User Reviews

This episode of "The Men Who Made the Movies" is fantastic because it features Raoul Walsh telling stories to students and talking with Richard Schickel (with questions edited out) about his life and career. He had a wonderful sense of humor, a great memory, and the students enjoyed what he had to say immensely. Walsh was a director kept very busy by Warner Brothers, and his descriptions of encounters with Jack Warner are hilarious. He talks about working with Bogart, Cagney, Flynn, George Raft, and all the tricks he played on them while shooting. There is a lot of footage from "White Heat," "Gentleman Jim," "They Died with their Boots On," and also footage of Walsh as an actor playing John Wilkes Booth in a silent film. He also talks about discovering John Wayne for "The Big Trail" and picking the name Anthony Wayne for him, after a character in a book he liked.

This was an invaluable episode. I wish IMDb had the Sam Fuller segment listed - perhaps I will try to add it myself - which was also excellent and featured the flamboyant Mr. Fuller talking about his work and life. We have some fine directors today, but these rough and tumble guys were from another era, and what they have to say is priceless. Worth every second of viewing.

In 1972 and '73, film critic Richard Schickel made an 8-part series for American public television: 'The Men Who Made the Movies'. Each episode featured a prominent Hollywood director discussing his career in an on-camera monologue (actually an interview, with Schickel's questions edited out), interspersed with generous clips from his most famous films, accompanied by somewhat overwrought narration (written by Schickel and spoken by Cliff Robertson). It's regrettable that Schickel did not include Fritz Lang, William Wyler and John Ford in this series: all three were alive at the time, although Ford was quite ill.

The Raoul Walsh episode begins with some discussion of Walsh's early film career as an actor; we see a clip from D.W. Griffith's 'Birth of a Nation', in which Walsh (as John Wilkes Booth) assassinates Lincoln (played by Joseph Henabery). According to Walsh's self-deprecating commentary, he became a movie actor when a director approvingly noticed the distinctive way Walsh picked his nose! Regrettably, this documentary does not include any footage from 'Sadie Thompson', in which the handsome and athletic young Walsh reached his peak as a self-directed leading man: when Schickel made this series, the 'Sadie Thompson' negative (owned by Gloria Swanson) was partially damaged and not legally available.

Walsh discusses the incident that ended his acting career: while starring in and directing 'In Old Arizona' on location, Walsh drove his jeep towards a jackrabbit that jumped through his windscreen, shattering it. A sherd of glass destroyed Walsh's eye. Walsh wore an eyepatch for the rest of his career; tragically, he went blind in his remaining eye a few years before he died. This documentary doesn't mention the notorious confrontation between Walsh and John Ford. The one-eyed and eyepatched Walsh resented Ford, who had two eyes but affected an eyepatch to conceal the bloodshot condition of one eye.

In the footage here, Walsh describes an incident from his pre-Hollywood life, when (as an assistant to a French dentist) he accidentally killed a patient by giving him too much gas. Let me offer a theory here. The 1933 film 'One Sunday Afternoon' is about a dentist who has a chance to murder his despised rival by 'accidentally' (on purpose) giving him too much gas. Raoul Walsh did not direct the '33 'One Sunday Afternoon', but he remade it as 'The Strawberry Blonde' and then he re-remade it under its original title, as a musical! Why was Walsh so attracted to this particular story? My theory is that he felt a need to expiate some self-imposed guilt for his own unintended act of dental manslaughter.

Among many other clips from Walsh films, we see a brief clip of Marguerite Churchill and John Wayne in 'The Big Trail'. This big-budget Western was supposed to be John Wayne's breakthrough film, before Ford starred him in 'Stagecoach' ... yet it flopped, and no reason is given here for the failure. In fact, 'The Big Trail' was filmed in a very unusual aspect ratio, and most cinema managers didn't want to refit their screens to accommodate it.

All eight episodes of 'The Men Who Made the Movies' are well-made, highly entertaining and informative, although they tend to concentrate on the most well-known films of their respective subjects. The Raoul Walsh segment is especially useful, due to the fact that Walsh gave so few interviews. Towards the end of his life, in failing health and nearly blind, Walsh wrote an autobiography called 'Each Man in His Time': a poorly-written book. Unfortunately, while he was writing his memoir, Walsh refused to grant interviews to other authors, as he wanted to conserve for his own book all his best anecdotes about his life and career. And what a life and career this man had!

Despite a few flaws, I'll rate all eight episodes of 'The Men Who Made the Movies' a perfect 10 out of 10.