Éternel conflit (1948) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Just A Gigolo
writers_reign7 October 2009
Warning: Spoilers
If there actually is a downside - apart from perhaps eye-strain - to reading thousands of books and watching thousands of films it may well be a tendency that can approach the status of an affliction to find links between given titles. Back around the middle of the twentieth century there was a short-lived vogue for the compendium or portmanteau film, i.e. one comprising three or more separate segments. Often - but not always, Easy Money, for example - the segments were the work of a single writer, Fox, for example, filmed five stories by O'Henry, Ophuls three by de Maupassant etc and in England between 1948 and 1951 no less than ten stories by Somerset Maugham were adapted into three (Quarter, Trio, Encore) portmanteau films. In the last of these, Encore, one of the stories was Gigolo and Gigolette and was set in a cabaret in the South of France where nightly for the delectation of the patrons a young woman would ascend a ladder, climb onto a small platform from which she would plunge perhaps a hundred feet or so into what from her perspective appeared to be little more than a tub full of water. The main thrust of the story was the strain the woman's increasing terror inflicted on her relationship with her partner who was faced with nothing more daunting than looking good in a tux, announcing the dive and counting the take. In Eternal Conflit Fernand Ledoux starts off as a schoolteacher who prefers to speak his mind rather than feeding les enfants the party line. He shares his home with his wife and mother in law neither of whom are exactly a barrel of laughs. Some years previously the couple had lost their daughter and after revealing to his wife that she actually took her own life Ledoux lights out for the circus where he becomes a clown and befriends a young woman (Annabella) who dives nightly from a high platform into a pool of water. As long as we're talking links how about this: Just as the movies were finding their voice Emil Jannings, a mannered actor at the best of times, played, in a film entitled The Blue Angel, a respected and respectable professor who would up wearing big shoes and a red nose. Once again there was a woman involved, in this case not a daughter but a love object in the shape of Marlene Dietrich. So there's nothing new under the sun. The transition is hazy at best, it's just possible that I didn't catch the dialogue where Ledoux says to his wife and mother in law, 'I've had it up to here so I'm running away to join the circus'. Possible but somehow I doubt it. This director was not a guy to let shaky transitions bother him. Though Ledoux likes Annabella and tries to straighten her out she in turn vacillates between the attentions of Clifton Webblookalike Michel Sadou and cad Michel Auclair, neither worth the powder to blow him to hell. Another curio but definitely worth a look.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sirkus
dbdumonteil4 July 2009
The first fifteen minutes of the movie are very strong,with a pessimism to rival the best of Duvivier.Ledoux masterfully portrays an aging teacher who lost his dear little girl a long time ago and who is sick and tired of his spouse and of his mother-in-law who dreamed the child was in Heaven.The moment when the teacher explains to his wife that it was not an accident (she actually took her own life) climaxes the movie.There's also the extraordinary scene in which he teaches his students about Napoleon in a school where they all line up to the sound of a drum roll: in front of an inspector,he refuses to praise the French emperor and he tells the boys about the death of million men Bonaparte's dreams caused.Then there's the meeting with a young girl on the bridge which brings back sad memories.

Probably fed up with teaching what the history books tell,and probably fired,the teacher becomes a clown,which does not make a big difference:both the clown and the teacher work/play in front of an audience ,but at least the clown makes them laugh.

Things begin to deteriorate beyond that point,and Fernand Ledoux's performance remains the only thing that keeps on grabbing you.Not that Annabella ,Michel Auclair and Louis Salou are bad actors: on the contrary they can be brilliant when they are given strong roles.The problem lies in the fact that ,after a (too) brilliant start,the movie loses steam considerably.

A beautiful girl works in the same circus as the ex-teacher ;he has become her confidant .She's got two lovers ,a young handsome artist of the circus and a middle -age aristocrat and she does not know where she stands anymore.Sorry to write this ,but Annabella's melodramatic-and a bit boring- story is irrelevant in Ledoux's tragic word.Maybe Douglas Sirk could have avoided the gap between the two plots.Lampin couldn't. The love triangle is a hackneyed subject and it takes genius to renew it.

Opinions differ:I know that a French oldies specialist,Marc A.,will disagree.

Like this ? try these...

La Foire Aux Chimères ,Pierre Chenal 1946 La Vie D'Un Honnête Homme Sacha Guitry 1952
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed