Death in Venice (TV Movie 1990) Poster

(1990 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Very well sung and a very good interesting production on the whole
TheLittleSongbird3 August 2012
Death in Venice is not my favourite Britten opera, partly because I am more familiar with works like Peter Grimes, Albert Herring and Turn of the Screw, but as with any Britten opera(that is if you like his music) it is worth a listen. I found this Glyndebourne production very good on the whole. Is it perfect? No, I personally found that the costumes and sets in the opening scenes could have been more imaginative, Alan Opie's Elderly Fop is like Truman Capote come back to life, and I wasn't entirely sure whether it worked. The sound quality is also a little boxy at this point, and some of the staging a little compact even on Glyndebourne's small stage. However, once Aschenbach is in Venice the production values largely improve and the sound gives more atmosphere. The orchestral playing is strong, and the conducting becomes more and more confident as the performance progresses. The staging has some interesting touches, the dancing is superb, the idea to have Tadzio not look directly as Aschenbach but look in his direction was a moving touch and Robert Tear's softer and more embarrassed exclamation of I love you was a nice change from it being the more insistent way. The performances are wonderful, Gerald Finley and Christopher Ventris would give better performances later on, Finley as Figaro and Oppenheimer and Ventris as Parsifal, but it was a pleasure to see them towards the start of their careers and seeing their potential before their rise to fame. Robert Tear gives a very involved and moving portrayal of Aschenbach, his voice not the most beautiful but nobly used. Michael Chance is a commanding Apollo and sings with a strong tone. But the production belongs to Alan Opie, who is in magisterial voice and gives each of his multiple roles a distinct personality, of note he is hilarious as the Traveller and he is the very definition of the Hotel Manager from Hell. All in all, well sung, interestingly staged and very good on the whole. The opening scenes and boxy sound are a little disappointing compared to the rest, but a vast majority of the production makes it a worthy one in regard to Britten's work. 8/10 Bethany Cox
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Betraying is no game
Dr_Coulardeau5 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This production is disappointing because the singers do not know how to act and they are as stiff as sticks, or they are under-directed. The singing itself is very confusing because of a mashed up English that makes most of the singing difficult to follow and this DVD does not have English subtitles. So you are trapped. And yet it has subtitles in other languages. In other words it is an old VHS recording that has been set on DVD without any re-mastering.

The meaning of the original novella or opera is twisted out of proportion. Tadzio is shown as a real tease that is more or less running after Gustav von Aschenbach who is not shown at all as being caught up by the cholera that is running loose in Venice. He is not shown as sick but he is shown as let's say slightly aroused and that goes against the meaning of the words.

I could easily accept even a pornographic production of this opera but then it should be clearly said that it is "after" Benjamin Britten's work and not Benjamin Britten's opera per se. In other words this production makes me sad because a major opera has been kind of slightly and maybe even slyly betrayed.

It is just fair to watch it not to be unaware of this early production, especially since many other productions, not available on DVD, have gone even a lot farther in this betrayal.

Dr Jacques COULARDEAU
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed