The Snow Goose (TV Movie 1971) Poster

(1971 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
35 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A Great Story
mount2124 June 2008
This is a movie that truly showed the talents of Richard Harris and a newer actor, Jenny Agutter. I used this in a class I taught in high school. The tape did not survive, and I too would like to see this on DVD if at all possible. When I taught this, I used it in a unit called "Love, Loneliness, and Alienation." All three elements of the unit are evident in this story First, the loneliness of Richard Harris's character, the alienation he felt from his community, and the love that develops because of the snow goose.

The heartbreak that is the ending cannot be described in words, but the powerful message that is sent is worth the deep sadness that the viewer feels.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Quite simply - the perfect film
Fellwanderer7 August 2005
Having been brought up just a few minutes from the Essex sea marshes, this film has always had a special poignancy for me.

I first saw The Snow Goose during the Christmas holidays in 1971 and it has remained the most moving film I have ever been privileged enough to watch. Everything about the film is as near perfection as it is possible to get. Richard Harris gives a masterful performance as Philip Rhayader and the young and incredibly beautiful (then and now) Jenny Agutter matches him scene for scene with a maturity beyond her years. I have a lump in my throat every time I watch it and I watch it at least once a month.

It is criminal that this film is not commercially available for generations yet unborn to revere as do all those who were fortunate enough to see it. If ever a film deserved a ten plus, this is it.

Postscript: In October 2007, almost 36 years after first watching it, I had the most memorable moment of my film viewing career when I saw a perfect version of The Snow Goose at the BFI, London, while sitting next to my friend Jenny Agutter. Tears were running down my face at the end.
33 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Wonderful Memory
jotheodorou4 November 2002
I read the short story in middle school and saw the TV version as an undergraduate. I will never forget either. Now that the late, great Richard Harris has recently passed away, won't someone look into offering this on DVD or Video? I look for it each and every Christmas on PBS. Some thirty years later, it still haunts me. It will break your heart, but is so worthy of attention.I look forward to comments from other baby boomers who remember the PBS movie. A little gem of a film.
30 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
How sad that this film cannot be seen again
jamesashford19 November 2004
This 1971 Hallmark Hall of Fame television production was a priceless gift to those viewers lucky enough to have seen it. The program was run at least twice in the '70s but is now "lost" to the public --- no VHS, no DVD. What a shame. The values that Gallico's story presents are timeless, and Richard Harris and Jenny Agutter were never better. And wrenching? I remember well a room full of adults, men and women alike, sobbing at the conclusion of the program. Folks, THAT"S what a great film is all about.

Other Hallmark productions can be seen on VHS or DVD, but not "The Snow Goose." If only Hallmark would "care enough to send the very best" back to us.
43 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
ONE OF THE MOST HEART WARMING MOVIES EVER MADE !
syzygy181820 November 2000
I saw this movie only once, when it was first broadcast close to thirty years ago. Yet it's warmth and beauty have stayed in my heart. " THE SNOW GOOSE " has the potential to become a holiday season classic if only it was shown more often. The casting is perfect and the performances are flawless. If you can locate it, rent it and be sure to watch it with the whole family. I defy you to tell me you walked away without a tear in your eye. THIS IS TRULY AN UNDISCOVERED GEM !
27 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the top 100 films of all time.
allisonmckinley18 March 2004
Warning: Spoilers
The Snow Goose

Often the first name that comes to mind when one thinks of mushy greeting cards, Hallmark is a veteran producer of classic films. For instance, look for a release this year of Homer Hickam's (author of October Sky/Rocket Boys) Sky of Stone.

I was not even born when this film version of Paul Gallico's The Snow Goose first appeared on the BBC in 1971, and it is only through my Uncle's affiliation with the Post Office that I was able to secure a copy of this film much later (British television comes under the supervision of the General Post Office).

This is an award-winning made-for-TV movie that affected me like no other, a black and white film set in the dismal east-coast marshes of Essex in the late 1930s.

There are only two characters, really: a misshapen, scraggly, dark-haired man who had taken up residence in an abandoned lighthouse from whence even the sea had retreated, and a smudgy-faced waif from the nearby Saxon oyster-fishing hamlet of Wickaeldroth.

In what I consider to be his best film role ever--though I am sure a younger generation will forever remember him as Albus Dumbledore in the Harry Potter films--a very young Richard Harris takes on the personality of Gallico's dark hero Philip Rhayader, assisted by a young Jenny Agutter as Frith.

We learn that Mr. Rhayader, a painter, has come to this desolate lighthouse to escape pity and the uncomfortable reactions that his physical deformities seem to engender. At 27 years of age, he buys the lighthouse and the land around it to be his haven from commerce with others, and creates a small artist's studio and a sanctuary for wounded fowl.

One day, he detects a small form approaching on the sea wall. His visitor is a young girl from the nearby village, and as she draws near, he sees that she carries a bird which has been shot by the fowlers in a nearby marsh.

I said earlier that there are only two characters of any import in this story, but there is indeed a third if we count the wayward Canadian snow goose who has miraculously survived a terrible storm. Blown nearly three thousand miles off her migratory course, upon her weary approach to the marshes, she is greeted by a shot from a hunter's gun.

Rhayader tells the apprehensive girl, Frith, that this bird comes all the way from Canada, so he calls the snow goose La Princesse Perdue, the lost princess. Frith begins to visit the recovering bird regularly, but once it has healed and flies off in response to its migratory instinct, her visits cease. It is then with even greater loneliness and sadness that Rhayader awaits the fall, which signals the return of the snow goose and his curious female visitor. Meanwhile, he recedes again into his sequestered life, only seeing the world twice a month when he deftly sails his boat to the village of Chelmbury for supplies.

Seasons pass and Frith grows to be a young woman, La Princesse Perdue returns every fall, and war continues to scar the face of Europe. One day, the government calls upon every able-bodied man on the east coast of England who owns a tug, a fishing boat or a power-launch, to sail to Dunkirk and save an army of British soldiers who are trapped on the beach, awaiting destruction at the hands of the advancing German army. When Frith comes to visit, she finds Rhayader in his boat, ready to sail across the channel to do what he can to help, a gleam in his eye at the challenge that awaits him. It is at this point that Frith becomes aware of the feelings that have grown in her heart for this man, and she offers to go with him.

To say more would indeed spoil this film, or should I say the story. Unfortunately, even though Paul Gallico wrote the screenplay for this classic, he stipulated in his will that the movie should never again be screened, so sure was he that the message he wished to convey was to be found in the 53 pages of his novelette of the same name. Few films created in the century since the dawn of the moving-picture medium deserve a perfect ten. This is one of them.

Reviewer's Note: This film is based upon the actual event known as `Operation Dynamo'. June 2, 2004, marks the 64rd anniversary of the evacuation at Dunkirk, wherein 338,000 stranded men were shuttled to safety by a flotilla of rag-tag vessels that would have been an embarrassment to McHale's Navy.
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A lovely, yet heartbreaking film
Aldanoli4 July 1999
A simple, beautifully-filmed story about a reclusive, hunchbacked lighthouse keeper (Richard Harris) and an orphaned girl (Jenny Agutter, whose beauty shines through her masculine clothing) brought together by an injured snow goose. The story is played out against the backdrop of early Second World War England, but the primary story is about these two outcasts and how their friendship, and their care for the goose, allows them to overcome the pain the rest of the world has inflicted on them. Tragic, unforgettable, yet never mawkish, and never a false note.
25 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Acclaimed tv special
HotToastyRag12 March 2022
Grunged up with a big beard, a hunchback, and an amputated arm, Richard Harris stars in the acclaimed television special The Snow Goose. He's a lonely lighthouse keeper who prefers the company of birds and animals to his neighbors. One day, he meets a young girl, Jenny Agutter, at the same time a bird has been wounded. Jenny cares about the bird, and he takes them both back to his house to heal its wing. There starts a beautiful friendship.

It's a short movie, and it easily could have been expanded with more character development or story, but it does manage to span a few years as Jenny grows up and WWII starts. If you really love Richard Harris, you can watch it, but I don't think it stands the time very well. It probably had an interesting message for those who lived through WWII and remembered how everyone came together and fought for their country. But now, when the human race doesn't have the same selfless character, it will probably leave most people shrugging in apathy.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An exceptional production mysteriously withheld from the public by Paul Gallico.
Fannygirl25 November 2002
Those of us who were fortunate to have seen this made-for-television production from the Hallmark Hall of Fame have never forgotten it and continue to hope that someone, somehow will find a way to make it available on DVD or video. My understanding is that Mr. Gallico specified in his Will that it was not to be made commercially available, but why he would do such a thing is beyond me! He wrote both the book and the screenplay and the final product was an exquisite use of the medium. Richard Harris has never given a better performance in his career, indeed, all the fuss about his appearance in the Harry Potter movies only reminds me that this wonderful performance is virtually unknown to most people. It is not an exaggeration to say that you cannot watch this film and come away unmoved.
22 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the most beautiful films ever made
jazerbini4 June 2017
When I read Paul Gallico's short story in 1966 in a Reader's Digest book publication, I concluded that I was facing one of the most beautiful stories I had ever read. I was 17 years old and now 68 years old, I'm just as sure. I've read hundreds of books, watched hundreds of other movies, but The Snow Goose remains not only the most beautiful story I've ever read, but also one of the most thrilling movies I've seen. It's a difficult story to shoot, as it revolves around a bird almost impossible to control, but the footage is perfect, preserving everything Paul Gallico has dreamed up. Some small parts of the film are different from the book, but we have to admit that for the transposition of a book into the cinema or TV, some adjustments are necessary. It only lacked in the end the destruction of the lighthouse by a German bomber. But it's a wonderful movie. Richard Harris and Jenny Agutter are perfect in their roles of Phillip Rhayader and Frith. For some reason I still can not identify, this story and this film touches me deeply. It is very difficult to contain the tears in the moments of affection between the goose, Rhayader and Frith, and when the goose departs to the North or when it returns. The greater emotion is due to the decision of the goose to accompany Rhayader in the small boat, facing the danger of the battles in the rescue of the wounded soldiers. It is something unprecedented and of unprecedented grandeur, and even at this very moment when I write this commentary, tears flow from my eyes. It's a wonderful story and the film retains the same atmosphere as the book. They are perfect: book and film. I only regret the lack of the film in the commercial market, I have already searched extensively for a DVD and never found it. I watch the movie often on YouTube, it's the only solution. But it is gratifying to watch it, it is good for the soul
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Le MASTERPIECE perdue
vironpride3 April 2006
I have always associated The Snow Goose with Christmas, as I believe one of the few times I saw it was at this time. Unfortunately, this was before the VCR came along, so it is now lost to me and everyone else who was lucky enough to have seen this masterpiece. I have read the story upon which it is based, and one of the few changes was that the injured snow goose was named, by Philip, "Le Princesse Perdue," or "The Lost Princess." In the film she is called by Frith (Jenny Agutter), "Fritha," after herself. The casting could not have been better. I must admit that I have never liked Richard Harris, but I make a very big exception here. He is brilliant beyond description, as is Jenny Agutter. I remember reading that the story caused quite a bit of controversy when it first came out, as some people thought it was unfitting for a "normal" girl to have a (you know what kind of) relationship with a deformed man. This was not stressed in the film, as I recall. In any case, the end is just heart-wrenching. Please, please, whoever has control of this gem, make it available again to all of us who remember it, and to those who will fall in love with it as we have!
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A recluse and young girl befriend a snowgoose. WW2 based drama
N-P-Roberts29 May 2006
I watched this heart breaking film as a callow youth and was enchanted by it. Since the film is so rare, read the book. (It's a novella and you can read it in an evening) The film was a BBC and Hallmark joint venture and was an acclaimed success. Therefore the BBC has never repeated it and Hallmark, who has the rights apparently, have never considered re-releasing it. Considering the rubbish around today this is a little mystifying. Richard Harris plays the hunchback, Phillip Ryader brilliantly. The young Jenny Agutter nicely underplays the part of the girl leaving as much unsaid as stated. These two damaged, shy people are thrown together in their common cause to look after a wounded snowgoose. Time passes and their relationship grows but events impinge on their world as Europe descends into war. How will these events affect them? Have the hankies ready....
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Lovely, haunting film
vsdennis28 October 2002
What a gorgeous movie, and a perfect adaptation of Paul Gallico's classic. I haven't seen it for 30 years, and was about 10 years old when I did see it -- but 30 years later, I still remember it and have the occasional "brain flash" of a scene in the movie. This is one that should be offered on video/DVD.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"The Snow Goose" is a movie with real heart!
dude-3531 April 2008
This was my very favorite movie as a young kid. It had something to do with making me a lifelong bird watcher. Awesome movie.

It is a beautiful story to share with children. It has a strong message about tenderness, love and appreciation for all God's creation. I have found that there are many of us out there who still remember this film. I hope someday Hallmark can settle the legal issues with the author's estate so they can release this on DVD for future generations to love.

Watching Richard Harris in this is a real lesson in acting. Wow, it's one of his best roles I think. And the scenery along the Essex coast is haunting and beautiful.

One note: Lots of people are looking for a copy of this, but they are hard to find. I just got a copy of this movie dubbed from an old video tape someone made when it aired on TV. Here is not the place to give you all the details. Go to the message boards under the thread "I have The Snow Goose" for details.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Fantastic Movie- watched it when first released
andrewbutler-28 February 2009
The movie has left an indelible mark on my psyche… it was emotionally moving with a riveting story line, and wonderfully acted with high drama without being undermined by special effects; superb acting by Richard Harris.

I would suggest that it is a great movie for every age and it does provide a great insight into the second world war- the time and events.

There are some movies that do not date themselves nor are dated through lack of being topical or relevant-this is one such movie.

Having watched it when it was first released and finding many years later still having an impact on me, I can't help feel that this movie needs to be promoted and more accessible.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of the most impressive Films ever made
lohengrin7722 July 2003
It was in June 1972 when this movie was shown on German TV entitled as: Schneegans! I just found out who was the writer of the movie minutes ago after 30 years! I had absolutely no idea who made the movie and in which country it was produced. My god the picture had such a great impact on my little soul, I was just 4 years old, and was watching it with my mother, that until now this movie is the most important in my life! Not only did my mother mention it in her diary, as we both were crying and I just could not recover after the movie, so exciting was this picture, but now I found out, that Rhayader was played by Richard Harris, one of my most favourite actors! This Picture is so full of true love, mystery and devotion, it makes a human being very sensitive for the relationship of humans and animals, that I recommend this picture to all teachers as a lesson on this terms.If a BBC Official is reading this, please reconsider the Will of Gallico and try to obtain the rights for a reissue on DVD (with the Screenplay as a Bonus!) As this movie was not repeated in our Country either (to my knowledge!) since it first aired and after reading all this similar entries I m sure he would reconsider it himself.
21 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tear Jerker
Tom81817 June 2001
When I first saw this movie I was only 10 years old. There was not a dry eye in the house by the time this movie ended. It was another 20 years before I saw it again one afternoon on PBS. It was tough to get through it...it had a very sad ending. However, this is a very well-made movie and worth watching. The acting and directing was incredible. I would like to see this movie released on VHS or DVD...still waiting for that. Although this movie is sad it has a strong message of love and caring. Definitely a classic (rarely seen).
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
the snow goose, a revelation!
mjtretton8 November 2006
The Snow Goose is one of the most moving films about the relationships between birds and man ever made. The film was made on the Blackwater in Essex, at the sea wall near and around Osea Road,( which leads to Osea Island). My wife's family owned a caravan close to where the film would have been shot since the 1950's, and my wife grew up spending a lot of her childhood in the area that the film so beautifully depicts. We no longer own a caravan there but would love to see the film again.The atmosphere in the film reflects the magic of the Blackwater. The honking geese are still part of the landscape,although the snow goose would be a very rare visitor. All the cast portray the essence of the local people and make them real.Please help us to see this wonderful film again.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Story of an innocent young girl and a crippled lighthouse keeper, wildlife and Dunkirk
BrianTimmins10 May 2006
An absolutely superb film made from one of the greatest short stories of all time (under the same name) - by Paul Gallico. Characterisation by Richard Harris (Philip Rhayadar) and Jenny Agutter (Frith) is nothing short of outstanding, the story and its apotheosis is mind-blowing - a real three handkerchief film even though it is only one hour long. A definite must see for anyone, film buff or not. Only the most hardened of cynics will not fail to be moved - an excellent family movie. The basic outline of the story concerns a young girl who makes friends with a crippled lighthouse keeper who also is an artist and lover of wild life. She finds an injured snow goose and brings it to Rhayadar and together they nurse it back to health. The final parts of the story are about Rhayadar going off in his little boat to help with the Dunkirk evacuation...
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of my most memorable films--a great loss?
mbimdb122 May 2004
I personally saw this film and count it as one of my favorites, if not most memorable ones, for all the reasons cited in previous comments. It is a great loss, to one time frequent filmgoers and serious 'buffs' such as I, that it is not commercially available since it is truly a cinematic work of art. I have sought its availability ever since videos were produced after I saw it (a couple of times) at the Musee de Cinema in Brussels, Belgium, where I went to school abroad in the early '70s. I don't know if the restrictions on its viewing include the Cinematheque there, but, since the facility is a center for film preservation and art and a film school and not for general public 'commercial' viewing per se, it may still be shown every couple of years or so, especially when they do specific monthly festivals, tributes or memoria to individual film celebrities/masters at memorable times of their deaths, anniversaries of their deaths or births, or genres: viz.Canadian films, Paul Gallico, R.Harris, J.Agutter, etc. Unfortunately, the Brussels Musee, on short staff and budget was not amenable when I last was there in the early '80s to sending out their monthly bulletins or giving easily available info. on the internet.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Maybe the Most Indelible Impression in Cinema
Snowgo23 November 2014
Like many of you (us), I saw this movie only once. This is a movie one only has to see once, so potent and impressive is it's memory. My heart comes alive as I write this, over forty years later. Being somewhat of an "outsider" or, as David Bowie put it "other-worldly person", I finally made friends with myself after watching the Snow Goose. This movie showed me that often, nobility and popularity are disparate, and that sometimes, one must choose one or the other. It showed me that a good heart is not always rewarded, but that we must continue to believe in ourselves. It showed me that if we do, after long while, there is some reciprocation. This movie is about thinking for ourselves: Developing our own code of ethics, regardless of how it is interpreted by some others. I have recalled the image of Rhyader often, whilst enduring isolation and misunderstanding by others, and have taken great solace in his patience and faith.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
All time Favorite TV movie
Akclegs19 January 2004
Though it's been years since this last aired i can still FEEL the haunting theme song and the spray of the sea - and the tears i shed watching this film! Richard Harris and Jenny Agutter are wonderful and perfect in these roles. I hope Hallmark one day will see fit to re-air it or release it in some format for purchase. I look vainly each week when the TV listings come out, just in case.

Few books are translated well on screen - this film version is a true "better than" candidate!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
World needs 'The Snow Goose' NOW
mrmoleandhisfriends15 December 2009
What a relief to find I'm not the only person on whom 'The Snow Goose' had such deep and lasting impact. It's quite simply one of the best films ever made and the importance of its availability cannot be overestimated. This is one of the few movies which can, literally, change lives, and yet seems to be the one thing unavailable. While I esteem Mr. Gallico immensely for writing such a magnificent story and screenplay (who wouldn't?), one can't help but question why he would have written the screenplay did he not wish a filmed version to be created for posterity. To the marrow of my bones I believe the re-releasing of his movie would be honouring Gallico's memory. This is honestly a sort of crusade as far as I'm concerned. It goes far beyond just wanting a copy for myself (though, of course, I do!). 'The Snow Goose' should be a gift to the world: like air, water, beauty, and grace, available to all. Perhaps if enough of us join together and petition Hallmark, the Beeb, Gallico's estate, etc., we could save this splendid creature. Individuals joining together over something worth a struggle can have remarkable results ... Just an update to let everyone know I've started a facebook group, 'Fans of The Snow Goose,' hope you'll give it a look. It's really boring now because I'm actually the only member! Sorry!
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Flash back to childhood
cchrisr2004525 August 2013
I remember reading this book in the second year (about 12 years old- 1976) at Secondary School and it was in a short story form.

It was given to us a "Character study book" to be read class, each person reading a page. Its character analysis in the story line, of two joined by a common interest, is truly beautiful and touching, even for a 12 year old. If I remember rightly, in the book, Fritha becomes a recluse too taking on where Ryhadda left off.

I am pleased to see that it is still available in its original format. I didn't realise until "wandering around" U-Tube that it had been turned in to a short serial, (I assume for TV) and apparently there is a longer film version.

Don't miss it in the book-shop or Library, as it is in small copy; it may even be in the children's' section. A lovely read, even for grown ups. Search U-Tube yourselves to find the film and serialised versions.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed