Number One (1976) Poster

(1976)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Hiding in the Boys' Bathroom
pjmay18 September 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This short, which really isn't short at a painful-to-watch 42 minutes, starts with two girls hiding in the boys' bathroom at their school, but slowly evolves into a huge waste of time.

The scenes with the two girls and two boys in the boys' bathroom are handled with taste and the child actors seem natural and unrehearsed. But when the first adult arrives, in the form of the school's principal, the normally pitch-perfect Allan Garfield, the film heads straight into, well, the toilet.

Subsequent scenes involve the various children being queried by their respective parents as to what transpired in the bathroom. One of the two boys is admonished by his parents as they bicker and try to force him to eat his dinner of liver and potatoes. This scene is far too long -- the point is obvious after a few minutes -- and is punctuated by Dyan Cannon's voice off-screen as the child's mother.

At 20 minutes, the film would have been worth seeing. At 42 minutes, you'll be looking for an exit 15 minutes in.

Ms. Cannon recently appeared at the AMPAS and told the audience the master print of the film was destroyed by a fire at her home. As a result of the fire, the film now only exists on DVD. One might want to consider tossing the DVD on a fire as well.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Serious to the point of tedium
steveklein11 March 2003
(Note: I'm rating this film 17 years after I saw it; I was 11 at the time.) I was one of several children invited to view this film at the home of Director Dyan Cannon. My main recollection is that every kid there found this to be a boring film; it is definitely not a children's film.

The plot: Childhood curiosity leads four very young boys and girls (Kindergarden age?) to expose themselves to each other in their school bathroom. They are caught by a teacher (or principal -- I can't recall), who notifies their parents. The story then shows how the different families react to the news.

It received an Oscar nomination, so perhaps it's better than my 11-year-old self judged it to be at the time. Or perhaps there was a paucity of entries for "Best Short Film, Live Action" that year.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed