Island (1989) Poster

(1989)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Captures the atmosphere, but the story is underdeveloped
PeterM2720 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This is a film of mood and enigma, that will please some and infuriate others.

The main character, Eva, played by Czech actress Eva Sitta, seems lost, having run away from the dullness of Australia and her marriage there, but unwilling to return to the Communist repression of her home country. She accepts the warm enthusiasm of the Greek artist, played by veteran Greek actress Irene Papas, while remaining a closed book, full of shy smiles and secrets. It's intriguing at first but a little tiresome by the end.

The other characters also remain somewhat underdeveloped, and we don't know much apart from their surface by the end. Although the film captures the beauty of the island, and the warmth of the villagers who care for these women, in the end the drama is slow, and sometimes confusing.

Chris Haywood, who plays a helpful Greek mute with convincing gusto, is the only major Australian presence in the film, as Norman Kaye, who plays either an Australian or an Englishman, only appears for a minute or so to mumble some inconsequential dialogue.

A major frustration with this film, as with many Paul Cox films, is the sound, as the dialogue is often muffled, too soft or drowned out by background noise.

The film leaves you with a strong impression of a rugged but beautiful island, where foreigners come for short stays to resolve their personal problems. It was a good idea, to have the three women from different cultures in an isolated place, but the characters seemed distant.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Disappointing, slow and dull.
nz man30 December 1999
When I put this video into the VCR I noticed that the previous user had not rewound the tape, and that it was not at the end - this has happened before and the movies were duds. We did not finish this movie since it was so so slow and uneventful.

This film promised to be quite good, after all it is an Australian movie filmed on a Greek island, with Irene Papas. The cinematography was very good and the acting was OK, but it was a big mistake to invest so much in the weak story. My wife did not like it either, so I don't think my comments are regarding a man not liking a woman's flick. It was just so slow and dull. Maybe we were not sensitive to the issues involved, whatever they were...
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Tenderness on a Greek Island
nbott3 February 2003
I personally found this film to be an excellent story of three women thrown together by life on a small Greek island. I was very impressed by the acting abilities of all the women and the villagers who played most of the other roles. In this regard, I was especially moved by a scene between some real villagers in their home and Eva. They were not professional actors but they were obviously wonderful people. The film is full of such wonderful moments.

I was also moved by the tender care shown to Eva by a deaf-mute handyman on the island and by the splendid understanding that developed between the three women. The ending was deeply moving.

The music and the cinematography were magnificent. I recommend this film. (8 out of 10)
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Island is a fine film ...
lofos26 April 2011
For Chris Hayward's performance, an excellent ensemble, grand cinematography and the delicacy of the story I have given this film 8/10.

It's Chris Hayward though, that makes this film for mine. His portrayal of character and the depth he applied to the role is reason enough to see this film.

Paul Cox is also an under-appreciated filmmaker in Australia. His European sensibilities with his film making see him fly underneath the radar of the usual obsession with making films that also double as tourist promos. The best Australian films are character driven and Cox is a master of his art. Island gives us an Australian story through the prism of the Greek island. Like many artists, their most accurate comments on home are usually made from afar - a place where context is everything. This also applies to the characters in this wonderful film.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed