Life and Death on the A-List (1996) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Better with the perspective of time
Havan_IronOak8 October 2018
I first saw this film in the late 90s but rated it pretty low as it was not an enjoyable film to watch.

This guy had been one of my early crushes (I'll never forget that laundry commercial with him in the elevator) and I knew of his print work for Marlboro.

The film was a well-made documentary for its time and it serves as a valuable time-capsule of that era. There is another review of this (by a family member) lamenting the mother's ignorance at the time. But, back then we didn't know and everyone went through a period of paranoia along similar lines though most gay men had passed through that phase by the time this was made.

I lost a number of friends to AIDS and though this brings back some painful memories, I'm glad I watched it again. Seen through the filter of time, it was a better documentary than I gave it credit for being.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Amazingly Eye Opening
megs354 March 2013
I guess I'm a little biased since he was my uncle, but I'm wondering where I can get a copy now. It was so powerful to watch and said a lot about the early Aids epidemic in the 90's. There weren't drugs like we had today, and it shows the stigma where those with Aids were treated like lepers and ostracized. I can remember one part where my Grandma Katy, his mother was just ignorant and didn't know any better. Can you imagine not being able to take care of your own son in his last days at your house because the other condo owners were so scared if he used the pool they'd have to drain it.

How awful to finally be educated years later when your son is gone, and live with that guilt! I know it bothered her, but we didn't know any better back then. He was such an amazing man in so many ways, despite his promiscuous lifestyle. Some of it is the dark side of the gay culture, and a lot of it in my opinion is just the feeding of the ego/addictive tendencies that run deep in our Irish Catholic family.

Regardless, I think anyone at the age of possible sexual activity should watch this documentary. It shows the heinous progression of this disease in such honesty I understand now why my parents would not let me see him in his last days. It broke my heart not to be able to say goodbye, but I still feel him around me sometimes.

The lessons in this documentary are profound, I keep finding meaning in it years later as an adult dealing with the cold side of human nature. Where even his many admirers where not there in the end to take care of him. Family was there, and that's why despite what anyone says I still believe family is the most important resource we have.

There's an unspoken obligation to get past hurt and anger to take care of each other when it's really needed. For this I am grateful. Tom came from a big family of 8 brothers and sisters and was the 5th. Fittingly in middle child style he made a name for himself, my favorite memory of him was when he would break out into show tunes in his strong Broadway style voice. It was something to see, and I'll never forget him!
20 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A film about our gay blessings & curses
mortgagesnow29 September 2003
This movie is a must see for any gay man it speaks to and from our very dark side. The documentary opens with the main character in his most golden and handsome state. He then gives you a glimpse of what it's like to be one of those gay men that are blessed with charm, manly beauty & intelligence. You see the privileges that are bestowed upon you by that ever so judgmental "Gay Foodchain" when you are one of its superstars. One also observes the MAN that seems to have it all really does not. The protagonist in the course of the film exponentially declines in health & looks. It is interesting to note that this man could have had at one point, just about ANY man he wanted yet, when he dies their is no husband / romantically loving soul by his side. The movie spoke to me in the following way. It brought to focus that the parties; the circuit and the barrage of beautiful men are our blessings as modern gay men, yet they can also be our biggest curses. The film reminds me that beauty fades and the gay male playground is only that a cold place to engage in adult pleasures. It also makes me realize the true worth of holding and being held by another man that loves & cares for me in the long term. A sobering film that is sometimes funny and sad with a subtle message to zip your pants and look for more in a partner that the perfect six pack.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Worth my time despite several drawbacks
fordraff1 July 2002
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS*** ***SPOILERS*** This 45-minute documentary details the death of Tom McBride (10/7/52-9/24/95) from AIDS. McBride was an extremely handsome guy who modeled, did commercials, and appeared in some minor plays, some TV shows, and films. He's best known for appearing in the Winston and Marlboro cigarette commercials.

This film was produced and directed by Jay Corcoran, whom I saw in "Party," one of those off-Broadway gay nudie shows in the later '90s. Corcoran is handsome, gym-buffed, hairy, and looked better naked than anyone else in the cast. Later, I saw him in the film, "All the Rage," cast to type as the gay, hairy, buffed friend to the film's leading man. He probably considers himself an A-List gay.

The A-List spoken of here is that group of gay men in large cities who are desired because of their handsomeness, their buffed body, and their celebrity, minor though that may be, but being an actor or model is definitely a plus here. In the film, Tom says he was on the Manhattan A-List for 1984-94, but he's no longer on the list--not because he has AIDS but because he talked about having it. "I have the disease, and I talked about it. I'm damaged goods. I'm wrinkled, have spots on my face. Yes, it bothers me that I'm not still on the A-List."

The documentary begins with McBride dying of AIDS. He has a progressive brain disease which results in his having seizures now and then. He has a lung disease as well, for he must use several times a day a nebulizer to deliver medicated spray to his lungs.

At the film's beginning, Tom is still a nice looking man despite AIDS and the drugs he's taking. In fact, he gets a role in a soap opera, and then fears that he may have a seizure under the stress of having to act.

The film gains its power from Tom's physical deterioration. It was stunning to see this man waste away--a guy who went to the gym seven days a week, who had a super body--turn into nothing more than a living skeleton.

At the film's end, we see Tom's family in his small Manhattan apartment. They are waiting for Tom to die. Lying in a hospital bed that takes up most of the space in the living room, Tom is now wasted to bones and paralyzed to the point where only his right arm can move a little bit. He's not even capable of speaking more than a grunt.

Unfortunately, not much Tom said impressed me. At one point, he ponders the question, "How do I get out of the darkness (meaning, I assume, the feelings? depression? he has now that he has AIDS)? Tom sits quietly for a few moments before saying, "I don't know." At another point, Tom answers the question, "What's the point to getting AIDS?" by saying, "Growing." But nothing Tom says indicates that he has grown.

He says he still thinks of all the men out there that he hasn't had. "It's just all the boys I didn't get. They're still out there." Corcoran says that he can take satisfaction in knowing about all the men he's already had. But Tom disputes that, saying no one thinks of the guys he's had, just those he hasn't.

It was hard to know whether Tom was making answers out of bravado, just to keep up a facade, because if he didn't do this, he had nothing but the horror of death to stare into.

I was left with the impression that Tom didn't understand that his entire way of life--being on the A-List--was the problem, the error, the disaster that he and far too many gay men, especially urban gay men, fall into. Although Tom doesn't seem to fully grasp this, I should imagine anyone watching the film would. One of Tom's friends says of Tom, "He was desperately looking to be loved." I wish there had been more questions exploring why Tom pursued a place on the A-List, why he thought this was important enough to build a life around.

Unfortunately, in quality this is just an amateur video. Because of the film's length, it wasn't distributed to theatres, though it did appear at some film festivals. Likewise, to the best of my knowledge, it's not been shown on television.

Despite its lack of polish, the video has its place among the documents that chronicle AIDS. I felt it was well worth my time. Not for the faint of heart, though.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed