."
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not quite a treasure.
doctorsmoothlove21 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
"Between God, the Devil and a Winchester" certainly has an intriguing title and even an interesting premise. The film is an Italian Western adapted from the novel "Treasure Island," with the role of Long John Silver and the other pirates replaced with cowboys. Like the source material, this film version also has a little boy character. To see this movie today, you probably are going to watch a poor VHS rip whether on DVD or youtube.

Perhaps it's the boy which makes the tone so uneven. The opening third takes place before the treasure hunt in a bar where he lives with his mother. A fat man enters town seeking a guide to a buried treasure. The bar has the typical tough guy visitors you would expect to see. What I didn't expect was for the place to be burned to the ground! The fire appears to be real (not crazy given the time this was filmed) and the actors walk through the burning set. It's a tense, thrilling moment in this otherwise lackadaisical film. My only complaint here is the lovely Dominique Boschero who plays the barmaid-mother is permanently removed from the story. She doesn't do anything except look beautiful so why dump her?

The rest of the film is an "adventure" if you could really describe it as such. I jest because not a lot happens. The story plays out more like a hiking documentary with the occasional lackluster shoot out.The boy and his chaperone, a priest played by the stone-faced Richard Harrison, are crossed and doubled crossed regularly by bandits they encounter. The bandits agree not to bother them until the treasure is found. The best character is this film's Long John Silver: Gilbert Roland's brigand who plays both sides for his own reasons. The priest and Roalnd are eventually holed up in a cabin area while the bandits attempt to starve them out. Of course they get away, kill the bandits and get the treasure.

I can't figure out who this movie wanted its audience to be. Harrison and the boy have moments you would expect in a live action family movie yet the film is far too violent for a family audience. Likewise, the adult audience wanting an adventure is probably going to get bored. Coupling the weird tone with the bland cinematography and you would expect the movie to be a stinker. Yet, I don't think it is. There are a few scenes that are genuinely intriguing from a visual perspective and the character interaction isn't cheesy like some other Westerns with kids. I think of the film as similar to True Grit in that both are too sentimental to be profound yet entertaining.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Between Rod (Stewart), a Breville, and Manchester
Bezenby20 May 2016
Ha! I'm so dumb I didn't get the Treasure Island thing!

Richard Harrison (with moustache on loan to Burt Reynolds) is an ex-priest or possible still priest who ends up with a treasure map to some gold somewhere that was previously owned by some arsey old guy but is now sought after by bandits and a guy with an iron hand whom the film spends a massive amount of time pondering the question of whether or not the guy is evil or not. That sentence made complete sense I'm sure.

This guy is called Quisido or something and he says he's protecting Harrison and this young kid but then he's making deals with the bandits and Enzo Castellari's brother (who here seems to have dyed his hair and lathered on loads of fake tan, if that was him)...

Plot aside (it's the usual stuff), I can tell even through the crappy copy I've got that this is probably a really good looking film. Made by Enzo's dad but nowhere near as entertaining as Zombie Holocaust. Also, I have made fun in the past of Richard Harrison's inability to act (he can sure glare though), I still enjoy seeing him in a film and he's good as an action star, especially here where's he's sworn's he's never's to fire's a gun's.

https://wearecreosote.bandcamp.com/album/the-complete-guzzlinsauce
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Satisfying Italian Western
FightingWesterner27 October 2009
After much wrangling over a treasure map, mystery man (and pacifist!) Richard Harrison leads a group of men and a young boy in search of an ex-Confederate's stolen gold, battling bandits and eventually one another to be the last one standing.

Between God, The Devil And A Winchester is a great spaghetti western with lots of action and a satisfying adventure loosely based on Robert Louis Stevenson's Treasure Island.

Gilbert Roland is excellent as a wily wagon master with an iron gauntlet on his hand, who plays all sides and may or may not be a villain. His performance in this is an absolute pleasure to watch and makes up for any of the film's shortcomings.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Between boredom and tedium
Wizard-83 July 2012
The basic idea of "Between God, the Devil and a Winchester" - a reworking of the Robert Louis Stevenson classic novel "Treasure Island" - had a lot of promise. However, you wouldn't know it from seeing this movie. I usually love spaghetti westerns, even the lesser ones, but this one took a great effort for me to sit through. For starters, there is far less action than you might think. Most of the movie is devoted to the characters engaged in (boring) chat. The actors seem to be trying, but the unbelievably actionless plot leaves them pretty much helpless and unable to do much. And while Richard Harrison is prominently billed, for some reason he is put on the backburner for the most part while the less famous actors are given more to do. The filmmakers chose some good locations, and occasionally you get a taste of what a GREAT western adaptation could have been like. But otherwise, this movie will be a great waste of your time.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Aimed at the lowest of brows
lor_1 July 2023
Unreleased in the USA (except for an unauthorized latterday Something Weird dumping), this Italian Western is typical of those that chose to merely imitate American product rather than innovate. It's designed for movie fans who enjoy slumming, and judging by some verbose IMDb reviews, are easily impressed by ripoffs (in this case aping "Treasure Island").

It's sad watching a real Hollywood talent like Gilbert Roland reduced to such a nothing role.

My advice to fans killing time watching low-grade Italian genre crap: take some time to watch the hundreds of masterworks from Italy -you might learn something about the human condition from the artists and craftsmen ranging all the way from Antonioni through Zurlini.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed