(TV Series)

(1989)

User Reviews

Review this title
16 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Superb! Much better than the available movies.
Curtis-2323 September 1999
Most of the actors were unfamiliar to me, but they were outstanding. P.J. Brown as Joe has a rich, bass voice, quite able to withstand the inevitable comparisons with Paul Robeson's performance in the 1936 movie. Playing Queenie, Joe's wife, Ellia English outdoes her famous 1936 counterpart (Hattie McDaniel) as both actress and singer.

Rebecca Baxter as Magnolia Hawks has a lovely soprano and a youthful appearance persuasively close to Magnolia's 19 years. She is also a marvelous dancer, with great legs, which she shows to advantage, playing Magnolia's daughter in 1920s costume. Shelly Burch as Julie La Verne looks and sounds right for the character when she speaks, but I thought her singing voice too high and coloratura-like for the role.

One advantage of this production is that it has enough time (over 2.5 hours) to emphasize an aspect of the operetta that abridged versions scant. The action occurs at four different times: 1887 on the southern Mississippi River, 1892 in Chicago at the World's Fair, 1900 in Chicago at the Trocade ro night club, and 1927 back on the Mississippi. This production, aided by foundation money, gorged itself in the fancy-dress styles of these four different eras.

Richard White as Gaylord Ravenal looks just fine as a charming gentleman and obsessive gambler. He has a rich baritone, which works well most of the time. Unfortunately, the part is written for very high baritone or tenor. The only place that this really creates a problem is in the duet, "You Are Love" (the romantic climax of the play), which requires Ravenal to spend some time at F and G above middle C. At those times both he and I were uncomfortable.

Lee Roy Reams and Lenore Nemetz, the show's principal dancers, were given plenty of time for their numbers, which they performed with great skill and elan. Eddie Bracken, whom I had seen before, but not since the 1940s, was a splendid Cap'n Andy. He is listed at the top of the credits and deserves that spot. He can take command of the stage when appropriate, as when he pantomimes a fight between hero and villain, or orchestrates Magnolia's triumph at the Trocadero. Marsha Bagwell is funny and deft as the wife who commands Cap'n Andy on every occasion but the important ones.

What a shame that, so far as I know, this tape has never been available for purchase! My comments are based on a PBS broadcast I recorded in 1989.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best Showboat production I have seen.
jcwolff-131 March 2007
I taped the PBS presentation of the Paper Mill production of Showboat way back when it was presented and I can say without reservation that it is the best production of this classic musical I have seen, better than any on Broadway and especially better than both movie versions. All the cast was excellent, particularly Ellie English as Queenie and P.L. Brown as Joe, Shelly Burch as Julie, Richard White as Gaylord, Rebecca Baxter as Magnolia and Eddie Bracken as Captain Andy. Their change of character from the 1880s to the 1920s was very well done. A real show stopper was the number "Ah Still Suits Me" done by Ellie English and P.L. Brown. Left out of the movies, I appreciated that it was retained and done so well in the Paper Mill production. I no longer have that old VCR that I taped, and am hoping that they will come out with a DVD of it. I would buy it immediately.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The definitive production, one for the ages
luannjim25 June 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Let me make one thing clear right off the bat: I yield to no one in my admiration for the 1936 version of SHOW BOAT. It's one of the great movie musicals, and in getting the unforgettable performances of Paul Robeson, Helen Morgan and Charles Winninger on film, producer Carl Laemmle Jr. and director James Whale did a service to posterity that future generations will be grateful for for centuries to come.

However, it was the nature of film-making in 1936, as in 1951 when MGM did their glossy remake, that the show had to be cut down to size to fit the medium. As much as I love the 1936 and like the 1951 versions, I never really understood what the big deal was about SHOW BOAT -- not until I saw this Paper Mill Playhouse production on Great Performances in 1989.

Here is SHOW BOAT restored to its lavishness of production and the epic sweep of its story. Like the original production, this one takes us through 40 years, from 1887 to the "present day" (i.e., 1927) -- from the post-Civil War South through the Chicago World's Fair of 1893 and the dawn of the ragtime era to the Charleston-dancing Jazz Age. It gives us the changing face of show business seen through the lives of the people who work in it, and the effects of time (and "the times") on four marriages: Magnolia and Gaylord, Capt. Andy and Parthy, Steve and Julie, and Queenie and Joe.

Performances are uniformly excellent. Is P.L. Brown Paul Robeson, or Shelly Burch Helen Morgan? Well, no, of course not -- but who is? Still, their performances are first-rate, both vocally and dramatically. Eddie Bracken was born to play Capt. Andy; it's a pity, perhaps, that he didn't do it 20 years earlier, but here, at 74, he still has the presence and energy the part calls for. Rebecca Baxter has probably the most demanding role in the show, aging from her teens to her 50s (plus, in this production, playing Magnolia's grown daughter Kim), and she's truly affecting; I dare anyone to sit dry-eyed through the scene where Magnolia learns that Gay has run out on her. Richard White as Gaylord, Ellia English as Queenie, Lee Roy Reams as Frank, Lenora Nemetz as Ellie, Marsha Bagwell as Parthy -- all are wonderful and can hardly be improved upon. The same goes for the huge chorus, whose vocal power on such songs as "Ol' Man River" and "Can't Help Lovin' That Man" is often thrilling. Add to this the excitement of seeing them all performing live, without prerecording, before a large and enthusiastic audience.

SHOW BOAT is the greatest work in the history of the American musical, and while most productions don't do the show justice (the less said about Harold Prince's dismal revival the better), this one proves it. It really is a shame that this truly great performance has never been issued on video or DVD (it's not too late; how about it, Paper Mill and PBS?). But those of us who had the foresight to tape the broadcast in 1989 have a SHOW BOAT for the ages, one we can enjoy and cherish to the end of our days.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A PBS Broadcast of a revival of the 1927 Musical Comedy Play
tobornot2wew82c16 April 2003
Taped during a repeat broadcast of the Paper Mill Playhouse, New Jersey production of "ShowBoat" based upon Edna Ferber's 1926 Novel.

Before obtaining this copy, we had never seen the film versions from 1929, 1936 and 1951 (In 1940, my parents took me to see the 1936 version on the big screen but I spent most of the time hiding under my seat - some scenes, especially those showing cotton bales being loaded, frightened me. I did, however retain some of the songs.) So, we had nothing with which to compare the Paper Mill stage production. Our fortuitous VHS copy inspired us to try to find a CD to help us remember the music. We wound up with a copy of the Angel/EMI CD; which is a symphonic version of this popular score. Only recently have we been able to see the 1936 Film Version; again, we caught a showing on Turner Classic Movies (TCM).

IMPRESSIONS - Paper Mill Playhouse

We had a great time staying up late to monitor the production; it provided us with some laughs and brought us to tears, the ending was a happy one as required by Theatrical Comedy. The Paper Mill Playhouse did not have the budget nor the space on the stage for a huge cast. We have viewed this tape several times and we have noticed the same actress working different parts in several scenes. Well, she was from a small troupe in a small town.

COMPARISONS - to 1926 Book and 1936 Movie and 1988 CD Recording

The adaptation compresses the adventures of many of Edna Ferber's characters between 1888 to 1927. Some roles from the book are changed in time and place, even switched from one of Ferber's to another person. All to suit the occasion and the size of the theatre.

The 1936 film deleted a favorite song: "Life on the Wicked Stage" but added another couple we had never heard. Also, to reduce the running time, some song repeats were deleted.

The 1988 CD is a reconstruction of the December 1927 Opening Night score.

BOTTOM LINE

Having lived with the Paper Mill Playhouse production, having read the Book, listened to the CD and seen the 1936 Film; I think that any one of them is still a lot of fun. Regardless of the exact selections of songs, the score is fun to hear, the songs set the toes to tapping and are easy to remember. I think the varied casting does nothing to change what is an excellent story. The same goes for the variations in staging. To me it doesn't matter what I am hearing or seeing, the story of "ShowBoat" transcends all and I like them all.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Jersey's Pride and Joy
EveySK22 September 2002
I first saw the Papermill Playhouse of Show Boat on PBS when I was 4 years old and I still watch my old worn out copy of the original broadcast and I get the chills. It's the greatest version of Show Boat that is out there. Being from New Jersey, I have gone to the Papermill Playhouse to see other performances, but Show Boat is still what they are most famous for. All the original still photographs are still hanging in the theater lobby. Many of the Show Boat performances still perform at the theater and are still complemented on their Show Boat performances even though it was first performed in 1984. Even after repeated viewings it still gives me the chills. Ol' Man River has the most soul in this version and you're heart just breaks when Joe sings it as Julie and Steve leave the Cotton Blossom. Can't Help Lovin' Dat Man has the most energy and the girls dancing is on target. All the songs are intact and sung with such emotion that the viewer is feeling what the characters are. This is the best version out there, but unfortunatly even Papermill has lost track of a copy. If anyone knows if this is available to buy or even the soundtrack please post any information. There is a reason IMDB users have rated this version so high.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Terrific version of classic musical
FDAVIDM28 July 2005
This is one of the best cast versions of this work albeit mostly excellent Broadway performers that are largely unknown outside of New York. In addition, it incorporates songs from the movie versions of this work that up until the time this production was filmed were never used in stage presentations. These extra songs nicely flesh out the Black characters in the work and prevent them from becoming stereotypes.

This version should be available for purchase on DVD and tape but is not due to the estates of the dead owners of this work. The copyright to this work has been convoluted for years (to say the least) and the lawyers representing R&H, Kern, and Edna Ferber are a greedy lot who are always hoping for a better deal to come along with a new production. IT's not going to happen and they should just let PBS release their version before technology begins to make it look to old to be released.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent, complete adaptation
jj-8728 June 1999
One of the best filmed versions of Show Boat (the other is the visually stunning 1951 film, but it consolidates a lot of plot, dropping songs along the way and relegating the black characters to minor roles) taken direct from the stage at Paper Mill Playhouse. By the time the third generation is introduced at the finale, you have felt the passage of many years and the weighty effects time can have on people's lives and perspectives....ole man river just keeps rollin along!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Great Production
efisch30 July 2012
This is a truly great production of a truly great musical. If you ever wondered why Showboat is so famous this production will show you why. If you're only experience is the splashy (but flat) 1951 film version, or even the much better 1936 version, get ready for a revelation. This show is moving and sincerely and beautifully performed. I just finished watching my 1989 tape of the broadcast, which unfortunately is grainy but in stereo which I transferred to a DVD. But the sincerity and exuberance of the performances shine right through. I wish someone would put this out on a professional DVD (along with Crazy For You) but there are probably copyright or ownership problems. PBS and the Paley TV museum probably have a copy. It is memorable and probably the best version of Show Boat you'll see and that this great show deserves.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A perfect record of a practically perfect show.
mark.waltz28 January 2015
Warning: Spoilers
While the 1936 movie is as near to perfection as Hollywood ever got on this old chestnut, this PBS production of the Paper Mill 1988 revival gives the audience a chance to see how "Show Boat" might have looked to audiences when they first saw it. Of course, the Paper Mill Playhouse stage is not nearly as some of the Broadway theaters who have presented Edna Ferber's classic drama, hauntingly attached to Jerome Kern's brilliant music and Oscar Hammerstein II's profound words. The 1990's revival was declared as lavish as any production of "Show Boat" could ever hope to be, and friends of mine who saw the 1966 Lincoln Center production also declared it a great event. Photos of the original production and a 1947 revival also are gloriously lavish, so the slightly more scaled down Paper Mill production isn't a spectacle, yet intimate and possibly more touching.

With a cast lead by veteran movie comic Eddie Bracken ("Hail the Conquering Hero", "The Miracle of Morgan's Creek"), this production is sweet, funny (if a bit dated at times) and emotionally raw. Shelley Burch really makes you feel Julie Laverne's pain, singing "Can't Help Lovin' Dat Man" with both joy and a knowing sorrow, and "Bill" with all the anguish that Helen Morgan performed it with in the 1936 version. Yes, this glorious soap star ("One Life to Live's" vixen turned heroine Delilah Ralston) really has a pair of pipes that you won't soon forget. The gregarious Ellia English is an automatic scene-stealer as Queenie, given a few big production numbers, especially several key moments in "Can't Help Lovin'..." and a glorious call to passer-bys to buy tickets to the show. Later, she has a romantic duet with the aging Joe (the touching P.L. Brown) who has survived memories of "Old Man River" and been a faithful partner to his very loving wife.

Naggie Parthy is played with bombastic imperiousness by the intimidating Marsha Bagwell, a veteran character actress whose operatic voice has been heard much in touring productions of musicals. I saw her as Dominia in "A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum" opposite Mickey Rooney many years ago, and she has the right knack for making head-strong women like Parthy and Dominia extremely funny and often touching. Rebecca Baxter and Richard White give memorable performances as Magnolia and Gaylord, singing their all with the romantic duets. This isn't at all edited like the 1951 MGM remake was (making it seem like a shell of itself even with the glorious Technicolor) and features all the wonderful choral numbers cut out of the film versions.

My only qualm about this version was the comic intrusion of two hillbillies who intimidate Lee Roy Reems' Frank when they confront him to buy tickets (with confederate money, of course) and later when he appears on stage, both as the villain in the play within the play and during his number with Ellie (a perky Lenora Nemetz). Yes, it's nice to see what the entire show appeared to be in 1927, and I am plenty aware that 88 year old comedy might seem unfunny, dated or goofy in 2015. But this sequence was rather uncomfortable to watch, too forced to be funny, and too unrealistic to seem even remotely possible. But in spite of that, this is a great production, well worth seeing, even if you've seen it on stage dozens of times or happen to be in your late 90's and saw it on Broadway when you were a kid.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent, complete adaptation
jj-8728 June 1999
One of the best filmed versions of Show Boat (the other is the visually stunning 1951 film, but this film consolidates a lot of plot dropping songs along the way and relegating the black characters to minor roles) taken direct from the stage at Paper Mill Playhouse. By the time the third generation is introduced at the finale, you have felt the passage of many years and the weighty effects time can have on people's lives and perspectives....ale man river just keeps rollin along!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Despite its "completeness", a severe disappointment
critic-218 December 2001
I have seen "Show Boat" both on stage and on film. I saw this 1989 production when it originally aired, and again when it was rerun. I have not seen it since, but I do have a strong remembrance of it, because "Show Boat" is my favorite musical, and in this case I was severely disappointed.I am glad I never taped it, because overall it is among the worst productions of the musical I have ever seen. I simply cannot understand the rave reviews for it.

It is true that, being a taped production of a stage performance, it is far more complete than the filmed versions of "Show Boat"--an hour longer than those in fact. And yes, you do get to hear much more of the score, but when it is as indifferently performed as it is here, so what? Richard White does have a reasonably good voice as Ravenal, as does Rebecca Baxter as Magnolia, but they do not erase memories of any other Ravenal and Magnolia with their singing. Neither, for that matter, do soap opera star Shelly Burch (especially bad as Julie), and most crushingly of all, P.L. Brown as Joe, whose "Ol' Man River" is a distinct disappointment. He has one of those voices in which the singer seems to be making an effort to hit the notes without getting too wobbly--his voice sounds downright unattractive at first, and only later does he manage to bring out some beauty in it. After hearing Paul Robeson and William Warfield perform "Ol' Man River" so memorably, as well as Michel Bell (from the 1994 Harold Prince revival) on various specials and talk shows, Brown's version is a near-total letdown.

Most of the acting here is enough to make the indifferently acted 1951 film version of "Show Boat" seem like one of the Royal Shakespeare Company's greatest triumphs, and as for the unforgettable 1936 "Show Boat", this 1989 TV production demonstrates that there quite possibly might never be a "Show Boat" to match that one. Shelly Burch hams it up unmercifully and blubbers all over the place during her confrontation with the sheriff (unlike other Julies who manage to keep their dignity intact in the face of such horrendous circumstances). Richard White gives an acceptable but unremarkable acting performance as Ravenal, and Rebecca Baxter is unbearably sweet as Magnolia. Her shrill acting in Act I as the eighteen-year-old Magnolia is so overdone it has to be seen to be believed. Marsha Bagwell is just a loud caricature as Parthy, and Lenore Nemetz and Lee Roy Reams create absolutely no impression as Ellie and Frank.

Oddly enough, P.L. Brown's acting as Joe is better than his singing. Ellia English is an acceptable Queenie. But the one actor who rises to the occasion, and enacts a truly memorable Cap'n Andy, is Eddie Bracken--yes, the same whiny, irritating nerd from all those 1940's films. He gives the kind of subtle, three-dimensional performance that one never would have dreamt he was capable of giving, both compassionate and funny.

Robert Johanson's direction is nothing special; he is just merely content to get the production going from one scene to another, and he apparently either has no talent for bringing out the intense drama in the story without stopping his actors from toppling over into hamminess, or doesn't realize that they *are* getting hammy. The orchestrations used in the production have been culled from several productions (mostly the 1946 revival), but the best ones have not been used (the rather slushy 1946 orchestration of "Ol' Man River" is used, rather than its hauntingly delicate 1927 original orchestration).

The only thing this production of "Show Boat" demonstrates is that more is not necessarily better; the 1936 and 1951 films, with all their omissions and abridgements, are far better done than this production is. Let's hope that one day the Harold Prince production will someday make it to television.

AN UPDATE: Not long ago, I was able to see this production again via YouTube, and it was exactly as I had remembered it, so my opinion of it has still not changed. It doesn't hold a candle to either the 1936 or the 1951 film versions of "Show Boat".
4 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great Performance of a Marvelous Show!
edwinphoenix27 April 2013
Well, the only way I have seen this is from a DVD copy an online correspondent sent me. I have the feeling that it has gone through several generations as it is quite grainy, but the performances are just great. I suppose I did not know about it being on, the first time it was given, or I would have taped it. I do not think it was ever available commercially, for whatever reason. I surely wish I could obtain a clearer copy. Last night "Carousel" was on, in a concert version, "Live From Lincoln Center," and it was just great. Now I have a DVD recorder, so of course I made a DVD of it for myself. Be alert, folks, as often this is the only way to obtain some of these shows. Too bad Papermill Playhouse (or PBS) cannot offer some of their shows on DVD - money would be made for everyone involved! Ed Rogers edwinphoenix@aol.com
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Special Place In My Heart
dgz7825 April 2006
I know there is at least one commentator on this production that did not care for it, but in my heart this will always get a 10 out of 10. When this first aired on PBS, I taped it to watch with my then 4 year old daughter. We watched the tape so often we wore it out and it was this production that made her a lover of classic Broadway musicals. Now we never miss a live production of Showboat, Sound of Music, Oklahoma, My Fair Lady, The Music Man, Guys & Dolls, The King and I, etc. I'm sure if we had not watched this performance she would have become an aficionado of the classics (2 of her favorite CD are Who's Next and What's Going On so you know she has good taste) but it sure helped.

As for this performance, I repeat what I said about the MGM Keel/Grayson version; it is hard to do a great version of Showboat and impossible to do a poor version. Impossible because the songs are so great that even poorly performed versions contain the magic of Kern and Hammerstein. I don't know if there is another first act I would ever want to watch or hear. And this version (unlike the MGM version) contains my favorite back to back to back numbers of any musical (Make Believe; Ol' Man River & Can't Help Lovin' Dat Man).

A great version of Showboat is hard because you have to have people that are good enough to play Gay and 'Nola as bad actors thrust into the show and still have the vocal range to sing the score.

The best thing about this performance (besides the score) is Eddie Bracken. He's my favorite Captain Andy and strikes the right balance needed to deal with Parthy and making sure the show goes on. My favorite Bracken performance remains Norval in The Miracle of Morgan's Creek but this is close.

I'm also glad they did not change the lyrics to meet current sensibilities. Ferber did not write Showboat for our current PC society.

The other performers remind me of other solid stage performers that are out there trying to make it big. They enable us to buy into the story and perform the score very well. P.L. Brown is no Paul Robeson but still does a great job as Joe.

I really wish this would be released on DVD (some of my taxes went to PBS and why won't they listen to me?). Since it is unlikely to ever be released get the 3 CD Frederica Von Stade version to listen to and watch any of the movie versions when they show up on TCM. And if you have a chance to see a live stage performance of Showboat, you should definitely get tickets. And thanks to the Paper Mill Playhouse and Great Performances for giving a father and a daughter a special bond.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best one of them all. It's on you tube!!
rlzank27 October 2020
Search for showboat papermill playhouse in New Jersey.

Looking for a DVD of it.

had one on video tape years ago and still looking for it ever since we all switched to digital
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
LOVED IT !!!
sweetadditions-hot12 November 2003
Warning: Spoilers
Having seen this particular version of Showboat when it first aired on PBS back in 1989 I was able to watch it numerous times as they were offering it as an incentive for membership ( for good reason ). Each time I caught it, I was mesmerized by the whole production. It was performed in front of a live audience complete with a revolving stage and an over-all "dinner theater within a dinner theater" effect was achieved. I can only compare it with the original 1936 movie version since I just watched that for the first time last night and was pleasantly surprised that this "live" version was quite true to it. My husband had only seen the 1950's movie so I actually clued him in on some things. I highly recommend getting a hold of this version for the sake of the similarities but also ( spoiler ? ) the addition of 2 songs not found in the 1936 movie. I know the songs are on one of the soundtracks ( possibly the 1950's Howard Keel version )so that alone should make this worth your while.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Help
leslieyoung-1364519 September 2018
I'm having trouble actually knowing how to watch the movie...tried Amazon to 😟
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed