"Play for Today" Scully's New Year's Eve (TV Episode 1978) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Hiding Their Light Under a Bushel
JamesHitchcock11 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Alan Bleasdale first created the character of Francis Scully, a rebellious Liverpool teenager, to entertain his pupils while he was working as a teacher. (The name may have been chosen because of its similarity to "scally", Liverpudlian dialect for a young rogue or rascal). Scully became the hero of a series of short stories broadcast on BBC Radio Merseyside; this play, first broadcast as part of the BBC's "Play for Today" series, marked his first appearance on television.

When I was growing up in Kent in the sixties and seventies, Christmas was always the be-all and end-all of the festive season. My family always spent time on the 31st of December with my grandparents, but only because it was my grandfather's birthday. Like many other families in Southern England we never did much to celebrate the New Year itself, an attitude which always puzzled my mother who had grown up in the North where New Year was always an important family celebration, if not quite as important as it was in Scotland. The play centres upon a Northern New Year's Eve family gathering.

Scully and his mate Mooey want to go out and celebrate, but Scully's formidable mother has other ideas, insisting that he spend the evening at the party she has organised for her family, friends and neighbours. (The one relative who has not been invited is Scully's father, from whom she is estranged). Scully is not, however, the only member of the family who is less than enthusiastic about socialising with his nearest and dearest. His eldest brother Henry would rather play with his train set and middle brother Tony's one great obsession is with watching his favourite movie, "High Noon", which is being broadcast that evening.

When the guests begin to arrive we soon realise just why Scully and his brothers were so keen to avoid them; those who are not terminally dull seem terminally weird. The play has something in common with Mike Leigh's "Abigail's Party", which had been broadcast on "Play for Today" two months earlier. Both plays deal with a social gathering which starts off politely enough, but as time passes the strained relationships and hidden resentments become more and more apparent, and in both cases the evening ends in sudden tragedy. One difference between the plays is the social milieu in which they are set. Several of the characters in "Abigail's Party", especially Beverly, are from a working-class background but have aspirations towards what they see as a more genteel middle-class lifestyle. The characters in "Scully's New Year's Eve" are all more straightforwardly working-class.

This is the second of Bleasdale's television plays which I have watched in recent weeks, the other being "The Black Stuff". Both show his talent for characterisation and for writing dialogue which is both credible and entertaining. When I reviewed "The Black Stuff" I described it as a very sharp, bleakly funny black comedy. The same could be said of "Scully's New Year's Eve" except that here the comedy has an even bleaker ending. I understand that this play has not been shown by the BBC for many years. The Beeb really ought to make more use of their treasury of excellent drama rather than hiding their light under a bushel. 8/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
New Year Mersey Blues - Excellent Rarely Seen TV Comedy Drama
ninjaalexs18 December 2022
I've watched a slew of arguably bad Euro-Horror and dull Arthouse drama this month and it's so refreshing to watch something which can tell a carefully crafted story in 70 minutes with the emphasis on good scripting, acting and characterisation rather than special effects, gore and ambiguity.

Scully's New Year's Eve is about a seemingly dull NYE party taking in a place in a modest working class home in Liverpool. We are introduced to Scully a 16 year old boy who wants to go to a "real party" with his dim-witted mate, Mooey. Scully's older brothers would be classed as Man-Children; Henry who hides in the loft playing with an electric train set and Tony who ignores his girlfriend to watch a TV broadcast of High Noon (this is before most people had a VHS players in their homes). For me the two stand out performances were Jane Freeman as the lady of the house and John Junkin as Jack; a father of a disabled child with an overbearing wife who keeps him under the thumb - being a comedian he brings a sadness to the role - "I'm 48, I'm a big boy and I want to run away from home again". A surprise appearance by Mick Miller who cracks jokes and says he is a comedian in clubs, but often dies - one of many ironic jokes. The main irony of the play being the pathos of adult characters who act like children.

The scenario is one anyone can relate to. Anyone who has had to put up with relatives they don't like, anyone who has been a teenager and felt trapped under their parent's supervision, anyone who feels they should be having fun at a party, but felt miserable.

The film was successful enough to have a spin-off TV series commissioned called Scully. Sadly, Scully's New Year's Eve isn't as widely available and is rarely repeated on TV or streaming services possibly partly due to music clearance. It is excellent and shows what a good script and acting can achieve while still being surprising and profound. It's also a real shame that most dramas the BBC puts out now are either historical dramas, crime or dramedys (that are neither funny or dramatic) rather than slice of life dramas with relatable characters and scenarios. It's also better than Abigail's Party which it suffers comparisons to.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed